But you ask one material Question in behalf of the People, viz. Are none of our hearers more competent judges than their Accusers what profiteth their own souls? And is this in your judgment, a tolerable Plea for Separation? then there can be no such thing as an unjustifiable or sinful separation; since the people are left to be their own judges. For where was any separation made but upon such a pretence? And upon this ground the people may leave you to morrow, and go to Doctor O. and leave him next week and go to the Anabaptists, and from them to the Quakers; and still plead that they are more competent judges than their Accusers, what profiteth their own souls.1 No one would think by such Questions as these, that ever you had written so much against Separation, and spoken so freely of the mischief of it, Thus I have picked out those Queries, which come nearest to the matter of Separation, and given a sufficient Answer to them. But as to the other remaining, concerning the constituent regent part of a National Church; the One Rule mentioned by the Apostle; and whether you or I have studied longer or to better purpose, I have in civility passed them over, as no more relating to our business,2 than determining the Principle of Individuation, is, to the keeping of the sixth Commandment. And I am resolved in debate of this nature not to be drawn off by any by-Queries from the main thing in Controversy. I do not press you to any speedy Answer, but I desire you rather to weigh and consider things impartially, than to give too hasty a Reply. I am neither fond of Controversy, nor can I desert so just and clear a Cause as I take this against Separation to be; from which I shall not be moved by the noise and censures of weak and injudicious people, who I find (as you formerly observed) can least endure to be touched in this matter. If you please at your leisure to return an Answer to this paper, it shall be thankfully received by
But you ask one matterial Question in behalf of the People, viz. Are none of our hearers more competent judges than their Accusers what profiteth their own souls? And is this in your judgment, a tolerable Plea for Separation? then there can be no such thing as an unjustifiable or sinful separation; since the people are left to be their own judges. For where was any separation made but upon such a pretence? And upon this ground the people may leave you to morrow, and go to Doctor O. and leave him next week and go to the Anabaptists, and from them to the Quakers; and still plead that they are more competent judges than their Accusers, what profiteth their own souls.1 No one would think by such Questions as these, that ever you had written so much against Separation, and spoken so freely of the mischief of it, Thus I have pickt out those Queries, which come nearest to the matter of Separation, and given a suffieient Answer to them. But as to the other remaining, concerning the constituent regent part of a National Church; the One Rule mentioned by the Apostle; and whether you or I have studied longer or to better purpose, I have in civility passed them over, as no more relating to our business,2 than determining the Principle of Individuation, is, to the keeping of the sixth Commandment. And I am resolved in debate of this nature not to be drawn off by any by-Queries from the main thing in Controversie. I do not press you to any speedy Answer, but I desire you rather to weigh and consider things impartially, than to give too hasty a Reply. I am neither fond of Controversie, nor can I desert so just and clear a Cause as I take this against Separation to be; from which I shall not be moved by the noise and censures of weak and injudicious people, who I find (as you formerly observed) can least endure to be touched in this matter. If you please at your leisure to return an Answer to this paper, it shall be thankfully received by
- 1§. 17.
- 2§. 18.