A26883:3353
Richard Baxter's Catholic theology plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriors who, 1. by contending about things unrevealed or not understood, 2. and by taking verbal differences for real,Richard Baxter's Catholick theologie plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriours who, 1. by contending about things unrevealed or not understood, 2. and by taking verbal differences for real,
London: printed by Robert White for Nevill Simmons, 1675
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
B. We come now somewhat nearer the heart of the Controversy: Try here your contending skill, Whether you can make this breach seem wider than you did the former, about Predestination and Redemption.
B. We come now somewhat nearer the heart of the Controversie: Try here your contending skill, Whether you can make this breach seem wider than you did the former, about Predestination and Redemption.
C. Some of them deny Original Sin, and so make man need no Saviour to pardon it, no Sanctifier to cure it, no Means or Duty on our part 1for the cure, no true Baptism for Infants, no true Repentance for such Sin; and so are true Pelagians.
B. 1. Those [some] I undertook not to prove of the same mind with you and me: But let us charge no more with it than we can prove guilty. That's nothing to all the rest: The Jesuits and Lutherans differ not from you herein as far as I can find, nor the generality of the Arminians. Those that are chiefly charged with it, are Arminius, Arnoldus, Corvinus, Episcopius, and Bishop Jeremy Taylor: Arminius expressly owneth it: Thes. private. 31. n. 9, 10, 11. pag. 299. Quoniam vero ratio-foederis a Deo cum hominibus primis mihi haec fuit, ut si ipsi in favore Dei & Gratia, ⟨p. 110⟩per praecepti istius & aliorum observationem permanerent, ad posteros dona in illos collata transmitterentur, eadem gratia divina quae illis obligat: si vero illi eorum se indignos facerent per inobedientiam, posteri quoque ipsorum iis carerent, & contrariis malis obnoxii essent: Hinc accidit ut omnes homines qui naturaliter ex ipsis propagandi fuerint, morti temporally & aeternae obnoxios evaserint, & do•o isto spirit•s sancti si•e justitiae originali vacui: quae paena priva•io imaginis Dei & peccatum originale appellari solet. An vero praeter carentiam justitiae Originalis aliqua contraria qualitas constituenda sit, tanquam pec•ati Originalis pars altera, disquiri permittimus: Quamquam arbitramur vero similius illam solam carentiam ipsum peccatum Originale esse, utpote quae sola sufficiet ad quaevis peccata actu••ia committen•um & producendum.
B. 1. Those [some] I undertook not to prove of the same mind with you and me: But let us charge no more with it than we can prove guilty. That's nothing to all the rest: The Jesuites and Lutherans differ not from you herein as far as I can find, nor the generality of the Arminians. Those that are chiefly charged with it, are Arminius, Arnoldus, Corvinus, Episcopius, and Bishop Jeremy Taylor: Arminius expresly owneth it: Thes. privat. 31. n. 9, 10, 11. pag. 299. Quoniam vero ratio-foederis a Deo cum hominibus primis mihi haec fuit, ut si ipsi in favore Dei & Gratia, ⟨p. 110⟩
C. Mark that he saith, but peccatum Original appellari solet.
C. Mark that he saith, but peccatum Originale appellari solet.
B. 1. But he disowneth it not. 2. He owneth the name in the next Thesis. 3. While he confesseth the thing, the lis est tantum de nomine, if he had denied the name. Also in Disp. privat. Thes. 67. de Baptis. p. 334, 335. he is for Infants Baptism to wash them in the blood of Christ, and give them the Holy Ghost. And he maketh this to be a washing from sin. What else should it be?
C. But he taketh it to be but Privatio Justitiae Originalis.
B. 1. He taketh it to be doubtful. 2. Remember that he calleth it not Negatio, but Privatio. 3. Almost all the School-men, and most or very many Calvinists say the same (though I do not).
C. But in his Articuli perpendendi in fine, lib. p. 780. col. 2. he saith, that Peccatum Originis non est illud actuale peccatum quo Adam legem de arbore scientiae boni & mali transgressus est, & propter quod nos omnes peccatores constituti sumus & rei facti condemnationis & mortis.
