The arrogancy of reason against divine revelations, repressed
The arrogancy of reason against divine revelations, repressed, or, Proud ignorance the cause of infidelity, and of mens quarrelling with the word of God
Richard Baxter 1615–1691London: printed by T.N. for Tho. Underhil, 1655
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I do therefore exhort al• that fear the Great Name of God, and love their own Souls, That they take special heed against this dangerous sin: Think not the Proved-Sealed. Word of God, is ever the more to be suspected, because that the matters in it do seem strange, and unlikely to your Reason. And think not that you should comprehend the mysterious counsels and ways of God. Let your understandings meditate on Scripture▪ difficulties, that you may learn to resolve them; but suffer not the apprehension of those difficulties to make you once question the Truth of God; but abhor such a thought as soon as it ariseth, and cast it with detestation out of your hearts.
I do therefore exhort al• that fear the Great Name of God, and love their own Souls, That they take special heed against this da•gerous sin: Think not the Proved-Sealed. Word of God, is ever the more to be suspected, because that the matters in it do seem strange, and unlikely to your Reason. And think not that you should comprehend the mysterious counsels and ways of God. Let your understandings meditate on Scriptu•e▪ difficulties, that you may learn to resolve them; but suffer not the apprehension of those d•fficulties to make you once question the Truth of God; but abhor such a thought as soon as it ariseth, and cast it with detestation out of your hearts.
1. Consider, who that God is whose ways thou dost so presumptuously pass thy censure of, and ⟨p. 47⟩whose Word thou callest to the B•r o• thy Judgment •• Is Infinite wisdom fit to be examined by thee? or t•e Works of Infinite power to be tried by thee? If there were nothing wonderful in his Word or Works, they would not believe the Majesty of God; nor the Saviour of the World, whose Name is Wonderful, Counsellor, the Mighty G•d Isai. • 6. Gods Name mu•t be written upon his Word and Works, and all must bear some part of his Image; and therefore have somewhat in them that is incomprehensible. Shall the Infinite God have no Word or Work, but what may be comprehended by such as we? I seriously profess, that it oft am••eth me, to think that we should know so muc• of God, his Will, and Ways, as we do? When I consider the infinite distance between him and us, I must admire that we are made so much acquainted with his mind, and that he hath told us so much of his mysteries as he hath done, and must say [What is man that thou art mindful of him, and the Son of Man that thou so vi test and regardest him.] Psal. 8 4. Job 7. 17. When I consider how little a poor Worm, or B•rd, or •east, knows of me that am made of the same fl•sh with him; and how much man knows of the mind of God, who is infinitely distant from him, it makes me admire at the Providence that hath so ordered it. If a Beast could so far consider, and discourse, would it not be f•lly in him to call my writings, words, and ways, to the Bar, and to suspect those as false that are beyond his reach! and to say▪ [How can these things be?] Why, alas, they are ten thousand ⟨p. 48⟩thousand times nearer to us, then we are unt• God. O then let us thankfully open his books and look upon his words and works, and bless him that hath condescended so far to man, and lifted up man so near to himself in knowledge, in comparison of other inferior creatures; and make much of that measure of knowledge which we have: But do not think to measure the Creation of God, not to comprehend his secrets; much less himself. Methinks the reading of those four Chapters in Job before cited, containing Gods expostulation with him, might do much to humble an Arrogant wit, and to make it submit to infinite wisdom. Alas, the very Angels cannot comprehend God, and whether a Creature can immediately see his Essence, we cannot now affirm:
Admirations do better beseem the highest of his Creatures, then bold expostulations. The flaming Mount might not be touched. You cannot endure to gaze upon the Sun, which is Gods Creature: Should you approach too near it, you would be consumed by its heat. And dare you be so bold with the highest Majesty? It were not greater folly to imagine that you can span the Earth in your hand, or that you can reach the Sun with your finger, then to imagine that you are meet to expostulate with God▪ and that all must be unreasonable in his Word or Works, where your wit is not able to discern the Reason. Surely, [His thoughts are not as our thoughts, nor his ways as our ways; but as far as the Heaven is above the Earth, so far are his thoughts and ways above ours, Isai. 55. 7, 8, 9]
