A26886:1355
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
You say [Giving and Receiving being Relata, all those Texts that prove it the duty of any to Receive the Sacrament, doth eo nomine oblige the Minister to deliver it to them, or admit them; because posito uno Relatorum, ponitur alterum. ]
Answ. Must Logic do the deed at last? If so, it will give us leave to distinguish between Relata secundùm dici & secundùm esse; simplices & duplices relations, &c. Ponitur autem hoc unum Relatorum vel in esse, vel in debito: If you speak of the former, then you know 1. that our Giving is not effectual Giving, but Offering, when it goes before Receiving: and 2. that as scibile may be sine scientiâ, as existent; so Offering may be without Receiving, though not Receiving in our present sense without Offering: therefore one of these may be put without the other. But I suppose it is Debitum offerendi, & recipiendi, which you think are thus related. But 1. here the debitum offerendi goes first, and the debitum recipiendi comes after, and is but conditional and not actual, till the very act of oblation. You may be bound to Offer ⟨p. 407⟩your people the Sacrament, and not perform your duty: they are not bound to Receive it, when you are bound to Offer it; but only on condition or supposition that you actually do Offer it: so that it is not your duty and theirs that are connected as Relata: else they should be bound to Receive that which is not offered them; for you may neglect your duty. Nor is it your actual Offering and their actual Receiving that are inseparably connected as perfect Relates; for you may offer it, when it shall be refused.
Answ. Must Logick do the deed at last? If so, it will give us leave to distinguish between Relata secundùm dici & secundùm esse; simplices & duplices relationes, &c. Ponitur autem hoc unum Relatorum vel in esse, vel in debito: If you speak of the former, then you know 1. that our Giving is not effectual Giving, but Offering, when it goes before Receiving: and 2. that as scibile may be sine scientiâ, as existent; so Offering may be without Receiving, though not Receiving in our present sense without Offering: therefore one of these may be put without the other. But I suppose it is Debitum offerendi, & recipiendi, which you think are thus related. But 1. here the debitum offerendi goes first, and the debitum recipiendi comes after, and is but conditional and not actual, till the very act of oblation. You may be bound to Offer