B. 1. Mark that he expressly maketh us by Adam's sin to be Peccatores & rei constituti. 2. So in the next Thesis. An peccatum Originis sit tantum carentia justitiae Originalis, & sanctimoniae primaevae, cum inclinatione ad peccandum, quae & antea in homine fuit, licet non ita vehemens, aeque & inordinata ut nunc est, propter amissum favorem Dei, maledictionem ejusdem, & amissionem ejus boni, quo in ordinem redigebatur; An vero contrarius quidam habitus justitiae & sanctimoniae infusus (vel ingressus, acquisitus) post peccatum perpetratum, Dub. Here he confesseth also a positive Original Sin in the inordinateness of the sensual inclination. 3. When he denieth Adam's Act to be our Original. 1. He denieth not (for no Christian denieth it) to be the Original Sin, that is, the first sin and the cause of ours. 2. And he seemeth but to mean that Adam's Sin individually was not ours: which is most certain: For the same Accident cannot be in two distinct Subjects: If our persons be not every one Adam's person, it is impossible that the same individual sin or guilt should be his and ours, any more than the same individual Soul. If God did arbitrarily (merely because he would do it) impute Adam's fact to all Mankind, and to every one personally, this would make it as many sins as there be persons; One mans Original Sin would not be another's, and none of theirs the same quoad formam numericam with Adam's. Adams is Adams, and yours is yours, and mine is mine. We cannot therefore be heretic men for such doubtful forms of speech, in which we differ among our selves. The plain truth is, the matter is not so well opened commonly among us, as to allow us to condemn others till we have better done our own ⟨p. 111⟩parts. My thoughts are these: 1. That we were seminally and virtually really in Adam; having the very essence of our Souls derived from him; not being in him only as the House is in the head of the Architect, but as an essential form is in the generator; though we call both, esse in causa. 2. That we were not personally in Adam (though seminally) that is, we were not natural persons in him, when he sinned. 3. God supposeth no man to have been what he was not, or done what he did not: For he erreth not. 4. God is not the Author of Sin:
B. 1. Mark that he expresly maketh us by Adam's sin to be Peccatores & rei constituti. 2. So in the next Thesis. An peccatum Originis sit tantum carentia justitiae Originalis, & sanctimoniae primaevae, cum inclinatione ad peccandum, quae & antea in homine fuit, licet non ita vehemens, aeque & inordinata ut nunc est, propter amissum favorem Dei, maledictionem ejusdem, & amissionem ejus boni, quo in ordinem redigebatur; An vero contrarius quidam habitus justitiae & sanctimoniae infusus (vel ingressus, acquisitus) post peccatum perpetratum, Dub. Here he confesseth also a positive Original Sin in the inordinateness of the sensual inclination. 3. When he denieth Adam's Act to be our Original. 1. He denieth not (for no Christian denieth it) to be the Original Sin, that is, the first sin and the cause of ours. 2. And he seemeth but to mean that Adam's Sin individually was not ours: which is most certain: For the same Accident cannot be in two distinct Subjects: If our persons be not every one Adam's person, it is impossible that the same individual sin or guilt should be his and ours, any more than the same individual Soul. If God did arbitrarily (meerly because he would do it) impute Adam's fact to all Mankind, and to every one personally, this would make it as many sins as there be persons; One mans Original Sin would not be anothers, and none of theirs the same quoad formam numericam with Adam's. Adams is Adams, and yours is yours, and mine is mine. We cannot therefore be heretick men for such doubtful forms of speech, in which we differ among our selves. The plain truth is, the matter is not so well opened commonly among us, as to allow us to condemn others till we have better done our own
Therefore he doth not by arbitrary imputing of Adam's act, and reputing us to have done what we did not, make all men Sinners, which Adam could not do. 5. But God doth truly repute us to have been seminally in Adam, and to have no Essence but what is really derived from his Essence: And as when a man is guilty, no part of him is innocent, neque semen neque sanguis, though they have not a distinct guilt, but participative qua partes rei; so we were Sinners in that act, and guilty of that act, so far as we were parts Adami, and in him. 6. This was not to be at that time guilty as distinct persons; for we were not such. 7. But we that were then only seminally inexistent, after became real distinct persons, and then that guilt even of Adam's fact, adhering still to us, became reatus personae, because the Subjects of it are personae. Even as if Eve had been made after the Fall, of Adam's Rib, that Rib at first was guilty, not by another, but the same numerical guilt that Adam was, as part of a Sinner: For it was a capable Subject of no more: But when that same Rib was made a person, it would be a guilty person; For it lost not the guilt by that change. But then it is not only or chiefly our Bodies which are from Adam (which are from the elements in our daily food) but our Souls. And therefore the adherence of the guilt to a rational spirit essentially flowing from another's essence, is more easily understood and defended than that of the corporal Rib could be. 8. I do (contrary to excellent Jos. Placeus) suppose that in primo instanti, this our participation in Adam's guilt is in order before our qualitative pravity: And that God doth therefore deny us his Spirit first, to make us originally holy, not only because Adam, but because we in Adam (as aforesaid) did forfeit and expel it. 9. I think that mens assertion of a Decree or Covenant of God, that if Adam fell, any more should be imputed to his Off-spring than they were thus really guilty of themselves, is the bold addition of mens invention, of greater audacity than the addition of Ceremonies to the Worship of God, which yet some are more sensible of. 10.
