A26886:1155
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Obj. Then must we judge falsely, for we must judge men to be what they are not. Answ. 1. If it were so, it is no sin in you, but in them that profess falsely. When ever you judge the most glorious hypocrite to be Godly, you judge falsely; but not sinfully: for every mistake is not our sin. 2. But I say you are not to judg falsely neither. For you are not to judge that it is certain that these are Godly men, but only that its probable. And note well, that there is a difference to be made within the Church, between the better and worser Members, as well as between the Church and those without. And observe, that there are divers degrees of this probability of mens sincerity: some do so fully second their profession by a Godly life, that we have a very strong confidence of their sincerity (though not a certainty). Some do give us some good hopes, but not so strong a persuasion. ⟨p. 345⟩Some are so dull and negligent, and faulty in their lives, that we have much fear of their perdition, though we are bound because of their profession, to keep up some hopes of them, as being not without some probability of their honesty. I doubt the common sort of Christians are but such as these. And therefore we may even in the Church preach for mens Conversion and Regeneration: because though we know not certainly who they be that are unregenerate, yet we know that many such there are that profess Religion, and have great cause of fear and jealousy concerning many in particular. So that we must place a great difference between those whom we must permit in the same Church-communion and must administer the same Sacraments to: we rejoice in our hopes of some: we have much fear of the condemnation of others. Yet if it come not to a strong or violent presumption grounded on sufficient evidence, we may not suspend or cast them out.
Obj. Then must we judge falsly, for we must judge men to be what they are not. Answ. 1. If it were so, it is no sin in you, but in them that profess falsly. When ever you judge the most glorious hypocrite to be Godly, you judge falsly; but not sinfully: for every mistake is not our sin. 2. But I say you are not to judg falsly neither. For you are not to judge that it is certain that these are Godly men, but only that its probable. And note well, that there is a difference to be made within the Church, between the better and worser Members, as well as between the Church and those without. And observe, that there are divers degrees of this probability of mens sincerity: some do so fully second their profession by a Godly life, that we have a very strong confidence of their sincerity (though not a certainty). Some do give us some good hopes, but not so strong a perswasion.