The great Difficulty is, How the Absolute Decree of Reprobation is consistent either with the Goodness or Righteousness of God, or those other Methods which are taken for the salvation of all men? What of Goodness is there in destinating men to eternal Misery? or what of Justice in purposing to punish them for ever without any regard to their Sin, even before any evil done? or how can the unalterable secret Decree for their damnation accord with the sincerity of God in the many Offers which are made of future Glory? 'Tis true; supposing the consideration of their fallen state as antecedent to the Decree, 'tis goodness enough that any are chosen out of the sinful Mass, and it would have been a righteous thing for God to have proceeded against all to a Sentence of Condemnation: and seeing Christ has died, and thereby satisfied Justice, and the Spirit strives, and that common Grace which is sufficient to enable men to do more towards their Salvation than they do, is offered them, and that 'tis their Sin which is the only proper cause of their denying due Subjection unto Christ, these things seem to be cleared up; only the greatest difficulty remains, to wit, How 'tis supposable that such who came pure out of the hand of God, can be considered as fallen, without some respect unto the anteceding Decree of God. What! is their Fall, on the supposition of which depends all the Discoveries of the glorious Perfections of God made unto us in the Scriptures, a mere casual hit? One would as soon think, that this curious and beautiful Fabric the World was owing only unto the casual concourse of Epicurean Atoms for its being so, as that the Glory and Beauty, the Wisdom and Harmony that shines forth most illustriously in the Christian Religion, should be only the product of Casualty or Chance; but if the Fall or Sin of man must be considered to be decreed by that God, the Purity and Holiness of whose Nature is infinite, we are as much at a plunge; so that on the whole, we see in the Decree of Reprobation somewhat Mysterious and Profound; there is in this Doctrine somewhat that may raise our greatest admiration, but can never be by vain Mortals comprehended; for what of goodness in destinating those who were in a state of Holiness and Innocency, unto Sin and Guilt?
The great Difficulty is, How the Absolute Decree of Reprobation is consistent either with the Goodness or Righteousness of God, or those other Methods which are taken for the salvation of all men? What of Goodness is there in destinating men to eternal Misery? or what of Justice in purposing to punish them for ever without any regard to their Sin, even before any evil done? or how can the unalterable secret Decree for their damnation accord with the sincerity of God in the many Offers which are made of future Glory? 'Tis true; supposing the consideration of their faln state as antecedent to the Decree, 'tis goodness enough that any are chosen out of the sinful Mass, and it would have been a righteous thing for God to have proceeded against all to a Sentence of Condemnation: and seeing Christ has died, and thereby satisfied Justice, and the Spirit strives, and that common Grace which is sufficient to enable men to do more towards their Salvation than they do, is offered them, and that 'tis their Sin which is the only proper cause of their denying due Subjection unto Christ, these things seem to be cleared up; only the greatest difficulty remains, to wit, How 'tis supposeable that such who came pure out of the hand of God, can be considered as fallen, without some respect unto the anteceding Decree of God. What! is their Fall, on the supposition of which depends all the Discoveries of the glorious Perfections of God made unto us in the Scriptures, a meer casual hit? One would assoon think, that this curious and beautiful Fabrick the World was owing only unto the casual concourse of Epicurean Atoms for its being so, as that the Glory and Beauty, the Wisdom and Harmony that shines forth most illustriously in the Christian Religion, should be only the product of Casualty or Chance; but if the Fall or Sin of man must be considered to be decreed by that God, the Purity and Holiness of whose Nature is infinite, we are as much at a plunge; so that on the whole, we see in the Decree of Reprobation somewhat Mysterious and Profound; there is in this Doctrine somewhat that may raise our greatest admiration, but can never be by vain Mortals comprehended; for what of goodness in destinating those who were in a state of Holiness and Innocency, unto Sin and Guilt?