A26859:284
Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries…
Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries necessary for the understanding of his accusation, II. a reply to his letter which denieth a solution, III. an answer to his printed sermon : humbly tendered, I. to himself, II. to the Right Honourable the Lord Mayor and the court of aldermen, III. to the readers of his accusation, the forum where we are accused.Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries necessary for the understanding of his accusation, II. a reply to his letter which denyeth a solution, III. an answer to his printed sermon : humbly tendred, I. to himself, II. to the Right Honourable the Lord Mayor and the court of aldermen, III. to the readers of his accusation, the forum where we are accused.
London: printed for Nevil Simmons, 1680
Letter: To the Reverend Dr. Edward Stillingfleet, Dean of St. Pauls, &c.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
VIII. Many English Doctors say, Rome is a true Church, as a Knave or Thief is a true man, and we separated not from It, but they cast Us out for doing our duty, and not sinning as they do. I say not as they (for as the Pope claimeth the Headship of the Church Universally, that form of Policy is not of God, and we separate from that essential form of their pretended Church:) But ad hominem if the Diocesan also be a true Church, and we cast out of it for not sinning, are We separatists, or are our Ejectors such?
VIII. Many English Doctors say, Rome is a true Church, as a Knave or Thief is a true man, and we separated not from It, but they cast Us out for doing our duty, and not sinning as they do. I say not as they (for as the Pope claimeth the Headship of the Church Universally, that form of Policy is not of God, and we separate from that essencial form of their pretended Church:) But ad hominem if the Diocesane also be a true Church, and we cast out of it for not sinning, are We separatists, or are our Ejectors such?
IX. I have showed you that the Canons Excommunicate ipso facto all that say the imposed Conformity is unlawful. If this be unjust, is it Separation to be so Excommunicated? and who is the Schismatic here? And what shall be thought of such Church-men as will first ipso facto Excommunicate us for our duty, and then, as ⟨p. 50⟩you do, call us Separatists. Would you have Excommunicate Men, Communicate with you? I (and many) do so, because you shall be the Executioners of your own sentence, and not I: But with what face can men cast Men out by Canon ipso facto, and then revile them for not coming in. You can mean no other in common sense, but that we are Schismatics or separatists because we are not of the Conformist's judgment: And that is not in our power: And you differ more in judgment in greater matters from each other; and yet call it not Schism or Separation. Yea you differ about the very essential form of your National Church, one part taking it to be the Kings supremacy, and another to be the Bishops or Clergy's Power: And therefore you cannot be truly of one National Church, that are not for one essential Form.