A26883:3556
Richard Baxter's Catholic theology plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriors who, 1. by contending about things unrevealed or not understood, 2. and by taking verbal differences for real,Richard Baxter's Catholick theologie plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriours who, 1. by contending about things unrevealed or not understood, 2. and by taking verbal differences for real,
London: printed by Robert White for Nevill Simmons, 1675
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
A. You have made us hitherto believe that the Controversies about Predestination and Redemption, are all resolved into those of Free-will and Grace, and if there be no difference here, there can be none there. Let us now then come to the core of the Controversy, which is all.
A. You have made us hitherto believe that the Controversies about Predestination and Redemption, are all resolved into those of Free-will and Grace, and if there be no difference here, there can be none there. Let us now then come to the core of the Controversie, which is all.
1. The Calvinists deny sufficient Grace, *and so make all men that are damned to suffer for mere Impossibilities, having no Grace to enable them to escape Sin or Misery; And consequently that Adam's sin only was avoidable, for which all the World is cast into a necessity of sinning, and none but a few elect ones have ever had so much as the possibility of any true remedy. Yea many of them deny that Adam himself had sufficient Grace.
1. The Calvinists deny sufficient Grace, *and so make all men that are damned to suffer for meer Impossibilities, having no Grace to enable them to escape Sin or Misery; And consequently that Adam's sin only was avoidable, for which all the World is cast into a necessity of sinning, and none but a few elect ones have ever had so much as the possibility of any true remedy. Yea many of them deny that Adam himself had sufficient Grace.
B. 1. The word [Sufficient] is sometimes taken, for all that is any way needful, and so it is that they commonly deny sufficiency of uneffectual Grace. More Grace might have certainly produced the Effect. A man is commonly said to have enough who needeth no more. Now more is here useful, needful, desirable to the facilitating and ascertaining the event. If you are not agreed with them in this, why do you pray for more Grace, and labour for more, and take it to be a sign of sincerity to desire more. For if the Regenerate have not Grace enough, surely the Unregenerate have not. 2. But in this Controversy the Dominicans and Jesuits, by sufficient, mean that which giveth the posse agere, that is, so much as is of absolute necessity to the act, without which it cannot be done, and with which alone it can or may be done. And in this sense the Protestants generally, and the Synod of Dort particularly deny not that there is such a thing ⟨p. 131⟩as sufficient Grace. I have oft told you, that 1. They confess it in the instance of Adam. 2. They confess it in the case of common Grace, enabling men to common preparatory duty, which many are able to do, and do not; as I have evinced before in many instances, and the Synod, and specially the British and Bremen Divines assert. 3. And as to the point of Faith it self, whether any unregenerate man have sufficient Grace to believe, which is not effectual, I find few meddling much with it. 4. But they commonly (I think) agree, that all regenerate men themselves have sufficient Grace for many an act of Faith, Love, Obedience which they never do. Is it not one of the Opinions which at Dort and frequently these Divines reject, as falsely imputed to them, that a man can do no more good, and forbear no more evil than he doth? And if he can do more, he hath power to do more: And power to act, is that which is called sufficient Grace. Therefore I need not trouble you any more with this Controversy, seeing under both the notions of Power and Liberty, it is decided, and confessed by you to be so before. Remember that all sufficient Grace is effectual; but not effectual to the act: It doth efficere potentiam, enableth men to act: but doth not cause the act it self, unless it be efficax ad actum, as well as ad potentiam.
B. 1. The word [Sufficient] is sometimes taken, for all that is any way needful, and so it is that they commonly deny sufficiency of uneffectual Grace. More Grace might have certainly produced the Effect. A man is commonly said to have enough who needeth no more. Now more is here useful, needful, desirable to the facilitating and ascertaining the event. If you are not agreed with them in this, why do you pray for more Grace, and labour for more, and take it to be a sign of sincerity to desire more. For if the Regenerate have not Grace enough, surely the Unregenerate have not. 2. But in this Controversie the Dominicans and Jesuites, by sufficient, mean that which giveth the posse agere, that is, so much as is of absolute necessity to the act, without which it cannot be done, and with which alone it can or may be done. And in this sense the Protestants generally, and the Synod of Dort particularly deny not that there is such a thing
How ordinarily do they profess the possibility of doing more than is done, by godly and ungodly, and that all the power that men have is not reduced into act. Yea when some assert Predetermination it self, they say that it doth not destroy Liberty or Power ad contrarium, but only determine it.
