A26886:114
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The Antecedent is plain in Scripture. No man may Judge (that is, ungroundedly, or without a Call) that would not be Judged. Who art thou that Judgest another mans servant? Rom. 14.4. Therefore we may not Judge them to tell a lye, when we cannot prove it, till they have quite forfeited their credit: no more then we may lawfully Judge a man to be a thief, or murderer, or adulterer, or Heretic, when we cannot prove it. If the slander of the tongue be a sin, so is the slander of the heart.
The Antecedent is plain in Scripture. No man may Judge (that is, ungroundedly, or without a Call) that would not be Judged. Who art thou that Judgest another mans servant? Rom. 14.4. Therefore we may not Judge them to tell a lye, when we cannot prove it, till they have quite forfeited their credit: no more then we may lawfully Judge a man to be a thief, or murderer, or adulterer, or Heretick, when we cannot prove it. If the slander of the tongue be a sin, so is the slander of the heart.
And for the Consequence, it is most clear, that either the Minister must believe the mans Profession, or take him for a Liar; there is no third way that can be pretended, save one, and that is, that we must suspend our belief, and neither Judge his Profession to be true or false. But this cannot be here pretended, with any tolerable appearance of reason. For, 1. God would never make mens profession necessary to their admittance, and put the Minister in the power of Baptizing upon such a Profession, and consequently, of requiring, receiving and Judging of that profession, if we might wholly suspend our Judgement of it whether it be true or false. It cannot be that I can be required, as an officer of Christ to require, and receive a mans Profession, without any respect of the truth of it: for it is therefore required that it may declare the mind: or else, why may not an Infidel be received without Profession: 2. And if I be not to Judge of the truth of a Profession, or of the falsehood; then a Profession apparently false, may be received: but that may not be, as hath been manifested. 3. It is denied by learned Philosophers, that the mind can possibly hang in equilibrio, in such cases. 4. Its one half the uncharitable sin of rash Censures to suspend the Judgement of Charity, and not to Judge the person to speak truth, when he hath not forfeited hs credit, as it is the other half to Judge him positively to speak falsely. 5. A pari, We must not suspend our judgement of the truth of mens Profession of Penitence, that they may be Absolved and Re-admitted to Communion; but must discern whether probably their Profession