A19884:757
An apologetical reply to a book called an answer to the unjust complaint of VV.B. Also an answer to Mr. I.D. touching his report of some passages. His allegation of Scriptures against the baptising of some kind of infants. His protestation about the publishing of his writings. By John Davenport BD.An apologeticall reply to a booke called an ansvver to the unjust complaint of VV.B. Also an answer to Mr. I.D. touching his report of some passages. His allegation of Scriptures against the baptising of some kind of infants. His protestation about the publishing of his wrightings. By Iohn Davenporte BD.
Rotterdam: printed by Isaac van Waesberghe, 1636Rotterdam: printed by Isaack van Waesberghe, 1636
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The usefulness of the Eldership in the Church being considered, with the Honour which the Holy Ghost putteth upon those who are called thereunto, should warn all men to take heed of contemning them, or occasioning others to despise them.
THe usefullnes of the Eldership in the Church being considered, with the Honour which the Holy Ghoast putteth upon those who are called thereunto, should warne all men to take heed of contemning them, or occasioning others to dispise them.
First.1 Their usefulness appeareth in that the Holy Ghost directed Paul and Barnabas to ordain Elders by voices in every ⟨p. 208⟩Church. Which text Mr. Nowell in this Catechism allegeth to show that there were in the well ordered Churches certain Seniors chosen, and joined with the Pastor, and thereby he would show that the Pastor should not excommunicate alone, without the judgement of the Church. This place being so understood, we may from hence note two things to declare the usefulness of such officers.2 1. that they were appointed to every Church. 2. That they were solemnly ordained, being commended to the Lord with prayer and fasting; which is not used in slight matters. It appeareth also in that they are joined, by the wisdom of God with other officers of as necessary use in the Church, as the members are in the body, 1 Cor. 12.28.
First.1 Their usefullnes appeareth in that the Holy Ghoast directed Paul and Barnabas to ordaine Elders by voyces in every ⟨p. 208⟩Church. Which text Mr. Nowell in this Catechisme alleadgeth to shew that there were in the well ordered Churches certaine Seniors chosen, and joyned with the Pastor, and thereby he would shew that the Pastor should not excommunicate alone, without the judgement of the Church. This place being so understood, we may from hence noate two things to declare the usefullnes of such officers.2 1. that they were appoynted to every Church. 2. That they were solemnly ordayned, being commended to the Lord with prayer and fasting; which is not used in slight matters. It appeareth also in that they are joyned, by the wisdom of God with other officers of as necessary use in the Church, as the members are in the body, 1 Cor. 12.28.
Secondly. The Honour which the Holy Ghost putteth upon them, is very great, as appeareth, first, in their employments, which are honourable services, as, to assist the Pastor, 1. In admonishing offenders. 2. In imposition of hands at the ordaining of officers. 3. in consulting and counselling about Church affairs, the Apostles refused not their help herein, and this use of them continued (as Ambrose saith) till it was altered by the sloth, or rather pride of Teachers, who would seem to be some body, by doing all things alone. 2. In the titles wherewith he honoureth them being thus employed, calling them(a) Leaders, (b)Presidents, (c)Overseers, (d)Governments. 3. In the qualifications required to be in them, viz. to be such as do the duty of their place in the fear of the Lord, faithfully and with a perfect heart, wise, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, blameless. In a word, they must not be destitute of any good property, whereby they may be fitted to rule well. 4. In the carriage which the Holy Ghost enjoineth the people to use towards them, in their well discharging their duty. As, to acknowledge them, and to esteem them very highly in love, to account them worthy of double honour. And to obey them.
