A26854:36
Richard Baxter his account to his dearly beloved, the inhabitants of Kidderminster, of the…
Richard Baxter his account to his dearly beloved, the inhabitants of Kidderminster, of the causes of his being forbidden by the Bishop of Worcester to preach within his diocese with the Bishop of Worcester's letter in answer thereunto : and some short animadversions upon the said bishops letter.Richard Baxter his account to his dearly beloved, the inhabitants of Kidderminster, of the causes of his being forbidden by the Bishop of Worcester to preach within his diocess with the Bishop of Worcester's letter in answer thereunto : and some short animadversions upon the said bishops letter.
London printed : s.n., 1662
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The rest which follows betrays the same weakness, because the inconveniences are urged upon a Duty to prohibit them, and his answer did charge the Command with sin in respect of such Accidents, as it was no part of the Commanders Duty to provide against. It is therefore most certain, that no one of those instances single, nor all of them jointly have any force in any measure to justify that Assertion which Mr. Baxter did maintain, and whereof he is accused.
The rest which follows betrayes the same weaknesse, because the inconveniences are urged upon a Duty to prohibit them, and his answer did charge the Command with sin in respect of such Accidents, as it was no part of the Commanders Duty to provide against. It is therefore most certain, that no one of those instances single, nor all of them jointly have any force in any measure to justifie that Assertion which Mr. Baxter did maintain, and whereof he is accused.
As for that last instance, which was (saith he) the matter of the Dispute, and which he urgeth in this manner, (Suppose it never so lawful of it self to Kneel in the reception of the Sacrament, if it be imposed by a penalty, that is incomparably beyond the proportion of the offence, that penalty is an Accident of the Command, and maketh it by Accident sinful to the Commander) he is manifestly guilty of a double falsification: First, in pretending the matter in dispute, was the imposition of kneeling at the Communion; when this very matter was expressly rejected in the very beginning of the dispute, as belonging to the Canons not the Common-Prayer-book, the lawfulness of which Canons the Commissioners had no Authority to debate, and Mr. Baxter knows, that his Argument was denied upon that ground. The second falsification is yet greater, in urging the penalty to make the ⟨p. 9⟩Command sinful, when his Answer did charge the Command with sin, without any relation to the punishment; and when the Proposition he replied to was so framed, that all unjust penalties were in terminis expressly excluded, even then I say he charged the Command of a lawful Act with sin, if it were otherwise by Accident sinful; though by the way I must not grant that the penalty imposed by the Law for not kneeling at the Receiving of the Sacrament (namely the not admitting of such as will not kneel, at the receiving of it) is incomparably greater then the offence; for the greatness of the offence in such cases, and as it stands in relation to such or such a penalty appointed for it, is not to be measured by the Quality of the Act considered in it self, but by the more or less Mischievous consequences it is likely to produce, if men be not restrained from such an Act by such a penalty; for example, when a Soldier is Hanged for stealing of a Hen, or for taking away any thing of never so little a value, without paying for it, no wise man will blame the General for such a severity; because if he did not do so, every one would take what he pleased, which would discourage the Country from bringing in provisions, and consequently the whole Army would be ruined.