A26886:1278
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Arg. 1. If the judgment of God, & the judgment of the Church ⟨p. 384⟩concerning mens Right and claim here be all one, then either the Churches judgement is infallible in this matter, or Gods judgement is fallible. But neither is the Churches judgement infallible, nor Gods judgement fallible. Therefore they are not both one.
The force of the consequence is evident. And for the Minor, 1. To say Gods judgement is fallible, even that which he doth himself immediately exercise (of which we speak) is to Blaspheme. 2. To say that mans judgement here is infallible, is to speak, 1. That which cannot be proved. 2. More than the Papists, yea more than the Italian Papists say of the Popes: For Bellarmine himself will confess him fallible about such personal causes as these; whether such a mans cause be good or bad, &c. 3. If the judgement of man be in this case infallible, then no man was ever wrongfully admitted by the Church, and so the argument would hold à facto ad jus, such a one was admitted: therefore he had Right to claim and Receive: But the consequent is intolerable. For 1. It hindereth all hypocrites in the world (that should believe it) from repenting of their unjust claim and Receiving, and justifieth them all Coram Deo; but sure it will prove an uneffectual justification. 2. The same it doth by all Ministers that ever administered the Sacraments: It teacheth them to justify themselves as infallible, and to disclaim Repentance for any mistake: He that dare tell all the Ministers in the world that they never gave a man a Sacrament without Right Coram Deo, or all the Receivers in the world, that they never received it without such Right as will warrant their claim and Receiving, will show whether the weakness even of good mens arguings may seduce.
The force of the consequence is evident. And for the Minor, 1. To say Gods judgement is fallible, even that which he doth himself immediately exercise (of which we speak) is to Blaspheme. 2. To say that mans judgement here is infallible, is to speak, 1. That which cannot be proved. 2. More than the Papists, yea more than the Italian Papists say of the Popes: For Bellarmine himself will confess him fallible about such personal causes as these; whether such a mans cause be good or bad, &c. 3. If the judgement of man be in this case infallible, then no man was ever wrongfully admitted by the Church, and so the argument would hold à facto ad jus, such a one was admitted: therefore he had Right to claim and Receive: But the consequent is intolerable. For 1. It hindereth all hypocrites in the world (that should believe it) from repenting of their unjust claim and Receiving, and justifieth them all Coram Deo; but sure it will prove an uneffectual justification. 2. The same it doth by all Ministers that ever administred the Sacraments: It teacheth them to justifie themselves as infallible, and to disclaim Repentance for any mistake: He that dare tell all the Ministers in the world that they never gave a man a Sacrament without Right Coram Deo, or all the Receivers in the world, that they never received it without such Right as will warrant their claim and Receiving, will shew whether the weakness even of good mens arguings may seduce.