A26860:331
An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlock, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical…An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlocke, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical…
An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlock, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical and monarchical, as church-tyranny and popery : and defending Dr. Isaac Barrow's treatise against it by Richard Baxter ; preparatory to a fuller treatise against such an universal sovereignty as contrary to reason, Christianity, the Protestant profession, and the Church of England, though the corrupters usurp that title.An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlocke, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical and monarchical, as church-tyranny and popery : and defending Dr. Isaac Barrow's treatise against it by Richard Baxter ; preparatory to a fuller treatise against such an universal soveraignty as contrary to reason, Christianity, the Protestant profession, and the Church of England, though the corrupters usurp that title.
London: printed for Thomas Parkhurst, 1682
Chapter 5: Wherein Mr. Dodwell's deceits, and the danger of them do consist.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And if this had been all our dispute, whether a Patriarch or Archbishop can rule a thousand Churches by a thousand Inferior Bishops, or Church-rulers, you had said something? But doth it follow that your Church Monarch can over-see them all himself without any sub-oversees, or rule them (by Gods word on the Conscience) without any sub-rulers? You appropriate the Decretory Power to your Monarch; and communicate only the executive. Hold to that. The whole Government is but Legislatio & Judicium; Legislation now we meddle not with, (yet our Bishops allow it to the Presbyters in Convocation, for they take Canons to be Church-Laws.) It is a lower power that is denied to them, that they grant the higher ⟨p. 83⟩to. Bare execution is no Government. A Hangman is no Governor. A Governor may also be Executioner, but a mere Executioner is no Governor. The People are Executioners of Excommunications, while they withdraw from the Excommunicate, and with such do not eat, &c. as 1 Cor. 5. And the Parish-Priest is an Executioner, while he (as a Crier) proclaimeth or readeth the Chancellors Excommunication in the Church, and when he denieth the Sacrament to those that he is bid deny it to. I grant you that this is Communicated. But it is the Judicial power it self which I have been proving the Bishop uncapable of. Exploration is part of the Judicial work. I know you include not that in execution (which follows it) If you did, it would be a sad office for a Bishop to sentence all men, upon other mens trial and word. As if the Bishop must Excommunicate all that some body else saith he must Excommunicate. This turneth Decreeing into a Hangman-like Execution. And the nature of the cause forbiddeth it. No man is to be Excommunicate for any other crime as such, but for Impenitence in some crime; nor to be absolved after, but upon Repentance. Now if it were, but whether a man de facto have been drunk, or fornicated, or perjured, &c. it were hard judging sententially merely on trust from others; but yet perhaps that might sometimes be done: But when the case is, Whether the man be penitent, Personal trial is necessary to a Rational and Ecclesiastical administration of the sentence. I conclude therefore, that as a King can judg by many hundred Judges, and a General command an Army by many hundred Commanders, but not without any one by himself alone, having Executioners under him.
And if this had been all our dispute, whether a Patriarch or Archbishop can rule a thousand Churches by a thousand Inferior Bishops, or Church-rulers, you had said something? But doth it follow that your Church Monarch can over-see them all himself without any sub-oversees, or rule them (by Gods word on the Conscience) without any sub-rulers? You appropriate the Decretory Power to your Monarch; and communicate only the executive. Hold to that. The whole Government is but Legislatio & Iudicium; Legislation now we meddle not with, (yet our Bishops allow it to the Presbyters in Convocation, for they take Canons to be Church-Laws.) It is a lower power that is denied to them, that they grant the higher