A. It is bad enough that they deny all sufficient Grace to believe that is not effectual, though not to other acts.
B. You wrong them: They do not so: Have I not told you now, that they commonly grant that even the godly themselves have sufficient Grace to believe, which is not effectual as to many an act of Faith? And as to Unbelievers, 1. They say that all have not Grace sufficient or necessary to believe: And so say the Arminians. 2. But whether any one have or no, who believe not, they rather leave it to the Searcher of hearts as an unknown thing to them, than deny it. But they seem to infer that it is most likely to be so, in that 1. It is so with the godly themselves. 2. And with all other men, as to other acts of common Grace. And they all agree (as I said before) that no man is denied power to believe savingly, but for not using as he could his antecedent commoner Grace. And I think neither Party knoweth more than this, and in this both are agreed. And he that will assert his uncertain Conjectures, and then pretend that this is a Church-Controversy, is the maker but not the ender of Controversies.
B. You wrong them: They do not so: Have I not told you now, that they commonly grant that even the godly themselves have sufficient Grace to believe, which is not effectual as to many an act of Faith? And as to Unbelievers, 1. They say that all have not Grace sufficient or necessary to believe: And so say the Arminians. 2. But whether any one have or no, who believe not, they rather leave it to the Searcher of hearts as an unknown thing to them, than deny it. But they seem to infer that it is most likely to be so, in that 1. It is so with the godly themselves. 2. And with all other men, as to other acts of common Grace. And they all agree (as I said before) that no man is denied power to believe savingly, but for not using as he could his antecedent commoner Grace. And I think neither Party knoweth more than this, and in this both are agreed. And he that will assert his uncertain Conjectures, and then pretend that this is a Church-Controversie, is the maker but not the ender of Controversies.
A. Some of them stick not to say that Adam himself had not Grace sufficient to stand, or forbear sinning: and if so, then there is none such.
B. We have nothing to do with any odd persons words. Who is it that never speaketh amiss? I confess Dr. Twice, Vind. Grat. l. 1. par. 3. de Reprob. sect. 2. pag. (Vol. minor) 306. saith, Gratiam ad peccatum vitandum necessariam duplicem esse dicimus; aliam ad posse vitare peccatum; aliam ad pecatum actu vitandum: illa est Gratia Regenerationis—Altera non in est homini per modum habitus, sed per modum passionis; & est motio quaedam gratiosa in voluntatem influens, & ad omnem sanctam actionem extimulans.—And so one or two say that Adam had Grace necessary ad posse stare, non autem ad actum. But this is but a few mens odd ⟨p. 132⟩Opinion, contrary to plain truth. I mean, If by necessary ad actum be meant in the proper School-sense (not all that is conducible to ascertain it, but) that sine quo esse non potest, it is a contradiction to say that men have the power to Act, and yet want that which is necessary to the Act, that is, that without which they cannot Act. It is plainly, [They Can] and [They Cannot] (For we talk not de potentia passiva which a Stone, Tree, or a Beast, or a mad Man have). This distinguishing of things that differ not, must be detected, as well as confusion avoided. To say a man can believe, or hath power to believe, and yet wants that without which he cannot believe, is palpable contradiction. And where he maketh Regeneration to give the posse, before the Act, he speaketh obscurely or unsoundly. Gods active Influx on the Will, exciting it to Act, is (at least) part of his Regenerating Grace. A man is not Regenerate before he ever actually believed or repented; though he first receive the Divine Influx ad agendum: Nor can he prove that any proper habit goeth before the first act. And whether it do or not, most certainly the nature, faculty, and the habit, and all together, is truly and formally no power ad hoc, to believe or love God, or do any good, without Gods necessary Influx, Concurse or exciting Grace: No more than a Plant hath a power to fructify without the Sun or Earth: Of Gods help ad bene esse we speak not: But to say that Gods exciting Grace is necessary ad actum, without which the Act cannot be, and yet that we have a power to do that Act without that Grace, is still a contradiction. This is potentia hypothetica & aequivoca, a term fit to play with:
B. We have nothing to do with any odd persons words. Who is it that never speaketh amiss? I confess Dr. Twisse, Vind. Grat. l. 1. par. 3. de Reprob. sect. 2. pag. (Vol. minor) 306. saith, Gratiam ad peccatum vitandum necessariam duplicem esse dicimus; aliam ad posse vitare peccatum; aliam ad pecatum actu vitandum: illa est Gratia Regenerationis—Altera non in est homini per modum habitus, sed per modum passionis; & est motio quaedam gratiosa in voluntatem influens, & ad omnem sanctam actionem extimulans.—And so one or two say that Adam had Grace necessary ad posse stare, non autem ad actum. But this is but a few mens odd
