A25467:2096
A Continuation of morning-exercise questions and cases of conscience practically resolvedA Continuation of morning-exercise questions and cases of conscience practicaly resolved
A Continuation of morning-exercise questions and cases of conscience practically resolved by sundry ministers in October, 1682.A Continuation of morning-exercise questions and cases of conscience practicaly resolved by sundry ministers in October, 1682.
London: printed by J.A. for John Dunton, 1683
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Sermon 18: Quest. How may we Graciously improve those Doctrines and Providences which transcend ou…
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
'Tis true, the moderate Dominican, such as Medina, Dominicus à Soto, and some others do in my Opinion, give the best satisfaction in the stating these Controversies; for they assert, That we must distinguish between what is Natural, and what is Moral in a sinful Action, and that the subject Matter of the Vitiosity of a sinful Action is somewhat Natural, that all the undue Modifications of it are Moral, and included in the Formality, whence they proceed to conclude, That what is merely natural in a sinful Action, is from God; a Notion no one will deny; but what is Moral and Vicious in it, or that Undueness that is the foundation of the sinful Relation (considering Sin with reference to the Law, whereof 'tis a Transgression) is from Man.
'Tis true, the moderate Dominican, such as Medina, Dominicus à Soto, and some others do in my Opinion, give the best satisfaction in the stating these Controversies; for they assert, That we must distinguish between what is Natural, and what is Moral in a sinful Action, and that the subject Matter of the Vitiosity of a sinful Action is somewhat Natural, that all the undue Modifications of it are Moral, and included in the Formality, whence they proceed to conclude, That what is meerly natural in a sinful Action, is from God; a Notion no one will deny; but what is Moral and Vicious in it, or that Undueness that is the foundation of the sinful Relation (considering Sin with reference to the Law, whereof 'tis a Transgression) is from Man.
This seems to be clear enough, only there still remains somewhat insoluble; for whoever looks well into this Controversy, will find that in the sinfulness of some Actions there is somewhat Positive; what else is the Conversion or Termination of a Natural Act on an undue Object, or the undue Determination of this Act on a due Object? It must be acknowledged, That Sin does not only result when the Act is about an undue Object, but also when about a due Object, if unduly conversant about it, e. g. In the Hatred of God, the Object of this Act is undue; but as for inordinate Love to Father or Mother, the Object of Love in this Case is not undue, but from the Intension of the Act doth the Sinfulness result; which Intension is somewhat Positive: but whether it must be considered as somewhat Natural, or as somewhat merely Moral, or Mixed, partly Natural and partly Moral, is beyond me; but if not merely Moral, it must be from God, and so God must be either the Author of Sin, or the foundation of this Relation must not be considered to be included in the Formality of Sin, that is, the intension of the Act, though inordinate and undue, is not sinful. By which it is manifest that if we consider the Controversy, there is somewhat above us in the fairest stating it, much more so in the other Accounts that are given; for as the rigid Dominicans do certainly make God the Cause of Sin, (whether culpable or not culpable, is not the Question) even so do the Scotists and Molinists; for they both include in the matter of Sin somewhat more than what is merely Natural, even somewhat that is