A26883:3688
Richard Baxter's Catholic theology plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriors who,…Richard Baxter's Catholick theologie plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriours who,…
Richard Baxter's Catholic theology plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriors who, 1. by contending about things unrevealed or not understood, 2. and by taking verbal differences for real,Richard Baxter's Catholick theologie plain, pure, peaceable, for pacification of the dogmatical word-warriours who, 1. by contending about things unrevealed or not understood, 2. and by taking verbal differences for real,
London: printed by Robert White for Nevill Simmons, 1675
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
For from thence they have plainly inferred the subversion of all morality as distinct from physical motion, and consequently of all true Religion. I deny not that I find my self the Controversy in it self exceeding difficult; and that I have not been without temptations to their Opinion, nor yet am: And that indeed, all pretended middle ways between Hobbes, his Necessitation Physical, and true Free-will, are but fancies as far as I can perceive. And if I leave true Free-will, I must turn to their necessitation. I confess their arguing is very plausible; that there is no Effect without a Cause; and that when ever the Will chooseth one thing, and refuseth another, there is some antecedent Cause in the power, disposition, or external things: and that the same Cause in the same state and mode, having no difference in it self, doth always produce the same effect: Otherwise the diversity should have no cause: And that the Will being in the same disposition, and having all the same objects, helps, impediments and other circumstances, will have the same acts. All this is plausible: But 1. If I receive it, I must let go almost all Religion (as well as Christianity); of the truth of which I have a better proof than they can give for their Opinion. And we must not reduce certainties to the obscurest unsearchable uncertainties. 2. And in God himself their foundation is confuted: For he that is the first Cause eodem modo see habens sine ulla diversitate, unicus plurima, immo omnia causat. Therefore their Principle is false. 3. And finding man made after the Image of God, not only as holy, but as man, (Gen. 6.) I have great reason to think that Free-will is part of his natural Image, and that as God is a causa unica plurimorum, so may Free-will be: And that as a God is causa prima entium, so Free-will may be a kind of causa prima (not actionis qua talis, but) of the comparative moral species of its own acts, (as choosing this thing rather than that) which is no addition to real entity, but a wonderful mode of it, which man cannot tell whether he should call something or nothing. 4. I say therefore that here is no Effect without a Cause: Free-will may be the cause of various Effects, without a various predisposition.
For from thence they have plainly inferred the subversion of all morality as distinct from physical motion, and consequently of all true Religion. I deny not that I find my self the Controversie in it self exceeding difficult; and that I have not been without temptations to their Opinion, nor yet am: And that indeed, all pretended middle ways between Hobbes, his Necessitation Physical, and true Free-will, are but fancies as far as I can perceive. And if I leave true Free-will, I must turn to their necessitation. I confess their arguing is very plausible; that there is no Effect without a Cause; and that when ever the Will chooseth one thing, and refuseth another, there is some antecedent Cause in the power, disposition, or external things: and that the same Cause in the same state and mode, having no difference in it self, doth always produce the same effect: Otherwise the diversity should have no cause: And that the Will being in the same disposition, and having all the same objects, helps, impediments and other circumstances, will have the same acts. All this is plausible: But 1. If I receive it, I must let go almost all Religion (as well as Christianity); of the truth of which I have a better proof than they can give for their Opinion. And we must not reduce certainties to the obscurest unsearchable uncertainties. 2. And in God himself their foundation is confuted: For he that is the first Cause eodem modo se habens sine ulla diversitate, unicus plurima, immo omnia causat. Therefore their Principle is false. 3. And finding man made after the Image of God, not only as holy, but as man, (