Admirations do better beseem the highest of his Creatures, then bold expostulations. The flaming Mount might not be touched. You cannot endure to gaze upon the Sun, which is Gods Creature: Should you approach too near it, you would be consumed by its heat. And dare you be so bold with the highest Majesty? It were not greater folly to imagine that you can span the Earth in your hand, or that you can reach the Sun with your finger, then to imagine that you are meet to expo••ulate with God▪ and that all must be unreasonable in his Word or Works, where your wit is not able to discern the Reason. Surely, [His thoughts are not as our thoughts, nor his ways as our ways; but as far as the Heaven is above the Earth, so far are his thoughts and ways above ours, Isai. 55. 7, 8, 9]
And as you cannot comprehend the thoughts and ways of God, so you are surely unfit to contradict them. The child will submit to the wisdom of his Father, and the Scholar of his Master, and will believe them when they cannot re•ch the reason of their sayings: They will not set their wits against them, thought they be reasonable Creatures, as well as they. It was the humble expression of men of old, when they would contemn themselves, in comparison of their superiors, to call themselves [A dead dog] or [a flea▪ ] 1 Sam 24. 14. and •0. 20. David himself doth so to Saul. What may we then call our selves, in comparison with the Lord, but even nothing and less then nothing, and lighter then vanity? and should nothing contend with immensity and Eternity? Should a Flea dispute with a Learned man and say [How can these things be] How much less should we s• dispute with God?
And as you cannot comprehend the thoughts and ways of God, so you are surely unfit to contradict them. The childe will submit to the wisdom of his Father, and the Schollar of his Master, and will believe them when they cannot re•ch the reason of their sayings: They will not set their wits against them, thought they be reasonable Creatures, as well as they. It was the humble expression of men of old, when they would contemn themselves, in comparison of their superiors, to call themselves [A dead dog] or [a flea▪ ] 1 Sam 24. 14. and •0. 20. David himself doth so to Saul. What may we then call our selves, in comparison with the Lord, but even nothing and less then nothing, and lighter then vanity? and should nothing contend with immensity and Eternity? Should a Flea dispute with a Learned man and say [How can these things be] How much less should we s• dispute with God?
If a man do but look up to the height of the visible Heaven, or look down into some exceeding depth, it will make him be ready to tremble: with what dread and submissive reverence then should our minds look to the height and depth of the Counsels of the Lord? D•re not therefore any more •o quarrel with his wisdom▪ but say as Job when God had non-plus'• him, Job 42. 2, 3. [I know that thou canst do every thing, and that no thought can be withholden from thee, who is he that hideth counsel without knowledge? Therefore have I uttered that I understood not; things too wonderful for me, which I know not.
If a man do but look up to the height of the visible Heaven, or look down into some exceeding depth, it will make him be ready to tremble: with what dread and submissive reverence then should our mindes look to the height and depth of the Counsels of the Lord? D•re not therefore any more •o quarrel with his wisdom▪ but say as Job when God had non-plus'• him, Job 42. 2, 3. [I know that thou canst do every thing, and that no thought can be withholden from thee, who is he that hideth counsel without knowledge? Therefore have I uttered that I understood not; things too wonderful for me, which I know not.
2. Consider also what we are our selves, as well ⟨p. 50⟩as what that God is with whom we do expostulate. The Lord knows we are silly Creatures for such an undertaking! Can such breathing lumps of earth, such walking dust, such bags of filth, be fit to enter a dispute with God? And though they are noble souls that are thus meanly housed, yet never endowed or fitted for such a task. A spoon or shell may as well contain the whole Ocean, as our narrow understandings comprehend the counsels of God. Are our understandings infinite, that we should think to comprehend the Reasons of the words and ways of the Lord, any further then he hath condescended to reveal them? Our eyes may as well expect an unlimited vision, and think to see beyond the Sun •s our understandings expect such a boundless intellection. It's a wonder that so much knowledge as we have, should be found in a soul that'• housed in clay: and shall we presume that we have so much more then we have? It was the sinful Arrogancy of our first parents to desire to be as Gods in Knowledge: and shall we go so far beyond them in our Arrogancy, as to presume that we are actually such indeed?
