The day following, Mr. Pagett asked me, whether I would rest in the writing of the 5. Ministers? To whom I answered, the writers themselves do not require this of me, and for ought I can see it would give them content, if an order be made in consistory to put an end to this controversy. But if any marvel, why I did not rest in that writing, I will tell the reasons, for by what right could it be exacted or expected that I should rest in the writing, when first the writers themselves professed that it was but their own private judgment. Secondly this their private judgment was nakedly propounded, without any proof from the word of God, whose prerogative it is to be rested in, for its own Authority. ⟨p. 5⟩Thirdly such a subjection, is greater then may be yielded unto any counsel, whether of classis, or Synods, and where it hath been granted or suffered, it hath been the cause of many mischiefs in the Church, for thereby the writings and decrees of men are made infallible, and equal with the word of God, which is intolerable. Fourthly those reverend brethren, take the word christian more largely then I, for they account all christians which profess christian religion at the reading of the liturgy of baptism publicly, before the Church, though it be done only in one word, yea or by bowing the head or body, when they say nothing, yea some of them go so far, that they hold that the very offering of the child to Baptism, giveth it a right thereunto, though the parents be not christians, because (they say) it may be their grandfather or great grandfather were christians, and another adds (if my memory fails not) that infants are holy in the root, if they be borne where the Gospel is preached. But I take the name of christians, (in this question,) in the same sense wherein the multitude of believers in Antiochia, were called christians. Act. 11, 21, 26. So that I account them to be christians children whose parents, at least one of them, in external profession, is within the covenant. Gen. 17, 10. Faithful. Rom. 4, 11. Called. Act. 2, 39. Joined to some true Church: 1. Cor. 5.12. Because the seal of the covenant belongs only to those in the covenant:
The day following, Mr. Pagett asked me, whether I would rest in the writing of the 5. Ministers? To whome I answered, the writers themselves doe not require this of me, and for ought I can see it would give them content, if an order be made in consistory to put an ende to this controversie. But if any marvell, why I did not rest in that writing, I will tell the reasons, for by what right could it be exacted or expected that I should rest in the writing, when first the wryters themselues professed that it was but their owne privat judgment. Secondly this their private judgment was nakedly prepounded, without any proofe from the word of God, whose prerogative it is to be rested in, for its owne Authoritie. ⟨p. 5⟩Thirdly such a subjection, is greater then may bee yeilded vnto any counsell, whether of classis, or Synods, and where it hath been granted or suffered, it hath been the cause of many mischeifs in the Church, for therby the writings and decrees of men are made infallible, and equall with the word of God, which is intolerable. Fourthly those reverend brethren, take the word christian more largely then I, for they account all christians which professe christian religion at the reading of the leiturgy of baptisme publickly, before the Church, though it be done only in one word, yea or by bowing the head or body, when they say nothing, yea some of them goe so farre, that they hould that the very offering of the child to Baptisme, giveth it a right therunto, though the parents be not christians, because (they say) it may be their grandfather or great grandfather were christians, and another adds (if my memory fayles not) that infants are holy in the roote, if they be borne where the Gospell is preached. But I take the name of christians, (in this question,) in the same sence wherein the multitude of beleevers in Antiochia, were called christians. Act. 11, 21, 26. So that I account them to be christians children whose parents, at least one of them, in externall profession, is within the covenant. Gen. 17, 10. Faithfull. Rom. 4, 11. Called. Act. 2, 39. Ioyned to some true Church: 1. Cor. 5.12. Because the seale of the covenant belongs only to those in the covenant: