A26859:395
Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries…
Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries necessary for the understanding of his accusation, II. a reply to his letter which denieth a solution, III. an answer to his printed sermon : humbly tendered, I. to himself, II. to the Right Honourable the Lord Mayor and the court of aldermen, III. to the readers of his accusation, the forum where we are accused.Richard Baxters answer to Dr. Edward Stillingfleet's charge of separation containing, I. some queries necessary for the understanding of his accusation, II. a reply to his letter which denyeth a solution, III. an answer to his printed sermon : humbly tendred, I. to himself, II. to the Right Honourable the Lord Mayor and the court of aldermen, III. to the readers of his accusation, the forum where we are accused.
London: printed for Nevil Simmons, 1680
Letter: To the Reverend Dr. Edward Stillingfleet, Dean of St. Pauls, &c.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. I preach (you say) when and where it is forbidden by Law.] Ans. Is this the formal reason of separation? Then disobedience and separation are all one. I suppose you mean the Law of the King and the Parliament, and not the Canons save as by them made Laws: when I had given you so many Historical instances of the ancient Bishops and Christians, doing the like, and justified commonly by the Church: did you think while you silently pass all that over, and all the rest that I said for my justification, that two lines of your saying was enough to confute all? Certainly it was not me that you meant to satisfy, nor any impartial man that had read my books. This dealing beseemeth, not so weighty a Cause. You seem to say [All preaching when and where it is forbidden by Law, is sinful separation: But, &c. I deny the Major. The Primitive Preachers did so for three hundred years: The Orthodox did so afterwards under Constantius, Valens, Theodosius junior, Anastasius, Philippicus, Justinian and many more: The Albigenses, Waldenses and Bohemians did so: The Reformers did so: The Protestants when the Interim was imposed did so: Episcopius justifieth it at large, and the Arminians in Belgia, did so: The Martyrs in England and elsewhere did so. The Jesuits in the East Indies did so. But what if the Law forbade you to preach at a certain hour—do you separate from the Church, if you miss your hour? They that Preached Afternoon Sermons when forbidden were taken for disobedient but not for separatists. And what if when the Churches here were burnt the Ministers had read the Liturgy and preached in a place forbidden by the Law: Had that been separation?
1. I preach (you say) when and where it is forbidden by Law.] Ans. Is this the formal reason of separation? Then disobedience and separation are all one. I suppose you mean the Law of the King and the Parliament, and not the Canons save as by them made Laws: when I had given you so many Historical instances of the ancient Bishops and Christians, doing the like, and justified commonly by the Church: did you think while you silently pass all that over, and all the rest that I said for my justification, that two lines of your saying was enough to confute all? Certainly it was not me that you meant to satisfie, nor any impartial man that had read my books. This dealing beseemeth, not so weighty a Cause. You seem to say [All preaching when and where it is forbidden by Law, is sinful separation: But, &c. I deny the Major. The Primitive Preachers did so for three hundred years: The Orthodox did so afterwards under Constantius, Valens, Theodosius junior, Anastasius, Philippicus, Justinian and many more: The Albigenses, Waldenses and Bohemians did so: The Reformers did so: The Protestants when the Interim was imposed did so: Episcopius justifieth it at large, and the Arminians in Belgia, did so: The Martyrs in England and elsewhere did so. The Jesuits in the East Indies did so. But what if the Law forbad you to preach at a certain hour—do you separate from the Church, if you miss your hour? They that Preacht Afternoon Sermons when forbidden were taken for disobedient but not for separatists. And what if when the Churches here were burnt the Ministers had read the Liturgy and preacht in a place forbidden by the Law: Had that been separation?