But it is true power, where nothing of absolute necessity sine quo non esse potest is wanting, which our Divines do commonly confess that Adam had, and that all men good and bad have to more good than they do. Therefore I find not that you are in that disagreed. And Dr. Twice, as I told you, oft and vehemently professeth, Vindic. Grat. de Amis. Grat. Cont. Bellar. pag. (Vol. Minor) 230. c. 2. & 232. that man hath no necessity of sinning ex decreto, but logical consequentiae: But if it were true that we wanted that Grace which is absolutely necessary to avoid sin, it must needs follow that such are under an absolute present necessity consequentis also of sinning; as much as of dying, when God ceaseth to continue life. And if he mean that the Decree necessitateth not sin, but the denying of necessary Grace doth, he should have said so. Andr. Rivet Disput. 7. de Grat. Univers. p. 113. saith, [Sed non quemadmodum Pomificii & alii qui eorum sententiam vel sequuntur vel interpolant, nobis imponunt, ita ut plane negemus sufficientis Gratiae phrasin posse usurpari, aut dicamus nullam esse sufficientem ullo modo, quae efficax non sit, vel nullam esse efficacem quae ad conversionem & salutem non sit efficax—Id tantum dicimus, non dari omnibus talem Gratiam sufficientem, quae ita moveat omnium hominum voluntates, ut sit in potestate electionis motioni aut obtemperare, aut res•agari: adeoque nullum esse qui per talem gratiam non possit ad salutem pervenire, Deumque id velle omnibus & intendere.] You see that he will own no more, but the denial of a universal sufficient Grace for Salvation, intended of God, to all men. And you your selves confess, 1. That God intendeth not Salvation for all men, unless conditionally, if they believe and repent, which from eternity he knew before he made them, that they would not. 2. And that all men have not sufficient Grace to Salvation, no nor to believe, but ⟨p. 133⟩only to make them better, and bring them nearer it, and prepare them for it; (which some call Grace mediately sufficient to Salvation; but that's an improper Speech, as long as for want of their Obedience, they never attain to much that is absolutely necessary.) For my part I doubt not to assert, 1. That no man in the World hath Grace sufficient for Salvation, that is, Glorification, an hour before he dieth: For he cannot be saved without more;
But it is true power, where nothing of absolute necessity sine quo non esse potest is wanting, which our Divines do commonly confess that Adam had, and that all men good and bad have to more good than they do. Therefore I find not that you are in that disagreed. And Dr. Twisse, as I told you, oft and vehemently professeth, Vindic. Grat. de Amis. Grat. Cont. Bellar. pag. (Vol. Minor) 230. c. 2. & 232. that man hath no necessity of sinning ex decreto, but logical consequentiae: But if it were true that we wanted that Grace which is absolutely necessary to avoid sin, it must needs follow that such are under an absolute present necessity consequentis also of sinning; as much as of dying, when God ceaseth to continue life. And if he mean that the Decree necessitateth not sin, but the denying of necessary Grace doth, he should have said so. Andr. Rivet Disput. 7. de Grat. Univers. p. 113. saith, [Sed non quemadmodum Pomificii & alii qui eorum sententiam vel sequuntur vel interpolant, nobis imponunt, ita ut plane negemus sufficientis Gratiae phrasin posse usurpari, aut dicamus nullam esse sufficientem ullo modo, quae efficax non sit, vel nullam esse efficacem quae ad conversionem & salutem non sit efficax—Id tantum dicimus, non dari omnibus talem Gratiam sufficientem, quae ita moveat omnium hominum voluntates, ut sit in potestate electionis motioni aut obtemperare, aut resagari: adeoque nullum esse qui per talem gratiam non possit ad salutem pervenire, Deumque id velle omnibus & intendere.] You see that he will own no more, but the denial of a universal sufficient Grace for Salvation, intended of God, to all men. And you your selves confess, 1. That God intendeth not Salvation for all men, unless conditionally, if they believe and repent, which from eternity he knew before he made them, that they would not. 2. And that all men have not sufficient Grace to Salvation, no nor to believe, but
that is, without the Grace of perseverance to the end. But every believing Penitent hath Grace sufficient and effectual to give him a present Right to Salvation. And 2. I add, that there is no such thing as Grace sufficient to Salvation which is not effectual, and doth not save. Seeing all that persevere in holiness are saved; and they that do not, have not Grace sufficient (that is, necessary) to Salvation. 3. And I add, that no man hath Grace sufficient to give him a Right to Christ, and Pardon and Salvation, which is not effectual, and doth not procure it. For every penitent true Believer hath that Right to Christ, Pardon and Life: And he that is not a penitent Believer, hath not Grace sufficient to obtain that Right.
A. Yes, if he have sufficient to help him to believe.
B. Not so: unless he actually believe: For is not Faith in act, somewhat more than power to believe? When you confess that men are damned that have the Power, but not that have the Act.