2. Consider also what we are our selves, as well ⟨p. 50⟩as what that God is with whom we do expostulate. The Lord knows we are silly Creatures for such an undertaking! Can s•ch breathing lumps of earth, such walking dust, such bags of filth, be fit to enter a dispute with God? And though they are noble souls that are thus meanly housed, yet never endowed or fitted for such a task. A spoon or shell may as well contain the whole Ocean, as our narrow understandings comprehend the counsels of God. Are our understandings infinite, that we should think to comprehend the Reasons of the words and ways of the Lord, any further then he hath condescended to reveal them? Our eyes may as well expect an unlimited vision, and think to see beyond the Sun •s our understandings expect such a boundless intellection. It's a wonder that so much knowledge as we have, should be found in a soul that'• housed in clay: and shall we presume that we have so much more then we have? It was the sinful Arrogancy of our first parents to desire to be as Gods in Knowledge: and shall we go so far beyond them in our Arrogancy, as to presume that we are actually such indeed?
And its observable what contradictions there be among s••ful principles, and how proud infidelity doth condemn it self: These unbelievers have such low thoughts of mens soul, that they think it doth but gradually differ in its rational power from the soul of a brute; and therefore think it cannot be immortal: and yet the very same men that think not the soul so noble as to be immortal, do think it so capable of disputing with God, and comprehending the reasons of his Truths and ways, that ⟨p. 51⟩they are ready to deny the most confirmed Truth, if they do not reach the manner and End• and Reasons of it, and God shall not be believed, unless their Reasons be satisfied in all these, and unless they are able to take so full a view of the whole body of Truth, as to answer all gain-sayers, and reconcile all seeming contradictions, they will not take Gods word to be his word▪ Yea with the wretched Atheist God shall not be God, because he cannot comprehended him: He shall not be infinite, in Immensity and Eternity, because that he cannot comprehend this Immensity and Eternity. And so wi•h the Infidel, Christ shall be no Christ, and the Trinity no Trinity, because his shallow brain cannot comprehend the mysteries of the incarnation, the Hypostatical Union and the Trinity So that the same m•n will have his soul to be but as the soul of a dog fo• kind, and yet will have it more comprehensive then the very Angels in Heaven, and think it so competent a Judge of Gods Counsels, that he will presume to condemn them, if he see not the Reasons of them.
And its observable what contradictions there be among s••ful principles, and how proud infidelity doth condemn it self: These unbelievers have such low thoughts of mens soul, that they think it doth but gradually differ in its rational power from the soul of a bruit; and therefore think it cannot be immortal: and yet the very same men that think not the soul so noble as to be immortal, do think it so capable of disputing with God, and compre•ending the reasons of his Truths and ways, that ⟨p. 51⟩
3. Consider, Doth not certain experience tell you that you are utterly unable fully to understand the nature and reasons of those works of God, that are daily visible before your eyes? I will not say, only of the greater and more distant, but even of the least, or of any one of them. I am confident that there is not the least fly or worm or pile of grass (much more the Sun and other Planets) but that which we know of them, is much less then that which no man knows. And should such poor understandings then be so Arrogant as to think to fathom the Counsels of God, and reject ⟨p. 52⟩his plain revealed Truths, because they see not, How such things can be.
3. Consider, Doth not certain experience tell you that you are utterly unable fully to understand the nature and reasons of those works of God, that are daily visible before your eys? I will not say, onely of the greater and more distant, but even of the least, or of any one of them. I am confident that there is not the least flie or worm or pile of grass (much more the Sun and other Planets) but that which we know of them, is much less then that which no man knows. And should such poor understandings then be so Arrogant as to think to fathom the Counsels of God, and reject ⟨p. 52⟩his plain revealed Truths, because they see not, How such things can be.
4. Consider, What a stream of experience do you sin against in this Arrogancy. Doth not every Study that you fall upon, and every days business that you are engaged in, most plainly discover the weakness of your understandings? Why else do you learn no faster, and know no more? Why are you not yet absolute masters in all Sciences and Arts? Yea why are you so defective in all? And yet will you presume to dispute with God, and reject his Truths as unreasonable, after all this experience of your own infirmity, and of your unfitness for works that are so much lower?
