A26886:1350
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To these I find you add another, the greatest of all, pag. 611. which you say sinks deep into you: but if reason will do it, I will pluck it up by the roots; partly by desiring you to peruse what I have twice or thrice before answered to it, and partly by adding as followeth; That 1. If a man by mistaken doubtings shall keep himself away from a Sacrament, that doth not destroy his Title to it or the Grace signified, nor is it any ones fault but his own. I therefore deny your Minor: It is not this doctrine that cuts off doubting Christians from the Sacrament, but themselves that do culpably withdraw. To your Prosyllogism; I deny the Major: that doctrine which concludes it sin in the doubtful Christian to Receive, doth not cut him off: For it concludeth it not his sin to Receive in it self, but to Receive doubtingly: so that it is not Receiving, but Doubting, that is properly his sin: and withal we say, that it is his Duty to Receive, and his greater Sin not to ⟨p. 405⟩Receive than to Receive. And though an erring Conscience doth always ensnare, and so create a necessity of sinning which way soever we go, till it be rectified, yet its a greater sin to trespass against a plain precept, than against an erring Conscience in many cases. But the main stress lieth on your proof, which is from Rom. 14.23. [Whatsoever is not of faith is sin.] But I could wish you would consider it better, before you press home that Text to the same sense against all other duties as you do against this, lest you leave God but little service from the Church. 1. It is one thing to doubt about indifferent matters, such as Paul speaks of, as eating, &c. For there he is condemned if he eat; because he is sure it is lawful to forbear; but not sure that it is lawful to eat. But press not this upon us in case of necessary duty. If God command me to pray, praise or communicate, my doubt will not justify my forbearance; and though it entangle me in sin, it cannot disoblige me from duty; but I shall sin more if I forbear.
To these I find you add another, the greatest of all, pag. 611. which you say sinks deep into you: but if reason will do it, I will pluck it up by the roots; partly by desiring you to peruse what I have twice or thrice before answered to it, and partly by adding as followeth; That 1. If a man by mistaken doubtings shall keep himself away from a Sacrament, that doth not destroy his Title to it or the Grace signified, nor is it any ones fault but his own. I therefore deny your Minor: It is not this doctrine that cuts off doubting Christians from the Sacrament, but themselves that do culpably withdraw. To your Prosyllogism; I deny the Major: that doctrine which concludes it sin in the doubtful Christian to Receive, doth not cut him off: For it concludeth it not his sin to Receive in it self, but to Receive doubtingly: so that it is not Receiving, but Doubting, that is properly his sin: and withall we say, that it is his Duty to Receive, and his greater Sin not to