A26860:360
An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlock, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical…An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlocke, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical…
An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlock, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical and monarchical, as church-tyranny and popery : and defending Dr. Isaac Barrow's treatise against it by Richard Baxter ; preparatory to a fuller treatise against such an universal sovereignty as contrary to reason, Christianity, the Protestant profession, and the Church of England, though the corrupters usurp that title.An answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlocke, confuting an universal humane church-supremacy aristocratical and monarchical, as church-tyranny and popery : and defending Dr. Isaac Barrow's treatise against it by Richard Baxter ; preparatory to a fuller treatise against such an universal soveraignty as contrary to reason, Christianity, the Protestant profession, and the Church of England, though the corrupters usurp that title.
London: printed for Thomas Parkhurst, 1682
Chapter 5: Wherein Mr. Dodwell's deceits, and the danger of them do consist.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
If you say, The Bishops in a General Council, that's almost all one. What Wars were there between many General Councils; and how long was it the Religion of one side, to be for one, and curse the other; and of the other side, to curse all that did not receive that? How shall we know which Council to obey? If you say as Binnius, that all Councils have just so much power as the Pope giveth them, how shall we know that this is true? But I suppose that will not be your answer. If you say, we must obey that which is Orthodox, who is the Judg? If every man, then they that judg the excommunicating-Bishops, or Councils, not Orthodox, will not obey them. Truly I know not what answer to expect from you. Qu. 3. Can that man expect, that excommunicating should set all right, and bring men to obedience now in the end of the world, who is constrained (against his will) to be certain, that abused excommunications have been the great means of setting the Christian world into pernicious Schisms and Confusions? ⟨p. 110⟩Qu. 4. At this day, when the Papal Church unchurches all the Christian Churches that are not Subjects to the Pope; and when the Greek Church excommunicateth the Papal, and most continue damning one another, can you think, that even excommunicating is the remedy to cure these Schisms, and set all right? Qu. 5. If denying men the Sacrament, will constrain men to obedience, why do not the Episcopal Churches through the world, cure the Peoples sins by keeping them from the Sacrament, when so great numbers are profane, and sensual, and worldlings, and wicked, how easy a means of Conversion were it to forbid them all the Sacrament? Qu. 6. Is it no contradiction to say, that the Sacrament is Gods means of giving Sanctification? and yet that keeping men from it is the means? Qu. 7. But if you mean not constraining to obey God, but only to obey the Bishop, and not God, what good will such obedience do the mans soul, that will not save him? I confess the Magistrate that hath the Sword, may compel men to the use of the necessary suitable means of Conversion and Grace; and those means may further Sanctification. IV. As to the Fourth Point, I have said enough of it to you heretofore. 1.
If you say, The Bishops in a General Council, that's almost all one. What Wars were there between many General Councils; and how long was it the Religion of one side, to be for one, and curse the other; and of the other side, to curse all that did not receive that? How shall we know which Council to obey? If you say as Binnius, that all Councils have just so much power as the Pope giveth them, how shall we know that this is true? But I suppose that will not be your answer. If you say, we must obey that which is Orthodox, who is the Judg? If every man, then they that judg the excommunicating-Bishops, or Councils, not Orthodox, will not obey them. Truly I know not what answer to expect from you. Qu. 3. Can that man expect, that excommunicating should set all right, and bring men to obedience now in the end of the world, who is constrained (against his will) to be certain, that abused excommunications have been the great means of setting the Christian world into pernicious Schsms and Confusions?