Richard Baxter's Catholic theology plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriors who,…Richard Baxter's Catholick theologie plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriours who,…
Richard Baxter's Catholic theology plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriors who, 1. by contending about things unrevealed or not understood, 2. and by taking verbal differences for real,Richard Baxter's Catholick theologie plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriours who, 1. by contending about things unrevealed or not understood, 2. and by taking verbal differences for real,
Richard Baxter 1615–1691London: printed by Robert White for Nevill Simmons, 1675
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
When something else, and not impotency, doth ascertain an event, by omission, or something besides Power ascertaineth the contrary efficiently, yet the effect is oft denominated possible or impossible, and ascribed to Power or Impotency, by a conjunction of this moral and logical denomination. So we say, That [Gods pure eyes cannot behold Iniquity, that God cannot love the Workers of Iniquity as such.] Not for want of Power, but by reason of his perfect Will and Nature. So God cannot lye, Tit. 1. 2. And it is impossible for God to lye. God cannot deny himself, 2 Tim. 2. 13. God cannot be tempted with evil, Jam. 1. 13. So Joh. 10. 35. The Scripture cannot be broken. Isa. 1. 13. Your Assemblies I cannot away with. No wonder also if this be said of men: As, 1. Joh. 3. 9. He cannot sin, because he is born of God. Not for want of power, but partly he will not, and partly logically these cannot consist. So of the wicked, Joh. 7. 7. The World cannot hate you—.
XXX. Oft times the word [Cannot] is taken politically, I cannot, that is, I must not, or I cannot lawfully: Quod turpe, impossibile. Gen. 19. 22. I cannot do any thing, till thou be come out. Act. 10. 47. Can any man forbid water, &c. that is, lawfully. 2 Cor. 13. 8. [We can do nothing against the Truth,] that is, by Authority from God.
XXXI. Oft times in Scripture the word [Cannot] is meant only of that which a man cannot do without suffering, or loss, or difficutly. So ⟨p. 96⟩
. We cannot do this thing,] that is, without God.
XXXII. Oft times this inconvenience procuring unwillingness, this unwillingness is named like impotency, and it is said, Men cannot, because they will not. And so it is in divers of the last cited instances.
When something else, and not impotency, doth ascertain an event, by omission, or something besides Power ascertaineth the contrary efficiently, yet the effect is oft denominated possible or impossible, and ascribed to Power or Impotency, by a conjunction of this moral and logical denomination. So we say, That [Gods pure eyes cannot behold Iniquity, that God cannot love the Workers of Iniquity as such.] Not for want of Power, but by reason of his perfect Will and Nature. So God cannot lye, Tit. 1. 2. And it is impossible for God to lye. God cannot deny himself, 2 Tim. 2. 13. God cannot be tempted with evil, Jam. 1. 13. So Joh. 10. 35. The Scripture cannot be broken. Isa. 1. 13. Your Assemblies I cannot away with. No wonder also if this be said of men: As, 1. Joh. 3. 9. He cannot sin, because he is born of God. Not for want of power, but partly he will not, and partly logically these cannot consist. So of the wicked, Joh. 7. 7. The World cannot hate you—.
XXX. Oft times the word [Cannot] is taken politically, I cannot, that is, I must not, or I cannot lawfully: Quod turpe, impossibile. Gen. 19. 22. I cannot do any thing, till thou be come out. Act. 10. 47. Can any man forbid water, &c. that is, lawfully. 2 Cor. 13. 8. [We can do nothing against the Truth,] that is, by Authority from God.
XXXI. Oft times in Scripture the word [Cannot] is meant only of that which a man cannot do without suffering, or loss, or difficutly. So ⟨p. 96⟩Act. 4. 16. We cannot deny it,] that is, without the shame of falshood. Luk. 14. 20. I cannot come,] that is, without such inconvenience as I am unwilling to bear. Jer. 29. 17. They cannot be eaten,] that is, without loathing. 1 Sam. 25. 17. He is such a Son of Belial, that a man cannot speak to him,] that is, without inconvenience by it. 2 Sam. 23. 6. They cannot be taken with hands,] that is, without hurt. Gen. 34. 14. We cannot do this thing,] that is, without God.
XXXII. Oft times this inconvenience procuring unwillingness, this unwillingness is named like impotency, and it is said, Men cannot, because they will not. And so it is in divers of the last cited instances. Joh. 3. 9. They cannot sin,] that is, They will not. Luk. 14. 20. I have married a wife, and therefore I cannot come,] that is, I will not, because I cannot without this inconvenience. Neh. 6. 3. I cannot come down,] that is, I will not. Gen. 44. 26. We cannot go down.
Josh. 24. 19. Ye cannot serve the Lord; for he is a holy God: that is, you are not disposed to do it holily, and then he will destroy you. Joh. 6. 60. This is a hard saying, who can hear it?] that is, willingly. Isa. 49. 15. Can a woman forget her sucking-Child?] that is, will she forget it? Jer. 2. 32. Can a Maid forget her Ornaments? Mar. 2. 19. Can the Children of the Bridegroom fast? &c. Mar. 9. 39. Can ye drink of the Cup that I drink of, and be baptized? &c. 39. They said unto him, we can,] that is, Have you Wills disposed for such sufferings, and will you go through them?
And this unwillingness when it is habitual and prevalent, is it that is commonly called mans moral impotency, as to believe, love, obey, &c.
