A19178:21
A reply to Dr. Mortons general Defence of three nocent [sic] ceremonies viz. the…A reply to Dr. Mortons generall Defence of three nocent [sic] ceremonies viz. the…
A reply to Dr. Mortons general Defence of three nocent [sic] ceremonies viz. the surplice, cross in baptism, and kneeling at the receiving of the sacramental elements of bread and wine.A reply to Dr. Mortons generall Defence of three nocent [sic] ceremonies viz. the surplice, crosse in baptisme, and kneeling at the receiving of the sacramentall elements of bread and wine.
Amsterdam: printed by Giles Thorp, 1622
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
In the second Epistle to the Non-conformists, many things are jumbled together, which afterward must be examined, but here cannot. For this Epistle taketh the whole book for unanswerable, and therefore should rather have been set at the end then at the beginning: only one ridiculous piece of Rhetoric is to be touched, wherein (forsooth) ⟨image 5⟩the Non-conformists above all their other faults wherewith they are usually charged and loaded, are now as it were lovingly entreated to acknowledge themselves guilty of superstition. The reason is rendered, because there is a negative superstition, the formal cause whereof is the forbearing and forbidding of things lawful as unholy and profane: and the Non-conformists have such negative opinions, as kneel not, cross not, wear not, &c.
In the second Epistle to the Non-conformists, manie things are jumbled together, which afterward must be examined, but here cannot. For this Epistle taketh the whole book for unanswerable, and therefore should rather haue been set at the end then at the beginning: one•ie one ridiculous piece of Rhetorick is to be touched, wherein (forsooth) ⟨image 5⟩the Non-conformists aboue all their other faults wherewith they are usuallie charged and loaded, are now as it were lovinglie intreated to acknowledge themselues guiltie of superstition. The reason is rendred, because there is a negatiue superstition, the formall cause whereof is the forbearing and forbidding of things lawfull as unholy and profane: and the Non-conformists haue such negatiue opinions, as kneel not, cross not, weare not, &c.
All this is nothing else but a trick of prevention usual with crafty men, who choose to lay that upon their adversaries which they know more properly to belong unto themselves. But I would that this Defendant, or rather Accusant, had given us some plain reason of his new opinion, there is no definition of superstition, properly so called, that will father this conclusion. The Schoolmen do with one consent place superstition in a kind of excess of Religions worship, Thom. 2. 2. q. 92. art. 1, from whom in this point our Divines do not dissent. Now though this excess do seem sometimes to consist in a negation, yet […] excess or error in negation, is never called by any author that ever writ (I dare say) superstition, when he meaneth to speak properly, except that very negation, abstinence or forbearing be held as a special worship. Now in the Non-conformists there is no such thing to be found: they do not abstain from these Ceremonies, but as they do from other unlawful corruptions. Suppose they err, yet every erroneous denial of things lawful is not superstition.