Reply. It is true that I so wrote, and that which I wrote herein is true. Let us now see what he answereth. He saith, what wise man is there that sees not the strange folly and vanity of such assertions as these? Junius was a wise man, and yet he saw no folly, nor vanity, nor strangeness in a like assertion, and so was Bogerman who relates it roundly, and without hesitancy from him, in these words.1 Servus mandatum Domini sui referens ad conservum suum obligat illius conscientiam instrumentali ministerio suo, at cognitioni suae, aut foro suo minimè obligat. Hoc nunquam Dominus quisquam daturus, nunquam fervus fidelis assumpturus. i. e. A servant relating the command of his Lord to his fellow servant bindeth his conscience by his instrumental ministry (that is, as I conceive it, so far as he reporteth the Lords mind and command) but doeth not bind him to his own outward jurisdiction. This no Lord will ever give, nor any faithful servant assume. But, did not they assume this, and more, when they would bind me to rest in that writing, and to be accountable to them for my conformity to it, not having convinced or instructed me, that it was the will of our Lord that I should do so? Also Dr. Whittaker was a wise man,2 & yet he saw no folly, nor vanity, nor strangeness in a like assertion. For, speaking of the definitions of Councils concerning matters to be believed, or to be done, he showeth, that to define a thing, signifieth, either 1. to declare what we are to believe & do, upon the authority of the Scripture, because the Scripture teacheth, ⟨p. 272⟩that it aught to be so believed and done, and that therefore they that believe or do otherwise, are in an error. 2. or else it signifieth to appoint and prescribe, by their own authority, what we are to believe or do, so as men must rest in it, whatsoever reason they have against it, and may not believe or do otherwise. The first he alloweth, and so did I, and desired nothing else but to understand some rule from the word warranting me to do that, whereunto they, in that writing, would have bound me. The second way of defining he denieth to belong to any Council, and affirmeth that it appertaineth only to God, and to Christ, and to the Holy Ghost.
Reply. Jt is true that I so wrote, and that which I wrote herein is true. Let us now see what he answereth. He sayth, what wise man is there that sees not the strange folly and vanity of such assertions as these? Iunius was a wise man, and yet he saw no folly, nor vanity, nor strangenes in a like assertion, and so was Bogerman who relates it roundly, and without haesitancy from him, in these words.1 Servus mandatum Domini sui referens ad conservum suum obligat illius conscientiam instrumentali ministerio suo, at cognitioni suae, aut foro suo minimè obligat. Hoc nunquam Dominus quisquam daturus, nunquam fervus fidelis assumpturus. i. e. A servant relating the command of his Lord to his fellow servant bindeth his conscience by his instrumentall ministry (that is, as I conceive it, so farr as he reporteth the Lords mind and command) but doeth not bind him to his owne outward jurisdiction. This no Lord will ever give, nor any faithfull servant assume. But, did not they assume this, and more, when they would bind me to rest in that wrighting, and to be accountable to them for my conformity to it, not having convinced or instructed me, that it was the will of our Lord that I should doe so? Also Dr. Whittaker was a wise man,2 & yet he saw no folly, nor vanity, nor strangenes in a like assertion. For, speaking of the definitions of Councills concerning matters to be beleived, or to be done, he sheweth, that to define a thing, signifieth, either 1. to declare what we are to beleive & doe, upō the authority of the Scripture, because the Scripture teacheth, ⟨p. 272⟩that it aught to be so beleived and done, and that therefore they that beleive or doe otherwise, are in an errour. 2. or else it signifyeth to appoynt and prescribe, by their owne authority, what we are to beleive or doe, so as men must rest in it, whatsoever reason they have against it, and may not beleive or doe otherwise. The first he alloweth, and so did I, and desired nothing else but to understand some rule from the word warranting me to doe that, whereunto they, in that wrighting, would have bound me. The second way of defining he denyeth to belong to any Councill, and affirmeth that it appertayneth onely to God, and to Christ, and to the Holy Ghost.
- 1Bogerm: Annot: in Hug: Grot ex Juni: p. 225.Bogerm: Annot: in Hug: Grot ex Iuni: p. 225.
- 2Whit. de Concil: Quest: 3. Chap. 2.Whitt. de Concil: Quest: 3. Chap. 2.