Secondly. The Honour which the Holy Ghoast putteth upon them, is very great, as appeareth, first, in their imployments, which are honourable services, as, to assist the Pastor, 1. In admonishing offenders. 2. In imposition of hands at the ordaining of officers. 3. in consulting and counsailing about Church affaires, the Apostles refused not their helpe herein, and this use of them continued (as Ambrose sayth) till it was altered by the sloath, or rather pride of Teachers, who would seeme to be some body, by doing all things alone. 2. In the titles wherewith he honoureth them being thus imployed, calling them(a) Leaders, (b)Presidents, (c)
Now then, if any man shall despise this office, as of no necessary use in the Church of God, or, if any shall go about, by disparaging speeches, to disable them from doing the work of their place, or to discourage and dishearten them in it, by a needles, though true, publishing their imperfections, much more, if the reports be untrue, and mere ungrounded reproaches, ⟨p. 209⟩the injury is, not only personal to the men, but public and common to the whole Church, which is much blemished, either for want of it officers, or for want of care to make a good choice, and to see that they discharge their duty as they aught, and much disordered, whilst those, who should be admonished by them, are now armed against them, as men branded with a mark of partiality, and insufficiency, and disorderly walking; and that by their Pastor, and in print.
Now then, if any man shall despise this office, as of no necessary use in the Church of God, or, if any shall goe about, by disparadging speeches, to disable them from doing the worke of their place, or to discourage and dishearten them in it, by a needles, though true, publishing their imperfections, much more, if the reports be untrue, and mere ungrounded reproaches, ⟨p. 209⟩the injury is, not only personall to the men, but publick and common to the wholl Church, which is much blemished, either for want of it officers, or for want of care to make a good choyse, and to see that they discharge their duety as they aught, and much disordered, whilest those, who should be admonished by them, are now armed against them, as men branded with a marke of partiality, and insufficiency, and disorderly walking; and that by their Pastor, and in print.
In which respect (for the prevention of such dangerous consequences or effects) it will be worth the while that we examine this second complaint concerning his slighting the Elders, which I will briefly dispatch, insisting principally upon those things which he calleth me to examine by mentioning my name, which he writeth at length, as his manner is, least else (it may be) the Reader should forget that I am the mark he shooteth at, thorough all these.
In which respect (for the prevention of such dangerous consequences or effects) it will be worth the while that we examine this second complaint concerning his slighting the Elders, which I will breifely dispatch, insisting principally upon those things which he calleth me to examine by mentioning my name, which he wrighteth at length, as his manner is, least else (it may be) the Reader should forget that I am the marke he shooteth at, thorough all these.
If it be a slander, it must needs be unjust: for no slander can be just. Yea; if it be a slander, it is a very great one: for it is not against a private, but a public person, a preacher of the Gospel, and their Pastor, and that, not whispered in the ears of one, but published to the view of many. But, if it be true; the Answerers sin is double: 1, that he gave just cause of this complaint, in a case, not of private, but of public injury, by depriving of his flock, not of civill, but of spiritual liberties, to the violation of that order which Christ hath settled in the Church; 2. That he unjustly chargeth them with a slander, and so maketh himself guilty of calling good evil, yea, of the same sin, whereof he accuseth them, viz, slander.
If it be a slander, it must needs be unjust: for no slander can be just. Yea; if it be a slander, it is a very great one: for it is not against a private, but a publick person, a preacher of the Gospell, and their Pastor, and that, not whispered in the eares of one, but published to the view of many. But, if it be true; the Answerers sinne is double: 1, that he gave just cause of this complaint, in a case, not of private, but of publick injury, by depriving of his flock, not of civill, but of spirituall liberties, to the violation of that order which Christ hath setled in the Church; 2. That he unjustly chargeth them with a slander, and so maketh himselfe guilty of calling good evill, yea, of the same sinne, whereof he accuseth them, viz, slander.
For the more clear and full understanding and judging of what is said, on both sides, it must be observed that the first three pretended answers are mere evasions and diversions of the Reader from the matter of the Complaint. For,
For the more cleare and full understanding and judging of what is sayd, on both sides, it must be observed that the first three pretended answers are mere evasions and diversions of the Reader from the matter of the Complaint. For,
First, They do not complain of those decisions and determinations which have been made by most voices in the Eldership, but of those which have been hindered and rejected by him: nor of his giving sentence by his authority alone, but of his rejecting the authority ⟨p. 210⟩of the Eldership, and interposing the authority of the Classis to hinder their proceeding in things which might have been ended amongst themselves: nor that, those resolutions which have been concluded in Consistory, have been transacted without consent of most, but that some considerable conclusions, which most have agreed upon, have been by him rejected, without sufficient cause. So that, unless he can acquit himself of rejecting those determinations, which have been made by most voices in the Elderships, and of hindering their proceeding in things which might have been ended amongst themselves, and that, without sufficient cause; the complaint appeareth to be just, in this particular, and no slander.
