A26886:1068
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
7. To which purpose, it is not altogether inconsiderable, that the Minister being by Office the Baptizer, and so the Judge of his own Actions, whom he ought to Baptize, and whom not; the action is not Null, though he mistake in his Judgement, and apply the Ordinance to one that he should have refused. For he doth but an act belonging to his Office, though he do it amiss, or on a wrong subject. As if a Judge do pass sentence mistakingly, yet may it be valid, as to some execution; For though he have no power given him directly to pass a wrong Judgement, yet in order to passing a right Judgement, he hath power to follow his own discretion, and to pass such a ⟨p. 319⟩Judgement as shall (at least in tantum) stand, though it prove wrong. I confess the Ministerial Power somewhat differeth from a strict Decisive Judicial power; but yet there is so much resemblance as may serve to illustrate the matter in hand.
Object. Then if a Minister Baptize a Heathen, it is not Null, because he is Judge whom to baptize.
Answ. 1. On the grounds we now go on, it it a contradiction to baptize a Heathen, that by a present profession is such. For Baptizing essentially containeth the persons external Covenant, or Profession of Believing in, and Dedication to the Father, Son and Holy Ghost. If there be not by the person and Minister such a Dedication, it is not Baptism: for if the bare external Washing were Baptism, then we were every day baptized. Now he that is Baptized into the Name of the Father, Son and Holy Ghost, doth thereby renounce Heathenism so far: Though whether his Profession shall be credited, dependeth on the probability of its verity or falsity. But on the first mentioned Definition of Baptism, it will be granted you, that Baptizing a Heathen is not a Nullity, as to the outward Baptism, though it be unprofitable and sinful. But to go on former grounds, I further answer, 2. It is one thing for a Judge to mis-judge a Cause that belongeth to his Judgement; and another to mis-judge a cause that is wholly exempted from his Judgement, and belongeth not to him. In the former, his Judgement may stand, in divers cases, because he was made Judge. In the later it is wholly Null, for he is but a Private man, and hath nothing to do in the business: and therefore whether he judge right or wrong, it is Null; As if a Judge go to another Bench, or into another Circuit, which is out of his Commission: So here, where a man layeth claim to Baptism, and professeth himself a Christian the Minister is to judge whether he do it truly, or falsely; and therefore though he mistake, the Baptism is not Null; For though the man be notoriously ungodly yet it is supposed that the Notoriousness is not absolutely unquestionable, and that the person doth not profess it when he comes to Baptism, but deny it, by professing Faith and Repentance; and so though the Church have sufficient ground to discredit that profession, by reason of hs contradicting Life, yet a Controversy