A26886:1381
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
So that if these be not mistaken, I may call the same term Analogical and Equivocal, yea and I must call it either Univocal or Equivocal when I have called it Analogical. To the same purpose have written R•da, Antonius Andreas, Francis. Mayo, Trombetta, Pendasius, Bonettus, Joan. Canonicus, Scribonius in Pantalit. Raconisius and others. And Guil. Camerarius Scotus in Part 3. Disput. Philosoph. select. maketh it his first question, and determineth it as all the Scotists, Nulla dari Analoga media distincta ab univocis & aequivocis, pag. 304.305, 306, 307. So Irenaus Brassavolus in Scoti universalia, q. 7. & 8. so that if this hold, the Opponents must prove that Hypocrites are ⟨p. 446⟩Christians, Saints, Church-members, &c. univocally as well as Analogically, or else they will prove to be such but equivocally.
So that if these be not mistaken, I may call the same term Analogical and Equivocal, yea and I must call it either Univocal or Equivocal when I have called it Analogical. To the same purpose have written R•da, Antonius Andreas, Francis. May•o, Trombetta, Pendasius, Bonettus, Joan. Canonicus, Scribonius in Pantalit. Raconisius and others. And Guil. Camerarius Scotus in Parte 3. Disput. Philosoph. select. maketh it his first question, and determineth it as all the Scotists, Nulla dari Analoga media distincta ab univocis & aequivocis, pag. 304.305, 306, 307. So Irenaus Brassavolus in Scoti universalia, q. 7. & 8. so that if this hold, the Opponents must prove that Hypocrites are ⟨p. 446⟩Christians, Saints, Church-members, &c. univocally as well as Analogically, or else they will prove to be such but equivocally.
I know other Schoolmen are of another mind; and indeed they are of so many minds about the very sense of the word Analogum, and the true nature of Analogy, that it may well make us despair of a fair end of this Controversy. They are not so much agreed wherein it is that Analogy doth consist: some say that it consisteth in dependentia: and some (as Petr. Hurtado de Mendoza, Disput. Logic. 9. sect. 4. subject. 5.) in transcendentia, &c. Read but Hurtado himself of this, Disput. 9. from pag. 111. to 124. and see whether there be not opinions enough about Analogy, to warrant us to despair of a determination of this Controversy, from the Consent of the Learned. Should I but tell you out of Tartaretus in 1. sent. dist. 3. qu. 3. and Rada, and others, of the threefold Univocation, Logical, Physical and Metaphysical, and the Description of each, and out of Francis. de Marchia of the four several degrees of Univocation, and many more distinctions which must be taken in, if we would exactly discuss this point, you will think before we have done that the Matter is not worth our pains. In a word, seeing our Controversy (as is said) is de nomine; and the Custom of Artists is the only Judge that can determine such Controversies, and they are here all in pieces among themselves, as much as about almost any one word in use with them, as far as I can remember, it followeth that Mr. Blake and I must stay for a decision till our Judges are agreed, what Analogy is.