Therefore he doth not by arbitrary imputing of Adam's act, and reputing us to have done what we did not, make all men Sinners, which Adam could not do. 5. But God doth truly repute us to have been seminally in Adam, and to have no Essence but what is really derived from his Essence: And as when a man is guilty, no part of him is innocent, neque semen neque sanguis, though they have not a distinct guilt, but participative qua partes rei; so we were Sinners in that act, and guilty of that act, so far as we were partes Adami, and in him. 6. This was not to be at that time guilty as distinct persons; for we were not such. 7. But we that were then only seminally inexistent, after became real distinct persons, and then that guilt even of Adam's fact, adhering still to us, became reatus personae, because the Subjects of it are personae. Even as if Eve had been made after the Fall, of Adam's Rib, that Rib at first was guilty, not by another, but the same numerical guilt that Adam was, as part of a Sinner: For it was a capable Subject of no more: But when that same Rib was made a person, it would be a guilty person; For it lost not the guilt by that change. But then it is not only or chiefly our Bodies which are from Adam (which are from the elements in our daily food) but our Souls. And therefore the adherence of the guilt to a rational spirit essentially flowing from anothers essence, is more easily understood and defended than that of the corporal Rib could be. 8. I do (contrary to excellent Jos. Placeus) suppose that in primo instanti, this our participation in Adam's guilt is in order before our qualitative pravity: And that God doth therefore deny us his Spirit first, to make us originally holy, not only because Adam, but because we in Adam (as aforesaid) did forfeit and expel it. 9. I think that mens assertion of a Decree or Covenant of God, that if Adam fell, any more should be imputed to his Off-spring than they were thus really guilty of themselves, is the bold addition of mens invention, of greater audacity than the addition of Ceremonies to the Worship of God, which yet some are more sensible of. 10.
I think that if Adam had not sinned that same first sin, but had sinned another sin the next hour, or day, or month, or year, or any time before Generation, it would have been equally ours, as this first was, because we were equally in him, and no Scripture-Covenant makes a difference. 11. I think that whereas Adam's sin had twenty particular sins as parts of the whole, we were guilty of all, as well as of the first act or part; else we should not be guilty of his eating the forbidden •ruit; for doubtless that was not the first: His incogitancy, and non-Nolition and sinful Volitions were before it. Yea I doubt not but we are guilty of all the sin that Adam committed, from his first sin till the making of the New-Covenant, at least. 12. I doubt not but if Adam had never sinned, yet (supposing the same Covenant to stand) if his Sons after him had sinned, we should have been guilty of it as we are of his sin: yea had it been but our nearest Parents. 13. I doubt not but that we are still so guilty of our nearer Parents Sins, further than as the introduction of the new pardoning Covenant, and the oft pardons by it, ⟨p. 112⟩and the incapacity of nature, to bear any more punishment, may make a difference. This is not a place voluminously to prove all this. But if any Arminians be tempted to speak doubtingly of this Original Guilt, while they confess Original sinful pravity, 1. Blame your own additions to Gods Covenant, and your obscure writings of the thing; 2. And say not that they deny Original Sin, but express the matter as it is. It seemeth that Arminius by Peccatores & rei constituti sumus meaneth as we do.
I think that if Adam had not sinned that same first sin, but had sinned another sin the next hour, or day, or moneth, or year, or any time before Generation, it would have been equally ours, as this first was, because we were equally in him, and no Scripture-Covenant makes a difference. 11. I think that whereas Adam's sin had twenty particular sins as parts of the whole, we were guilty of all, as well as of the first act or part; else we should not be guilty of his eating the forbidden •ruit; for doubtless that was not the first: His incogitancy, and non-Nolition and sinful Volitions were before it. Yea I doubt not but we are guilty of all the sin that Adam committed, from his first sin till the making of the New-Covenant, at least. 12. I doubt not but if Adam had never sinned, yet (supposing the same Covenant to stand) if his Sons after him had sinned, we should have been guilty of it as we are of his sin: yea had it been but our nearest Parents. 13. I doubt not but that we are still so guilty of our nearer Parents Sins, further than as the introduction of the new pardoning Covenant, and the oft pardons by it,
C. I must confess your explication is rational and concilatory: But how can you excuse Corvinus?