A26860:357
An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlock, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical…An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlocke, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical…
An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlock, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical and monarchical, as church-tyranny and popery : and defending Dr. Isaac Barrow's treatise against it by Richard Baxter ; preparatory to a fuller treatise against such an universal sovereignty as contrary to reason, Christianity, the Protestant profession, and the Church of England, though the corrupters usurp that title.An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlocke, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical and monarchical, as church-tyranny and popery : and defending Dr. Isaac Barrow's treatise against it by Richard Baxter ; preparatory to a fuller treatise against such an universal soveraignty as contrary to reason, Christianity, the Protestant profession, and the Church of England, though the corrupters usurp that title.
London: printed for Thomas Parkhurst, 1682
Chapter 5: Wherein Mr. Dodwell's deceits, and the danger of them do consist.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But if you mean that you must needs have the Magistrate to second you, as your Lictor or Executioner, and to imprison, fine, banish, burn, &c. it would be too gross hypocrisy to call the effects of this coercive power, the effects of Excommunication, and to call it coercive power to deny a man the Sacrament, because he feareth the sword. 11. De facto, there are supposed to be in the Parish that you dwell in, above 60000 souls, suppose 10000 of these yearly receive the Sacrament (though some say it is not 5000.) Are the other 40000 compelled to obedience by not communicating. 12. All those forbear your Sacrament without any sense of coercion or loss, 1. Who believe (as you do) that Sacramental Communion is a sin, where it cannot lawfully be had (that is, say you, where the Bishops forbid it; say they, where Gods Laws forbid it, by reason of adherent sin. 2. And that, take the Bishops who forbid it them to be Usurpers, that have no true calling (as all the Papists do of our Bishops, and many others.) 3. Who take it to be more eligible, yea a necessary duty to hold Communion with purer societies. 4. Besides all those Sectaries that make light of Sacraments in general. What Papists, Quakers, Anabaptist, Separatists, &c. are compelled to any good by the Bishops denying them the Sacrament? 13. Nothing but Ignorance or Impudence can deny that the difficulty of knowing whose Excommunication it is that is to be dreaded as owned by God, hath encouraged professed Christians so confusedly to Excommunicate one another, as that this Excommunication hath been so far from constraining most to repentance, that it hath made Christianity a horrid scandal to Infidels and Heathens, ⟨p. 107⟩by setting the Christian World in the odious confusion of Excommunicating one another. To give some instances how far Excommunication is not coercive. 1. Who but the Devil was the gainer of Pope Victor's Excommunicating the Asians about Easter-day? Did it compel them to obedience? 2. When the Orthodox Excommunicated the Arians, did it force them to obey? When they got almost all the Bishops for them, and Excommunicated and destroyed their Excommunicators? 3. When the Cecilians (or Orthodox) and the Donatists for so many ages Excommunicated one another, merely upon the difference which party had the true Ordained Bishops, did Excommunications force them to obedience? 4.
But if you mean that you must needs have the Magistrate to second you, as your Lictor or Executioner, and to imprison, fine, banish, burn, &c. it would be too gross hypocrisie to call the effects of this coercive power, the effects of Excommunication, and to call it coercive power to deny a man the Sacrament, because he feareth the sword. 11. De facto, there are supposed to be in the Parish that you dwell in, above 60000 souls, suppose 10000 of these yearly receive the Sacrament (though some say it is not 5000.) Are the other 40000 compelled to obedience by not communicating. 12. All those forbear your Sacrament without any sense of coercion or loss, 1. Who believe (as you do) that Sacramental Communion is a sin, where it cannot lawfully be had (that is, say you, where the Bishops forbid it; say they, where Gods Laws forbid it, by reason of adherent sin. 2. And that, take the Bishops who forbid it them to be Usurpers, that have no true calling (as all the Papists do of our Bishops, and many others.) 3. Who take it to be more eligible, yea a necessary duty to hold Communion with purer societies. 4. Besides all those Sectaries that make light of Sacraments in general. What Papists, Quakers, Anabaptist, Separatists, &c. are compelled to any good by the Bishops denying them the Sacrament? 13. Nothing but Ignorance or Impudence can deny that the difficulty of knowing whose Excommunication it is that is to be dreaded as owned by God, hath encouraged professed Christians so confusedly to Excommunicate one another, as that this Excommunication hath been so far from constraining most to repentance, that it hath made Christianity a horrid scandal to Infidels and Heathens,