4. Consider, What a stream of experience do you sin against in this Arrogancy. Doth not every Study that you fall upon, and every days business that you are engaged in, most plainly discover the weakness of your understandings? Why else do you learn no faster, and know no more? Why are you not yet absolnte masters in all Sciences and Arts? Yea why are you so defective in all? And yet will you presume to dispute with God, and reject his Truths as unreasonable, after all this experience of your own infirmity, and of your unfitness for works that are so much lower?
5. Consider, Whether by this sinful Arrogancy you do not equal your understandings with Gods? For if you must be able to see the Reason of all his Truths and ways, and will control them because you see not the reason of them, doth not this imply that you suppose your self to equal him in understanding? And what greater madness can you be guilty of, then such a conceit? So also when you quarrel with the word as if it contained things that are unrighteous, and strengthen your unbelief by such conceits, what do you but say, that you are more righteous then God? Oh think not that the foolishness of man is wiser then God, or that our darkness is comparable to his incomprehensible light, or our unrighteousness to his perfect Justice; or that we are fit Judges of these his perfections. Hear that voice that Eli•haz heard, from the Spirit that passed before him in the Visions of the night, Job 4. 13, 14, 15, ⟨p. 53⟩16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21. [Shall mortal man be more just then God? shall a man be more pure then his Maker? Behold he put u• trust in his servants, and his Angels he charged with folly: how much less on them that dwell in houses of clay, whose foundation is in the dust, which are crushed before the moth: They are destroyed from morning to evening: they p•rish for ever without any regarding it: doth not their excellency which is in them go away? they die, even without wisdom.]
5. Consider, Whether by this sinful Ar•ogancy you do not equal your understandings with Gods? For if you must be able to see the Reason of all his Truths and ways, and will control them because you see not the reason of them, doth not this imply that you suppose your self to equal him in understanding? And what greater madness can you be guilty of, then such a conceit? So also when you quarrel with the word as if it contained things that are unrighteous, and strengthen your unbelief by such conceits, what do you but say, that you are more righteous then God? Oh think not that the fool•shness of man is wiser then God, or that our darkness is comparable to his incomprehensible light, or our unrighteousness to his perfect Justice; or that we are fit Judges of these his perfections. Hear that voice that Elihaz heard, from the Spirit that passed before him in the Visions of the night,
6. Consider further, that it is the very nature of Faith to believe the thing revealed or testified, upon the mere credit of the testifier or revealer, If therefore you will have no such implicit belief in God, you will have no faith at all. To see a thing in its own Evidence, is not to Believe. The formal object of faith is the veracity of God: Reason assures us first that God cannot lye: and next it discerneth by evidence, that [This is Gods word, or a Divine Revelation]: and then we may well build upon this foundation, that each particular of this Revelation is true. So that it is no true Belief, if the credit of the Testifier be not the reason of your Assent. If therefore you must see the reason of Gods revealed truths, and the very manner and end of all his works, before you will believe, this is as much as openly to proclaim, that you will be no believers at all. You will Assent to the words of the falsest Liar, as long as you see the Evidence of truth in the things themselves which they report. And will you give no more credit to God then to such a one? Will you believe God no further then you see a Cogent Evidence ⟨p. 54⟩in the thing asserted, which shows that he cannot deceive you therein if he would? Why, thus far you will believe the worst of men: For indeed this is no believing at all. If you do not first believe that God cannot lye, and so that all that he saith is true, you have no belief in him at all.
6. Consider further, that it is the very nature of Faith to believe the thing revealed or testifyed, upon the meer credit of the testifyer or revealer, If therefore you will have no such implicite belief in God, you will have no faith at all. To see a thing in its own Evidence, is not to Believe. The formal object of faith is the veracity of God: Reason assures us first that God cannot lye: and next it discerneth by evidence, that [This is Gods word, or a Divine Revelation]: and then we may well build upon this foundation, that each particular of this Revelation is true. So that it is no true Belief, if the credit of the Testifyer be not the reason of your Assent. If therefore you must see the reason of Gods revealed truths, and the very manner and end of all his works, before you will believe, this is as much as openly to proclaim, that you will be no believers at all. You will Assent to the words of the false•t Lyar, as long as you see the Evidence of truth in the things themselves which they report. And will you give no more credit to God then to such a one? Will you believe God no further then you see a Cogent Evidence
7. If you are Christians, you are Christs Disciples, and therefore must wait on him in the humble posture of learners. And he that will no w•it credit this teacher is not like to learn. If you will not believe him, but assent only to that which is evident of it self without his word, then how are you his Scholars?
