A26859:154
Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries…
Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries necessary for the understanding of his accusation, II. a reply to his letter which denieth a solution, III. an answer to his printed sermon : humbly tendered, I. to himself, II. to the Right Honourable the Lord Mayor and the court of aldermen, III. to the readers of his accusation, the forum where we are accused.Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries necessary for the understanding of his accusation, II. a reply to his letter which denyeth a solution, III. an answer to his printed sermon : humbly tendred, I. to himself, II. to the Right Honourable the Lord Mayor and the court of aldermen, III. to the readers of his accusation, the forum where we are accused.
London: printed for Nevil Simmons, 1680
Letter: To the Reverend Dr. Edward Stillingfleet, Dean of St. Pauls, &c.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§. 4. But yet in so public a Cause, to be by your Accusations so loudly called to be accountable for my Doctrine and Practice, and that to the Magistrate, and to an End easily discernible; and to refuse to tender you or the Magistrate any just satisfaction, when refusing may make me and thousands more taken for Guilty, as by our (silent) Confession, and consequently the Magistrate and you to incur a far greater Guilt, if you should mistake, this seemeth to me a Crime not to be ventured on. When you have made Answering necessary, I must answer: Else I should have imitated Melanchthon, who oft boasteth how much he had profited in Philosophy, so that he could silently let Illiricus, Osiander, and such others write and talk against him. If possible, and as much as in us lieth, we should live peaceably with all Men; but when that which Men make impossible to us is no Duty, nor the want of it a Sin, though an Affliction, the Aggressor doth make Defence a Duty. And indeed I must be guilty of Scandal against you and others, if I deny you satisfaction. Either I or you live in no small Sin: Though Mr. Cheney think otherwise, your words, and many such others, show, that you take our Course to be a Sin intolerable. And if it should prove that the Sin is yours, it could not be small, not only to do what we fear would be so bad in us, but also to accuse us so publicly to Magistrates, for not forbearing to preach the Gospel when we were solemnly devoted to it; and pleading against the toleration of it, when Non-toleration must be by Imprisonment, Banishment, or Death, or such Disablement, against such as believe they are bound to preach while they are able.
§. 4. But yet in so publick a Cause, to be by your Accusations so loudly called to be accountable for my Doctrine and Practice, and that to the Magistrate, and to an End easily discernable; and to refuse to tender you or the Magistrate any just satisfaction, when refusing may make me and thousands more taken for Guilty, as by our (silent) Confession, and consequently the Magistrate and you to incur a far greater Guilt, if you should mistake, this seemeth to me a Crime not to be ventured on. When you have made Answering necessary, I must answer: Else I should have imitated Melancthon, who oft boasteth how much he had profited in Philosophy, so that he could silently let Illiricus, Osiander, and such others write and talk against him. If possible, and as much as in us lieth, we should live peaceably with all Men; but when that which Men make impossible to us is no Duty, nor the want of it a Sin, though an Affliction, the Aggressor doth make Defence a Duty. And indeed I must be guilty of Scandal against you and others, if I deny you satisfaction. Either I or you live in no small Sin: Though Mr. Cheney think otherwise, your words, and many such others, shew, that you take our Course to be a Sin intolerable. And if it should prove that the Sin is yours, it could not be small, not only to do what we fear would be so bad in us, but also to accuse us so publickly to Magistrates, for not forbearing to preach the Gospel when we were solemnly devoted to it; and pleading against the toleration of it, when Non-toleration must be by Imprisonment, Banishment, or Death, or such Disablement, against such as believe they are bound to preach while they are able.