A26886:1387
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And first the Word [Church] in its general sense is not the thing that we have now in question: Otherwise I should soon confess that in all Assemblies there is something common: a Congregation of materials is common to them all. And thus it may as well be said that the word Ecclesia is univocally spoken of a mutinous confused tumult, Act, 19.32, 39, 40. or any other common Assembly; as of an Assembly of mere Professors. But it is a Christian Church than we are speaking of; which being Coetus Fidelium, vel Christianorum, is differenced from other societies by the Matter, and by the End. And for the first: If bare Professors are but equivocally called Christians or believers in Christ, then they are but equivocally Church-members, nor a Church as consisting of such, but equivocally a Church. But the antecedent is true, therefore so is the Consequent. The Consequence is undeniable, because it is not a Congregation or Society in general, but the Christian Church thus specified by its Matter and End, which we speak of, as is said. The Antecedent I prove, reducing the Paronyma into the Abstracts; and first of the term Believers: If Faith ⟨p. 448⟩be but equivocally attributed to the bare Professors and the true Believers, then they are equivocally called Believers. But the Antecedent is true, as I prove thus: If the name of faith be the same, and the ratio substantiae secundum illud nomen, be divers, then faith ascribed to bare Professors and to true Believers is an aequivocum. But the Antecedent is true, as is most apparent: For that its the same name [Faith, Belief, Believers] we are agreed: And that it is not the thing in both that is thus named, I think we are also agreed. For in one sort, it is a true saving Faith, that is called by the name of [Faith]: and in the other, it is no faith at all, but the bare verbal Profession of that faith which they have not. And I hope we are agreed, that faith, and the Profession of Faith, are not the same thing.
And first the Word [Church] in its general sense is not the thing that we have now in question: Otherwise I should soon confess that in all Assemblies there is something common: a Congregation of materials is common to them all. And thus it may as well be said that the word Ecclesia is univocally spoken of a mutinous confused tumult, Act, 19.32, 39, 40. or any other common Assembly; as of an Assembly of meer Professors. But it is a Christian Church than we are speaking of; which being Coetus Fidelium, vel Christianorum, is differenced from other societies by the Matter, and by the End. And for the first: If bare Professors are but equivocally called Christians or believers in Christ, then they are but equivocally Church-members, nor a Church as consisting of such, but equivocally a Church. But the antecedent is true, therefore so is the Consequent. The Consequence is undeniable, because it is not a Congregation or Society in general, but the Christian Church thus specified by its Matter and End, which we speak of, as is said. The Antecedent I prove, reducing the Paronyma into the Abstracts; and first of the term Believers: If Faith