A26886:1361
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To all this I answer: 1. I do not think you ever read such a distinction as you here frame: at least not from him, whom (you know) I have reason to think you intend. Doubtless, he that hath Right to be admitted, hath also in eodem foro a Right on his own part to Ordinances. This is not fairly done: Indeed a Right of Admission may be in the Minister, (who is another subject) when yet the party hath no Right (of the same sort) to be admitted, or to seek or Receive.
But we must once more consider your Canon de relatis. And to what is said before, let me deal plainlier with you, and tell you that the things in question are not Relata: For though actual Giving and Receiving have some kind of Relation, yet several Rights, viz. the Jus dandy, & Jus accipiendi, are not Relates. Show us if you can, how Jus ad Jus refertur.
But we must once more consider your Canon de relatis. And to what is said before, let me deal plainlier with you, and tell you that the things in question are not Relata: For though actual Giving and Receiving have some kind of Relation, yet several Rights, viz. the Jus dandi, & Jus accipiendi, are not Relates. Shew us if you can, how Jus ad Jus refertur.
Moreover, the Distinction which is used by those whom you here oppose, is (not as you feign it, but) between [a Right Coram Deo to claim and receive the Sacraments] and [a Right or Duty of the Minister to give it upon claim or demand.] Now the former Right is actual and positive; the later but suppositive: Demanding or seeking is supposed to go before my giving, and my right and duty to give: And I think (according to my small skill in Logic) Demanding and Giving are no inseparable Relates; and I am content that any beggar at your door be Judge: This or nothing you must prove to your purpose. And if you prove it, I may the next time I see you demand all your Estate and Learning; and what will you do then? And (with submission to the Judgement of better Lawyers, especially the Learned Citer of your words) I conceive that [a Right of delivering on supposition of a demand or claim] doth not so necessarily suppose a Right to demand and claim, as one Relate supposeth its Correlate. If a man demand your coat (upon terms of violence) you may give him your cloak also; and yet no more justify his demand, than you justify his smiting you by turning the other cheek. But if I should be mistaken in these Law-matters, I must remember Mr. Prin, that when ever he delivereth to soldiers the key of his house to prevent the breaking open the doors, or delivereth them his Arms or moneys to save his life, or a contribution to save the rest, he justifieth their Right to claim all this. And by the same rule when ever he went to prison at their command, he justified their right of commanding him: For Commanding and Obeying are as much Relates, as Demanding and Delivering are.