XXXIII. This impotency which is the moral pravity of the Will hath divers degrees: And the same degree of received help from God, will not cure it in one that will in another. The godly have some of it, and the ungodly more, and some of them more than others. But we use to call it absolutely a moral impotency, when the indisposition of the Soul is such, as that none such ever do believe and consent without more help of Grace than yet they have received. And we use to say that he is morally able, or hath power, whose indisposition is not so great nor Grace so small, but that some in that case by that same help do believe and consent, though it be rarely. But that power is morally called impotency, which no man ever reduceth to act.
XXXIV. This moral Power is yet short both of Act and Habit; For a Habit is not only a power to Act, but to Act promptly, and easily, and aright.
XXXV. By all this you may partly see how to answer the common questions about mens power or impotency to believe, and to love God.
Quest. 3. *Is a man able to sin, if God Decree he shall not; or able to forbear sin, or obey, if God fore-know that he will not?
*That Potentia peccandi is of God, see Aureolus in 2. d. 44. art. 2. pag. 327. 328. Utrum praecept• supernaturalia possit bomo servare fine specia•i auxilio gratiae? Resp. Quod non: quia ipsa neque•nt servari nisi eliciendo actus insusarum virtutum, &c. Carera sum. Theol. 2. 2. c. 1. And what would you have higher than his▪ q. 4. a. 1. An l•men supernaturale infusum fidei fit tota virtus agendi actum fidei? Resp. Ass-Quia actus fidei est quoad omnem rationem •odum, substantiam, denominationem, quidditatem, supernaturalis: ejus vita in actu secundo supernaturalis, Deum & authorem supernaturalem attingens, nec continetur intra vires & ordinem naturae, & intellectus creatus suapt• natura est ad illam improportionatus, p. 38. 39. So other Thomists. But here wanteth some explication of supernaturality. Yea they assert (ut idem ibid. p. 39, &c.) That the Intellect hath not so much as a potentia obedientialis activa, but only passiva to the act of Faith; but conceive that the supernatural infused Grace of Faith is as necessary to enable the faculty to that act, as the faculty to the Essence of the Soul therein. Though yet they grant that the Intellect is causa fidei principalis, as the essence is which yet can do nothing but by the faculty: And thus they make potentiam fundari in potentia, which Dr. Twice denieth. But a hard question troubleth some of the School-men, seeing saith is wholly supernatural, and Gods work, and it was so in the Jews that believed that Christ was to come; if that Faith continued in any some time after (as in Nathanael, &c.) Whether God still caused it when it became false as he did before? which must needs put them upon some exception: They say, How it is fides humana, but per opporentiam divinam, & D•us omnium dominus efficere potest ut quis •li•••ecidat fin• pacc••o (Idem, ibid.) But a further answer may and must be given; which will be useful to the Case before us, when conside ed. Of which in due place.That Potentia peccandi is of God, see Aureolus in 2. d. 44. art. 2. pag. 327. 328. Utrum praecept• supernaturalia possit bomo servare fine specia•i auxilio gratiae? Resp. Quod non: quia ipsa neque•nt servari nisi eliciendo actus insusarum virtutum, &c. Carera sum. Theol. 2. 2. c. 1. And what would you have higher than his▪ q. 4. a. 1. An l•men supernaturale infusum fidei fit tota virtus agendi actum fidei? Resp. Ass-Quia actus fidei est quoad omnem rationem •odum, substantiam, denominationem, quidditatem, supernaturalis: ejus vita in actu secundo supernaturalis, Deum & authorem supernaturalem attingens, nec continetur intra vires & ordinem naturae, & intellectus creatus suapt• natura est ad illam improportionatus, p. 38. 39. So other Thomists. But here wanteth some explication of supernaturality. Yea they assert (ut idem ibid. p. 39, &c.) That the Intellect hath not so much as a potentia obedientialis activa, but only passiva to the act of Faith; but conceive that the supernatural infused Grace of Faith is as necessary to enable the faculty to that act, as the faculty to the Essence of the Soul therein. Though yet they grant that the Intellect is causa fidei principalis, as the essence is which yet can do nothing but by the faculty: And thus they make potentiam fundari in potentia, which Dr. Twisse denieth. But a hard question troubleth some of the School-men, seeing saith is wholly supernatural, and Gods work, and it was so in the Jews that believed that Christ was to come; if that Faith continued in any some time after (as in Nathanael, &c.) Whether God still caused it when it became false as he did before? which must needs put them upon some exception: They say, How it is fides humana, but per opporentiam divinam, & D•us omnium dominus efficere potest ut quis •li•••ecidat fin• pacc••o (Idem, ibid.) But a further answer may and must be given; which will be useful to the Case before us, when conside ed. Of which in due place.
Answ. Yes: for God is not supposed to decree or fore-see that he shall not be able; nay, if God fore-see that he will not do what he can, it inferreth that he can. But the event is a logical impossibility; that is, it is not true that it will be.
Answ. It is the excitation of a Power; or a received impulse: Call it Power or what you will, so you trouble not the Church with a needless wrangling about a Name, when there are others as fit.
Answ. It is somewhat not well known by man; But we know that it is less than the natural Power, in point of substantiality, as being but an Accident: But it is more than both natural and moral power, in order of perfection to the act: For to be able and prompt is more than to be merely able.
Answ. It is somewhat not well known by man; But we know that it is less than the natural Power, in point of substantiality, as being but an Accident: But it is more than both natural and moral power, in order of perfection to the act: For to be able and prompt is more than to be meerly able.
PuritansEngland
Pastor at Kidderminster and prolific nonconformist author.