A26886:1229
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. He is commanded to give it Believers, and to you if you will profess that you are a Believer; but withal you are forbidden to profess it if it be false, and therefore that is a sufficient Bar against your claim, Coram Deo in the Judgement of ⟨p. 369⟩God; though its true that Ecclesia Judice, your claim is such even upon a false profession which they cannot deny. If they be commanded to give it you if you claim, and you not commanded and warranted to claim it, then their duty of giving it upon such claim, will prove no title in you before God.
Answ. He is commanded to give it Believers, and to you if you will profess that you are a Believer; but withall you are forbidden to profess it if it be false, and therefore that is a sufficient Bar against your claim, Coram Deo in the Judgement of ⟨p. 369⟩God; though its true that Ecclesia Judice, your claim is such even upon a false profession which they cannot deny. If they be commanded to give it you if you claim, and you not commanded and warranted to claim it, then their duty of giving it upon such claim, will prove no title in you before God.
The next part of my Proposition doth so clearly follow from what is said, that I need not say any more to prove it, It is your sin to claim and receive that Sacrament, which the Minister may deliver to you upon your claim without sin; because you must judge by heart-evidence, but the Minister cannot.
But whereas Mr. Blake doth make it so strange that a Minister may lawfully administer that Sacraments to a man which Coram Deo, he hath no right to (against which he is so confident) I would demand of him whether Coram Deo, or Deo Judice, a man have true title to Sacraments without any faith at all, I mean a downright Infidel or Heathen? If he say, No; then he yieldeth all the cause. For if this Heathen will so far play the Hypocrite as to profess a Dogmatical Faith (as he saith) or a saving faith (as the Church saith) then he will confess that it is the Ministers duty to give him the Sacrament upon his claim; and so he must give it to a man that Deo Judice hath no true right to it. But if he say that such an Heathen hath right to it Deo Judice, I shall not stand now any further to confute him, then 1. to challenge him to prove his Title: And 2. to advise him to be cautelous how he undertaketh to justify his title and claim at the bar of God when the reckoning comes, and these matters must be reviewed.