But a Merit as to Commutative Justice, contains in it an Implication, when spoken of God; for in plain English 'tis to say, That the Absolute Sovereign is not Absolute Sovereign: However this Notion is embraced by some Papists, who do not only •••y, That Commutative Justice is in God, but that according to the Rule of Commutative Justice man may merit of God: the which is the more absurd, as it supposes that man can give that unto God, which is of a value proportionable to Eternal Life, although Eternal Life, as 'tis to endure infinitely, includes in it somewhat of an infinite Excellency; such is the Nature of Commutative Justice as to stick to an Arithmetical proportion, in adjusting the Value of things commuted, which cannot be by man in this case, unless there were somewhat of Infinity in what he gives unto God. However, notwithstanding the ridiculousness, as well as falseness of the Notion, there are many among the Papists (if we may believe Arriaga) who assert it. 'Tis true Vasquez explodes it, with an Essay to evince that the Papists generally reject it; but Arriaga, a later Jesuit, freely rebukes Vasquez, affirming that commutative righteousness is in God, and may be found to be between God and man, and that this is generally received in the Church of Rome: for says he, This is the Opinion of Suarez, Valentia, Granadus (who introduces Medina, and Alvarez, to agree with him in this Point) Hurtado de Mendoza, Ragusa, Tannerus, and Albertinus, and Molina also; who, though he expresses himself with Caution in one place, yet elsewhere doth freely enough own it; besides Capreolus and the Thomists generally (says Arriaga) do agree with him in this; and that therefore Vasquez is greatly to be blamed for affirming, that so many were of the contrary Opinion, whereas this about Merit quoad Justitiam commutativam, has many more Authorities than Vasquez could produce for his Sense of it. In fine, Arriaga corrects Vasquez's Mistake, in saying that Hosius and Sotus were against Commutative Righteousness, and then proceeds to an Attempt of demonstrating the Truth of this Doctrine.
But a Merit as to Commutative Justice, contains in it an Implication, when spoken of God; for in plain English 'tis to say, That the Absolute Sovereign is not Absolute Sovereign: However this Notion is embraced by some Papists, who do not only •••y, That Commutative Justice is in God, but that according to the Rule of Commutative Justice man may merit of God: the which is the more absurd, as it supposes that man can give that unto God, which is of a value proportionable to Eternal Life, although Eternal Life, as 'tis to endure infinitely, includes in it somewhat of an infinite Excellency; such is the Nature of Commutative Justice as to stick to an Arithmetical proportion, in adjusting the Value of things commuted, which cannot be by man in this case, unless there were somewhat of Infinity in what he gives unto God. However, notwithstanding the ridiculousness, as well as falseness of the Notion, there are many among the Papists (if we may believe Arriaga) who assert it. 'Tis true Vasquez explodes it, with an Essay to evince that the Papists generally reject it; but Arriaga, a later Jesuit, freely rebukes Vasquez, affirming that commutative righteousness is in God, and may be found to be between God and man, and that this is generally received in the Church of Rome: for says he, This is the Opinion of Suarez, Valentia, Granadus (who introduces Medina, and Alvarez, to agree with him in this Point) Hurtado de Mendoza, Ragusa, Tannerus, and Albertinus, and Molina also; who, though he expresses himself with Caution in one place, yet elsewhere doth freely enough own it; besides Capreolus and the Thomists generally (says Arriaga) do agree with him in this; and that therefore Vasquez is greatly to be blamed for affirming, that so many were of the contrary Opinion, whereas this about Merit quoad Justitiam commutativam, has many more Authorities than Vasquez could produce for his Sence of it. In fine, Arriaga corrects Vasquez's Mistake, in saying that Hosius and Sotus were against Commutative Righteousness, and then proceeds to an Attempt of demonstrating the Truth of this Doctrine.