A26859:392
Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries…
Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries necessary for the understanding of his accusation, II. a reply to his letter which denieth a solution, III. an answer to his printed sermon : humbly tendered, I. to himself, II. to the Right Honourable the Lord Mayor and the court of aldermen, III. to the readers of his accusation, the forum where we are accused.Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries necessary for the understanding of his accusation, II. a reply to his letter which denyeth a solution, III. an answer to his printed sermon : humbly tendred, I. to himself, II. to the Right Honourable the Lord Mayor and the court of aldermen, III. to the readers of his accusation, the forum where we are accused.
London: printed for Nevil Simmons, 1680
Letter: To the Reverend Dr. Edward Stillingfleet, Dean of St. Pauls, &c.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§ 55. Pag. 33. You come to me, for denying that I separate causelessly from the Communion of true Churches, or set up Antichurches, [though (say you) they prea•• when and where it is forbidden by Law, and administer Sacraments by other Rules and after a different manner than what our Church requireth: This is not dealing with us with that fairness and ingenuity which our former brethren used—they deny the fact which is evident to all persons: For do they not the very same things and in the same manner that the others do. How comes it to be then separation in some and not in others. They are very unwilling to confess a separation because they have formerly condemned it with great severity, and yet they do the same things for which they charged others as guilty of a sinful separation.] And I am cited.
§ 55. Pag. 33. You come to me, for denying that I separate causelesly from the Communion of true Churches, or set up Antichurches, [though (say you) they prea•• when and where it is forbidden by Law, and administer Sacraments by other Rules and after a different manner than what our Church requireth: This is not dealing with us with that fairness and ingenuity which our former brethren used—they deny the fact which is evident to all persons: For do they not the very same things and in the same manner that the others do. How comes it to be then separation in some and not in others. They are very unwilling to confess a separation because they have formerly condemned it with great s••erity, and yet they do the same things for which they charged others as guilty of a sinful separation.] And I am cited.
Ans. 1. This is like H. F•wlis, The Puritans are the worst men on earth: The Papists, are far preferred before them, Because the Papists differ in fundamentals, but the Puritans take mass for a Ceremony. So we are the most disingenuous and not fair dealers, that own them to be true Churches and Ministers and hold Communion with them; and yet deny that we are Schismatics or separate: We leave you therefore, to treat with the lesser disingenuous and the fair dealers, that say you are no true Ministers, nor is it lawful to have Communion with men that openly avow such heinous sin, and covenant against ever endeavouring to reform notorious Church corruptions: because with such we are forbid even to eat, and commanded from such to turn away; Its well you have some more ingenious and fair dealers than I am.