7. If you are Christians, you are Christs Disciples, and therefore must wait on him in the humble posture of learners. And he that will no w•it credit this teacher is not like to learn. If you will not believe him, but assent onely to that which is evident of it self without his word, then how are you his Scholars?
8. Will you allow your own children or Scholars to do so by you? If they should dispute with you instead of believing you, and so should reject all that you tell them as false, that is beyond their capacity as to the reasons and manner; you would not think that they did their duty When a schoolmaster is teaching his scholars their lesson, shall they instead of learning, dispute it with their master, and in every difficulty or seeming contradiction, unbelievingly say, [How can these things be]? Be not guilty of that towards God, which you would not have a child be guilty of to a man.
9. Consider also, if this course be taken, whether ever you be like to come to knowledge. For the knowledge of things whose Evidence is all in the Revelation, and the credit of the Testifier, can be no other way attained but by believing. All things seem strange and difficult at first, to those ⟨p. 55⟩that have not learned them. If you understand all things already, what need you to learn any more? If you do not, then all that you understand will appear to you at first as darkness or contradiction. If now you will be so confident of your own understandings, as to cast away all that you understand not already, because it seems contradictory or unlikely, how are you like to know any more? If you will conclude that all is false which you understand not already, you are like to make but unprofitable scholars. Well therefore saith Solomon, Prov. 6. 12. [Seest thou a man wise in his own conceit? there is more hope of a fool then of him] For certainly it is a double degree of folly, for a man not only to be ignorant of the things of God, but also to be so ignorant of his own ignorance. And we must be at more pains to make such proud men know that they do not know, then to make the humble to know the truths themselves, which they perceive that they yet know not. And therefore Paul doth not only bid us [Be not wise in your own conceits] Rom. 12 16 But also, intimates that ignorance is the cause of such conceits of wisdom, Rom. 11. 25. [For I would not brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits] As Solomon saith of the foolish sluggard, that [He is wiser in his own conceit then seven men that can render a reason] Pro. 26 16.
9. Consider aso, if this course be taken, whether ever you be like to come to knowledge. For the knowledge of things whose Evidence is all in the Revelation, and the credit of the Testifyer, can be no other way attained but by believing. All things seem strange and difficult at first, to those ⟨p. 55⟩
10. Consider, Whether in this case you join not impudency and inhumane ingratitude to your Arrogancy? When Christ condescendeth to become your teacher, and you are loiterers and ⟨p. 56⟩dullards and will not learn, but have lost the most of your time in his school, is it not a great mercy now, that he will yet entertain you and instruct you, and doth not turn you out of his school? And will you, instead of being thankful for this mercy, fall a quarrelling with his truth, and take on you to be wiser then he, when you have so provoked him by your ignorance and unprofitableness! Will you fly in his face, with audacious unbelieving questions, and say [How can these things be.] As if it were he that knew not what he said, and not you that did not understand him?
10. Consider, Whether in this case you joyn not impudency and inhumane ingratitude to your Arrogancy? When Christ condescendeth to become your teacher, and you are loyterers and ⟨p. 56⟩dullards and will not learn, but have lost the most of your time in his schoole, is it not a great mercy now, that he will yet entertain you and instruct you, and doth not turn you out of his schoole? And will you, instead of being thankful for this mercy, fall a quarrelling with his truth, and take on you to be wiser then he, when you have so provoked him by your ignorance and unprofitableness! Will you flye in his face, with audacious unbelieving questions, and say [How can these things be.] As if it were he that knew not what he said, and not you that did not understand him?
