A26880:598
Catholic communion defended against both extremes, and unnecessary division confuted in five parts ...…Catholick communion defended against both extreams, and unnecessary division confuted in five parts ...…
Catholic communion defended against both extremes, and unnecessary division confuted in five parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...Catholick communion defended against both extreams, and unnecessary division confuted in five parts ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed for Tho. Parkhurst, 1684
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I doubt I weary the Reader with oft repeating the same thing, to make them plain against perverters.
§ 24. Let us follow him further: p. 47. he saith, [But how to apply the Copula in a Proposition either to the union of Soul or Body, or of Christ and his Church, I cannot tell; and shall never be able to learn, till I meet with some new Baxterian Logic, as well as Grammar and Metaphysics.
§ 24. Let us follow him further: p. 47. he saith, [But how to apply the Copula in a Proposition either to the union of Soul or Body, or of Christ and his Church, I cannot tell; and shall never be able to learn, till I meet with some new Baxterian Logick, as well as Grammar and Metaphysicks.
Ans. And yet you will think your self wise enough to stir up men against us for our ignorance, while you are raging confident. Are you resolved to read no Logic that's already written? One would have thought it should have pleased one that pleads for Unity: As it is no Proposition, but made so by the Copula, uniting the terms as Subject and Predicate, and the Union maketh one the Predicate; so it is no Man and no Church by the bare existence of Soul and Body, or of Christ and Believers, without the uniting of both together, that so the Soul may become in actu, the forma hominis, and Christ the forma Ecclesiae. Homo & Animal rationale, are no Proposition without a Uniting est. Is not this plain?
Ans. And yet you will think your self wise enough to stir up men against us for our ignorance, while you are raging confident. Are you resolved to read no Logick that's already written? One would have thought it should have pleased one that pleads for Unity: As it is no Proposition, but made so by the Copula, uniting the terms as Subject and Predicate, and the Union maketh one the Predicate; so it is no Man and no Church by the bare existence of Soul and Body, or of Christ and Believers, without the uniting of both together, that so the Soul may become in actu, the forma hominis, and Christ the forma Ecclesiae. Homo & Animal rationale, are no Proposition without a Uniting est. Is not this plain?
§ 25. P. 47, 48. Granting that there is no Universal Government but Christ, he's again at it, that there is somewhat more than Organization, and all the Essentials of Christianity and Union with Christ, to make the Church One: and thereupon feigneth me to say, [That which maketh this Body to become a Church, is no union among themselves]; and leaveth out the rest of the Sentence, [but their common union with Christ:] As if their common Union with Christ were not an Union among themselves. If I have not made this plain enough, That 1. the Church hath the Unity of the parts to make it a capable Body or Matter. 2. That it hath a consequent Union and Communion after it is a Church. 3. But that it is only the Union of adapted Matter and Form, that makes it essentially the Church of Christ in the proper political sense, then I despair of making it intelligible, that forma dat esse & nomen: And if that which maketh it [the Church] do not thereby make it hoc unum, then eus & unum non convertuntur, and unum must have a distinct cause from eus.
§ 25. P. 47, 48. Granting that there is no Universal Government but Christ, he's again at it, that there is somewhat more than Organization, and all the Essentials of Christianity and Union with Christ, to make the Church One: and thereupon feigneth me to say, [That which maketh this Body to become a Church, is no union among themselves]; and leaveth out the rest of the Sentence, [but their common union with Christ:] As if their common Union with Christ were not an Union among themselves. If I have not made this plain enough, That 1. the Church hath the Unity of the parts to make it a capable Body or Matter. 2. That it hath a consequent Union and Communion after it is a Church. 3. But that it is only the Union of adapted Matter and Form, that makes it essentially the Church of Christ in the proper political sence, then I despair of making it intelligible, that forma dat esse & nomen: And if that which maketh it [the Church] do not thereby make it hoc unum, then eus & unum non convertuntur, and unum must have a distinct cause from eus.
§ 26. He adds, [I should rather think that the Unity of several Churches makes them one Church, and does not only prepare and dispose them to be one].
Ans. Their Unity in Christ doth make them one formally: And this is the informing Unity among themselves: But all other Unity is but preparatory or consequential to the formal unity. I told you out of Dr. Barrow, and may see in Rod. Goclenius, Martinius, and many more, beside Metaphysics, in what abundance of loose senses things may be called One: We deny no such Unity, no not in an heap of Sand. But of formal political Unity, why would you never tell us what it is but Union with one King, that makes ⟨p. 28⟩many Cities one Kingdom? Do you rather think they are One Kingdom by any other Union among themselves? Yes, if you take [Kingdom] materially and equivocally, but not else. Dare you say, That they are the Church of Christ, without their Union with him as the Form? Or dare you say, That all Christians united to Christ as their Head and Form, are not eo nomine, one Polity or Church?
