A26886:1351
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
You say [If it be sin for the unregenerate to Receive, then cannot the doubting Christian be persuaded, and consequently sinneth.] Ans. True: but that's not long of the doctrine, but of his error: and it is the case of all practical errors; which will not therefore justify you in blaming the doctrine: its the unavoidable effect of an erring Conscience. And again I say, he sinneth more in forbearing.
You say [If it be sin for the unregenerate to Receive, then cannot the doubting Christian be perswaded, and consequently sinneth.] Ans. True: but thats not long of the doctrine, but of his error: and it is the case of all practical errors; which will not therefore justifie you in blaming the doctrine: its the unavoidable effect of an erring Conscience. And again I say, he sinneth more in forbearing.
Whereas you conclude this Argument to be convincing, I have told you before why it convinceth not me: but to your selves I would ask, whether it do not also convince you that your own doctrine is as unsufferable? For I am past doubt that not only most Christians, but even most doubting Christians have more knowledge that they have true justifying faith, than the rest of the world have, that they have true Dogmatical faith. Though the wicked doubt less, because they believe and regard it less, yet indeed they have not only far more cause to doubt of the truth of their Dogmatical faith, but have less true knowledge of it. At least many of them its thus with, when so many true Christians do as much doubt of their Dogmatical faith, as of any. Now what will you do with all these? If you take their ⟨p. 406⟩faith it self (though common) to be their Title, then they must according to you, all keep a way, while they doubt of it: And if it be but the verbal profession of that Dogmatical faith that is their Title, before God, and their own Conscience, then any infidel may make himself a Title at pleasure by a lye, and the bare opus operatum of speaking the words which he never believed, but derideth the sense while he uttereth the terms. As you will save your own Communicants from condemning themselves then for want of Assurance of their Lower faith, so shall you direct us to do by ours.