1. Consider, who that God is whose ways thou dost so presumptuously pass thy censure of, and ⟨p. 47⟩whose Word thou callest to the B•r o• thy Judgment •• Is Infinite wisdom fit to be examined by thee? or t•e Works of Infinite power to be tryed by thee? If there were nothing wonderful in his Word or Works, they would not believe the M•jesty of God; nor the Saviour of the World, whose Name is Wonderful, Counsellor, the Mighty G•d Isai. • 6. Gods Name mu•t be written upon his Word and Works, and all must bear some part of his Image; and therefore have somewhat in them that is incomprehensible. Shall the Infinite God have no Word or Work, but what may be comprehended by such as we? I seriously profess, that it oft am••eth me, to think that we should know so muc• of God, his Will, and Ways, as we do? When I consider the infinite distance between him and us, I must admire that we are made so much acquainted with his minde, and that he hath told us so much of his mysteries as he h•th done, and must say [What is man that thou art mindful of him, and the Son of Man that thou so vi test and regardest him.] Psal. 8 4. Job 7. 17. When I consid•r how little a poor Worm, or B•rd, or •east, knows of me th•t am made of the same fl•sh with him; and how much man knows of the minde of God, who is infinitely distant from him, it makes me admire at the Provi•ence that hath so ordered it. If a Beast could so far consider, and discou•se, would it not be f•lly in him to call my writings, words, and ways, to the Bar, and to suspect those as false that are beyond his reach! and to say▪ [How can these things be?] Why, alas, they are ten thousand ⟨p. 48⟩thousand times neerer to us, then we are unt• God. O then let us thankfully open his books and look upon his words and works, and bless him that hath condescended so far to man, and lifted up man so neer to himself in knowledge, in comparison of other inferior creatures; and make much of that measure of knowledge which we have: But do not think to measure the Creation of God, not to comprehend his secrets; much less himself. Methinks the reading of those four Chapters in Job before cited, containing Gods expostulation with him, might do much to humble an Arrogant wit, and to make it submit to infinite wisdom. Alas, the very Angels cannot comprehend God, and whether a•• Creature can immediately see his Essence, we cannot now affirm:
they are ready to deny the most confirmed Truth, if they do not reach the maner and End• and Reasons of it, and God shall not be believed, unless their Reasons be satisfyed in all these, and unless they are able to take so full a view of the whole body of Truth, as to answer all gain-sayers, and reconcile all seeming contradictions, they will not take Gods word to be his word▪ Yea with the wretched Atheist God shall not be God, because he cannot comprehended him: He shall not be infinite, in Immensity and Eternity, because that he cannot comprehend this Immensity and Eternity. And so wi•h the Infidel, Christ shall be no Christ, and the Trinity no Trinity, because his shallow brain cannot compre•end the mysteries of the incarnation, the Hypostatical Union and the Trinity So that the same m•n will have his soul to be but as the soul of a dog fo• kind, and yet will have it more comprehensive then the very Angels in Heaven, and think it so competent a Judge of Gods Counsels, that he will presume to condemn them, if he see not the Reasons of them.
16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21. [Shall mortal man be more just then God? shall a man be more pure then his Maker? Behold he put u• trust in his servants, and his Angels he charged with folly: how much less on them that dwell in houses of clay, whose foundation is in the dust, which are crushed before the moth: They are destroyed from morning to evening: they p•rish for ever without any regarding it: doth not their excellency which is in them go away? they die, even wi•hout wisd•m.]
⟨p. 54⟩
in the thing asserted, which shews that he cannot deceive you therein if he would? Why, thus far you will believe the worst of men: For indeed this is no beli•ving at all. If you do not first believe that God cannot lye, and so that all that he saith is true, you have no belief in him at all.
that have not learned them. If you understand all things already, what need you to learn any more? If you do not, then all that you understand will appear to you at first as darkness or contradiction. If now you will be so confident of your own understandings, as to cast away all that you understand not already, because it seems contradictory or unlikely, how are you like to know any more? If you will conclude that all is false which you understand not already, you are like to make but unprofitable scholars. Well therefore saith Solomon,
. [Seest thou a man wise in his own conceit? there is more hope of a fool then of him] For certainly it is a double degree of folly, for a man not onely to be ignorant of the things of God, but also to be so ignorant of his own ignorance. And we must be at more pains to make such proud men know that they do not know, then to make the humble to know the truths themselves, which they perceive that they yet know not. And therefore Paul doth not only bid us [Be not wise in your own conceits]
. [For I would not brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits] As Solomon saith of the foolish sluggard, that [He is wiser in his own conceit then seven men that can render a reason]