Ans. Their Unity in Christ doth make them one formally: And this is the informing Unity among themselves: But all other Unity is but preparatory or consequential to the formal unity. I told you out of Dr. Barrow, and may see in Rod. Goclenius, Martinius, and many more, beside Metaphysicks, in what abundance of loose sences things may be called One: We deny no such Unity, no not in an heap of Sand. But of formal political Unity, why would you never tell us what it is but Union with one King, that makes ⟨p. 28⟩many Cities one Kingdom? Do you rather think they are One Kingdom by any other Union among themselves? Yes, if you take [Kingdom] materially and equivocasly, but not else. Dare you say, That they are the Church of Christ, without their Union with him as the Form? Or dare you say, That all Christians united to Christ as their Head and Form, are not eo nomine, one Polity or Church?
And what's the reason that all this while you will not name that thing else, that makes the Church one? Do it if you can.
§ 27. P. 49. Falsely saying, that I have not told him what Union of the Churches among themselves is necessary, he feigns an Union in Christ the Centre, consistent with as great distance as the two Poles..
§ 27. P. 49. Falsly saying, that I have not told him what Union of the Churches among themselves is necessary, he feigns an Union in Christ the Center, consistent with as great distance as the two Poles..
Ans. What base thoughts hath this man of Christianity? Is it a contemptible Union to have all one Faith, one Hope, one Baptismal Covenant, and so one God, one Lord, one Spirit, and one body of such, and all the Twelve parts of Union and Communion before named? 2. Were it not worth the labour for this man to tell us what the more near and excellent Union is which he hath a mind to set up? Paul saith, I tell you of a more excellent way, when he speaks of the Union of Love, even Love to God and our Saviour first, and to all his Members as united in him. Out of all this man's books I cannot find what his nearer Union is, unless it be to unite in such as he; that is, in obedience to their Wills; and so Subjection to them be this high Communion: He saith over and over the general word, Catholic Communion; but what he placeth it in, let him find that can.
Ans. What base thoughts hath this man of Christianity? Is it a contemptible Union to have all one Faith, one Hope, one Baptismal Covenant, and so one God, one Lord, one Spirit, and one body of such, and all the Twelve parts of Union and Communion before named? 2. Were it not worth the labour for this man to tell us what the more near and excellent Union is which he hath a mind to set up? Paul saith, I tell you of a more excellent way, when he speaks of the Union of Love, even Love to God and our Saviour first, and to all his Members as united in him. Out of all this man's books I cannot find what his nearer Union is, unless it be to unite in such as he; that is, in obedience to their Wills; and so Subjection to them be this high Communion: He saith over and over the general word, Catholick Communion; but what he placeth it in, let him find that can.
§ 28. He saith, [This is a pretty easy way of determining Controversies, to out-face all the authority of Scripture and Antiquity by a dogmatical assertion, without offering the least Reason, or shadow of Reason to confirm it.
§ 28. He saith, [This is a pretty easie way of determining Controversies, to out-face all the authority of Scripture and Antiquity by a dogmatical assertion, without offering the least Reason, or shadow of Reason to confirm it.
Ans. Reader, find one word of Scripture or true Antiquity that I contradict, or that ever he showed that I contradict; and judg who giveth Reason, and take not his word or mine.
Ans. Reader, find one word of Scripture or true Antiquity that I contradict, or that ever he shewed that I contradict; and judg who giveth Reason, and take not his word or mine.
§ 29. Saith he, [I had at large proved the necessity of one Catholic Communion to make one Catholic Church, and instead of answering the proof, he asserts the contrary upon his own naked authority, and that must pass for confutation.
§ 29. Saith he, [I had at large proved the necessity of one Catholick Communion to make one Catholick Church, and instead of answering the proef, he asserts the contrary upon his own naked authority, and that must pass for confutation.
Ans. Could a man have spoken more untruly that had studied it? 1. While he tells us, that by Communion he means Union; did I ever deny it? No, nor ever met with a Christian that denied it. 2. Yea, I said more than he, That besides Union, some Communion in transient acts is necessary, which he placeth not his Communion in. Is not this an hardened Disputer? Who can doubt but Union and Communion is necessary to one Church? But the doubt is, wherein it doth consist? whether in Essentials, ⟨p. 29⟩Integrals or Accidents? and what these be? We are far more for Catholic Union and Communion than you. We are for Communion with all true Christians, even those that you represent odious, and excommunicate and ruin; and you are for Communion with a Sect that will honour you and obey your will. We know that to have one God, and Christ, and Holy Spirit, one Faith and Hope of Heaven, one Baptism, and a true Love to one another, and to be all under one Law and Covenant of Christ, and in our several Assemblies to read the same Scripture, use the same Sacraments, and the same Rule of Prayer (the Lord's Prayer) and Praise; this is a most excellent Catholic Communion. We believe that true Christian Unity is the Unity of the Spirit; that is, mental in Faith, Hope and Love; but that it must be held, exercised and preserved in the bond of peace, Eph. 4 3. And therefore if any Christian take it for a sin to join with us in the circumstances of Worship, if we can, we'll alter them to satisfy them: If we cannot, we will gladly allow them to worship God together in their own circumstances, and there we will love and pray for one another: We will not cut men off from Christ or the Catholic Church, and damn them for not swearing or saying, that they will obey us, and that there is nothing sinful in any of our Government, Liturgies, Forms or Ceremonies. Our Union is in greater matters common to all Christians, and not in wearing the same fashions, and reading the same forms, and obeying the usurpers of the power of the Keys that are Lay-men, &c.
