A26886:1436
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And six Reasons he addeth fol. 24. col. 2. And fol. 25. he refuteth Bellarmines Arguments for the contrary, (the same that others since make use of) from Scripture and Reason. Where Bellarmine saith, They cannot be cast out of the Church by Excommunication, if they be not in it; he answereth, [Si Fide & Charitate & Spiritu sancto careant, tum licet vel Praelatorum sedes occupent, vel in Ecclesiae catalogo censeantur, non tamen sunt vera membra Ecclesiae. Nec ad rem facit quod Christus malis Praelatis obaudiendum docet: Hoc en•m sit, quia tales adhuc videntur esse in Ecclesiae—Of a Councils testimony produced by Bellarmine he saith, [Licet Concilium quoddam Et iscoporum in colloq. cum Donatistis fateatur malos esse nonnunquam in Ecclesia velut paleas in area,— non tamen asserit hujusmodi malos esse vera membra Ecclesiae, sed ostendit quid vulgus existimat.
I know the answer to all this must be, that Dr. Sutlive speaks all this only of the Catholic mystical Church, and not of the Visible Church. To which I Reply, 1. He and other Protestants profess, that they hold not that there is two Churches, one Visible and the other Invisible; but one Church, only. 2. And that this one is called Invisible from its essence, and Visible from an adjunct, which is so. 3. And therefore that where there is Profession without true faith, and so men that have only that which denominateth it Visible, without that which denominateth it Invisible, these are only equivocally and not truly members.
I know the answer to all this must be, that Dr. Sutlive speaks all this only of the Catholick mystical Church, and not of the Visible Church. To which I Reply, 1. He and other Protestants profess, that they hold not that there is two Churches, one Visible and the other Invisible; but one Church, only. 2. And that this one is called Invisible from its essence, and Visible from an adjunct, which is so. 3. And therefore that where there is Profession without true faith, and so men that have only that which denominateth it Visible, without that which denominateth it Invisible, these are only equivocally and not truly members.