First, They doe not complaine of those decissions and determinations which have bene made by most voyces in the Eldership, but of those which have bene hindred and rejected by him: nor of his giving sentence by his authority alone, but of his rejecting the authority ⟨p. 210⟩of the Eldership, and interposing the authority of the Classis to hinder their proceeding in things which might have bene ended amongst themselves: nor that, those resolutions which have bene concluded in Consistory, have bene transacted without consent of most, but that some considerable conclusions, which most have agreed upon, have bene by him rejected, without sufficient cause. So that, unlesse he can acquitt himselfe of rejecting those determinations, which have bene made by most voices in the Elderships, and of hindring their proceeding in things which might have bene ended amongst themselves, and that, without sufficient cause; the complaint appeareth to be just, in this particular, and no slander.
Secondly. They do not complain of his opposing, contradicting, or rejecting their opinions and counsels, when they were against right, and truth, or hurtful to the Church, or to any member thereof, but, when matters have been agreeable to truth, and right, and for the good of the Church, upon unjust pretences of the Elders insufficiency and partiality, as in the cases instanced by them.
Secondly. They doe not complaine of his opposing, contradicting, or rejecting their opinions and counsailes, when they were against right, and truth, or hurtfull to the Church, or to any member thereof, but, when matters have bene agreeable to truth, and right, and for the good of the Church, upon unjust pretences of the Elders insufficiency and partiality, as in the cases instanced by them.
Thirdly. They do not complain of his rejecting the counsel of the Elders only by showing his particular judgment, as one Deacon may oppose the opinion of another in their own session, or as in a Senate Civill, or Ecclesiastical, there may be difference, and so opposition of opinions amongst men; without rejecting such conclusions as are made by most voices in things lawful and equal; but of this they complain, that he so opposeth and rejecteth their power, in some cases, that he unjustly depriveth them of their power, upon untrue pretences of their partiality, and insufficiency to judge.
Thirdly. They doe not complaine of his rejecting the counsaile of the Elders only by shewing his particular judgment, as one Deacon may oppose the opinion of another in their owne session, or as in a Senat Civill, or Ecclesiasticall, there may be difference, and so opposition of opinions amongst men; without rejecting such conclusions as are made by most voyces in things lawfull and aequall; but of this they complaine, that he so opposeth and rejecteth their power, in some cases, that he unjustly depriveth them of their power, upon untrue pretences of their partiality, and insufficiency to judge.
Fourthly. In his fourth answer, his accusing the Elders of partiality & insufficiency is propounded by him, but the grounds thereof, or the proofs of it are not declared, and so, upon the matter, just nothing is said.
Fourthly. In his fourth answer, his accusing the Elders of partiality & insufficiency is propounded by him, but the grounds thereof, or the proofes of it are not declared, and so, upon the matter, just nothing is sayd.
Fifthly. In his fifth answer, he pretendeth just cause of his excepting against three of the Elders, as partial, in this controversy about me. And to make this cable strong, he twisteth three causes, as cords, together, that they profess themselves to be of ⟨p. 211⟩the same opinion with me touching baptism. Ans. 2. that they have, by their example, allowed and countenanced the meeting of diverse, at a private exercise, upon the Lords day, after the Sermons were ended. 3. that they made an act for my preaching amongst themselves, as an assistant, for a certain time &c.
Fifthly. In his fifth answer, he pretendeth just cause of his excepting against three of the Elders, as partiall, in this controversy about me. And to make this cable strong, he twisteth three causes, as cords, together, that they professe themselves to be of ⟨p. 211⟩the same opinion with me touching baptisme. Ans. 2. that they have, by their example, allowed and countenanced the meeting of diverse, at a private excercise, upon the Lords day, after the Sermons were ended. 3. that they made an act for my preaching amongst themselues, as an assistant, for a certaine time &c.
These are new crimes, which former ages have not heard of, Reply. and after times will wonder at, if all things be considered.