A26886:141
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. 1. A known Lye you may not, you cannot believe: and should you administer the Ordinances upon a Profession which is notorious false, you should profane them 2. But if I believe a Liar when I cannot prove him such, that's none of my sin, nay its m• duty. God made mens tongues to show their minds: and so I am to take their words: but if they will abuse them to lying, that's their own sin, and not mine. 3. If you would believe no man, till you are sure that he saith true, then you must believe no man in the world: For though you may know the thing to be true by other Evidence, yet believing him can give you no certainly of th• truth: for belief dependeth on the credit of the speaker. Your Argument therefore tendeth to the destroying of all humane faith, which is not to be endured. 4. It is but with a humane faith that we believe them: and therefore, we believe them but as deceitful fallible men who may possibly deceive us. It is not with such a faith as we owe to God, wherein we conclude the thing revealed to be so unquestionably true, as that it cannot possibly be false, because God cannot Lye: yea it is with a divers degree of Faith, that we believe divers persons, who are to us of divers degrees of Credibility. And if after all this, we be deceived in the most, the sin is only in the deceiver. And as for us; 1. We proceeded upon that evidence which Nature it self directeth us to take: even a mans words, as the sign of his mind. 2. And upon that Evidence which the holy Examples of the Apostles of Christ have directed us to take; who ⟨p. 31⟩were not rashly venturous nor profaners of Gods Ordinances. 3. And if we be indeed deceived in the most, or in many, its rather a sign that we are in Gods way, than out of it; for as Charity believeth all things (credible) so Christ hath told us, that the tares and wheat must grow together, and that many are called and few chosen: and that in the end he will take out of his Kingdom all things that offend, and them that work Iniquity: therefore such there will be.
Answ. 1. A known Lye you may not, you cannot believe: and should you administer the Ordinances upon a Profession which is notorious false, you should prophane them 2. But if I believe a Lyer when I cannot prove him such, that's none of my sin, nay its m• duty. God made mens tongues to shew their minds: and so I am to take their words: but if they will abuse them to lying, that's their own sin, and not mine. 3. If you would believe no man, till you are sure that he saith true, then you must believe no man in the world: For though you may know the thing to be true by other Evidence, yet beleving him can give you no certainly of th truth: for belief dependeth on the credit of the speaker. Your Argument therefore tendeth to the destroying of all humane faith, which is not to be endured. 4. It is but with a humane faith that we believe them: and therefore, we believe them but as deceitful fallible men who may possibly deceive us. It is not with such a faith as we owe to God, wherein we conclude the thing revealed to be so unquestionably true, as that it cannot possibly be false, because God cannot Lye: yea it is with a divers degree of Faith, that we believe divers persons, who are to us of divers degrees of Credibility. And if after all this, we be deceived in the most, the sin is only in the deceiver. And as for us; 1. We proceeded upon that evidence which Nature it self directeth us to take: even a mans words, as the sign of his mind. 2. And upon that Evidence which the holy Examples of the Apostles of Christ have directed us to take; who