A26886:1276
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
4. It hath till now been taken for granted that there is a twofold forum or judgement expressed in Mat. 16.19. and Mat. 18.18. Where binding on earth and binding in heaven are distinguished, and loosing on earth and loosing in heaven. The Treatisers that have wrote of the power of the Keys, and the Expositors upon this Text, have not thought that these two were but one, nor did offer so injuriously (that I say not reproachfully) to expound Christs words. If you say that [though they be not the same yet they agree, for that shall be bound or loosed in heaven, which is bound or loosed on earth] I answer; that is, quando clavis non errat. When the Church judgeth justly, as the truth is. For God will not judge erroneously or unjustly because man doth so. Yea though the Churches error be inculpable (as if they absolve or excommunicate a man upon the full testimony of false witness, &c.) yet God will not therefore judge as they. Though he will justify their act of judging, yet he will not censure the true Title of the person to communion accordingly, nor bind or loose in heaven according to any mistaking sentence. Many other Texts do sufficiently evidence this distinction.
4. It hath till now been taken for granted that there is a twofold forum or judgement exprest in Mat. 16.19. and Mat. 18.18. Where binding on earth and binding in heaven are distinguished, and loosing on earth and loosing in heaven. The Treatisers that have wrote of the power of the Keyes, and the Expositors upon this Text, have not thought that these two were but one, nor did offer so injuriously (that I say not reproachfully) to expound Christs words. If you say that [though they be not the same yet they agree, for that shall be bound or loosed in heaven, which is bound or loosed on earth] I answer; that is, quando clavis non errat. When the Church judgeth justly, as the truth is. For God will not judge erroneously or unjustly because man doth so. Yea though the Churches error be inculpable (as if they absolve or excommunicate a man upon the full testimony of false witness, &c.) yet God will not therefore judge as they. Though he will justifie their act of judging, yet he will not censure the true Title of the person to communion accordingly, nor binde or loose in heaven according to any mistaking sentence. Many other Texts do sufficiently evidence this distinction.