Ans. Could a man have spoken more untruly that had studied it? 1. While he tells us, that by Communion he means Union; did I ever deny it? No, nor ever met with a Christian that denied it. 2. Yea, I said more than he, That besides Union, some Communion in transient acts is necessary, which he placeth not his Communion in. Is not this an hardened Disputer? Who can doubt but Union and Communion is necessary to one Church? But the doubt is, wherein it doth consist? whether in Essentials, ⟨p. 29⟩Integrals or Accidents? and what these be? We are far more for Catholick Union and Communion than you. We are for Communion with all true Christians, even those that you represent odious, and excommunicate and ruin; and you are for Communion with a Sect that will honour you and obey your will. We know that to have one God, and Christ, and Holy Spirit, one Faith and Hope of Heaven, one Baptism, and a true Love to one another, and to be all under one Law and Covenant of Christ, and in our several Assemblies to read the same Scripture, use the same Sacraments, and the same Rule of Prayer (the Lord's Prayer) and Praise; this is a most excellent Catholick Communion. We believe that true Christian Unity is the Unity of the Spirit; that is, mental in Faith, Hope and Love; but that it must be held, exercised and preserved in the bond of peace, Eph. 4 3. And therefore if any Christian take it for a sin to joyn with us in the circumstances of Worship, if we can, we'l alter them to satisfie them: If we cannot, we will gladly allow them to worship God together in their own circumstances, and there we will love and pray for one another: We will not cut men off from Christ or the Catholick Church, and damn them for not swearing or saying, that they will obey us, and that there is nothing sinful in any of our Government, Liturgies, Forms or Ceremonies. Our Union is in greater matters common to all Christians, and not in wearing the same fashions, and reading the same forms, and obeying the usurpers of the power of the Keys that are Lay-men, &c.
And as for having obligation and right to Communion with all other Churches (which is all that I can gather he placeth it in, save obeying the same Bishops and Canons), we make no doubt of such right to be used in due order: And therefore we condemn all Church Tyrants that deny men their right: And we do not believe that our right is in the power of Prelates to take from us, unless we forfeit it, and cast it away: And we grant obligation to due Communion, as well as right; and therefore will be no such Separatists as you are, that refuse Communion with Dissenters in their Churches; yea, condemn all that do but call them Churches: And seeing no man is obliged to sin, we disown their crime that will not let men preach nor communicate, unless they will make a solemn Covenant to sin.
The Catholic Communion that he seems to aim at, is to receive and reject the same persons in every Church that are received in or rejected by any one. We are for as much of this as is needful to the purity and peace of the Church: But we do not believe that all the Christian World is bound to take all the godly persons for excommunicate, who shall be excommunicated here according to the 5th, 6th, 7th, 8th, &c. Canons of the Church of England; nor to silence all Ministers that you silence. ⟨p. 30⟩When we were newly silenced, 1662. some great men were employed to affirm, That if we would go and preach to the Americans it was an excellent work, and they would bear our charges: I told them, that our lives would be spent ere we could learn their Languages, as fit to preach to them. But it seems if we had gone, Catholic Communion would have silenced us there too, and have obliged the Americans, if we converted them, to reject us.
The Catholick Communion that he seems to aim at, is to receive and reject the same persons in every Church that are received in or rejected by any one. We are for as much of this as is needful to the purity and peace of the Church: But we do not believe that all the Christian World is bound to take all the godly persons for excommunicate, who shall be excommunicated here according to the 5th, 6th, 7th, 8th, &c. Canons of the Church of England; nor to silence all Ministers that you silence. ⟨p. 30⟩When we were newly silenced, 1662. some great men were imployed to affirm, That if we would go and preach to the Americans it was an excellent work, and they would bear our charges: I told them, that our lives would be spent e're we could learn their Languages, as fit to preach to them. But it seems if we had gone, Catholick Communion would have silenced us there too, and have obliged the Americans, if we converted them, to reject us.
What if Bishops excommunicate men for not paying the Civilians their Fees, or for not repenting of a truth, or silence us for not assenting and consenting to all in their book? must all the World reject us in conformity to them? It's an heinous crime for any one man to draw a Nation to sin with him; but much more to engage all the Christian World to sin with him; yea, and that on pretence of Catholic Communion. Christ saith (by his Spirit in his Apostle), Him that is weak in the faith receive, and receive one another as Christ received us. If Bishops silence and excommunicate even them that ate strong in the Faith, must all the World disobey Christ to obey them?
What if Bishops excommunicate men for not paying the Civilians their Fees, or for not repenting of a truth, or silence us for not assenting and consenting to all in their book? must all the World reject us in conformity to them? It's an heinous crime for any one man to draw a Nation to sin with him; but much more to engage all the Christian World to sin with him; yea, and that on pretence of Catholick Communion. Christ saith (by his Spirit in his Apostle), Him that is weak in the faith receive, and receive one another as Christ received us. If Bishops silence and excommunicate even them that ate strong in the Faith, must all the World disobey Christ to obey them?