A26886:1503
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mr. Blake [And whereas Mr. Baxter saith that other Divines generally plead that Hypocrites are not true members of the universal Church, but as a wooden leg to the body: I am almost confident that in turning over all his books, he can produce but few such testimonies,] Had he said [the Catholic Church] instead of [the universal] I believe he might have found many — I think that scarce any man will deny that the universal Church is visible—yet Whitaker as largely makes good that the Catholic Church is invisible: If I be now sent to my Dictionary, to see whether Catholic and Universal be both one —the one a Greek word, the other a Latin; I confess it is so in Grammar, but not in their use of it that handle the question of the Church Catholic in this manner — &c.
Mr. Blake [And whereas Mr. Baxter saith that other Divines generally plead that Hypocrites are not true members of the universal Church, but as a wooden leg to the body: I am almost confident that in turning over all his bookes, he can produce but few such testimonies,] Had he said [the Catholick Church] instead of [the universal] I believe he might have found many — I think that scarce any man will deny that the universal Church is visible—yet Whitaker as largely makes good that the Catholick Church is invisible: If I be now sent to my Dictionary, to see whether Catholick and Vniversal be both one —the one a Greek word, the other a Latine; I confess it is so in Grammer, but not in their use of it that handle the question of the Church Catholick in this manner — &c.
Answ. Wonderful Confidence• Readers, take warning by Mr. Blake and me, and for our sakes be not over credulous, no not in the most palpable matters of fact. You hear Mr. Blake's confidence, and now you shall hear mine. Whether I can cite many such testimonies is partly apparent already. Melanchthon, Calvin, Beza, Ursine, Polanus, Paraeus, Piscator, Zanchy, Junius, and I think I may add an hundred more, do promiscuously use the terms [Catholic] and [Universal] here: and commonly join them thus [Ecclesia Catholica seu Universalis.] I profess, I mention that which mine eyes have many a time punctually observed: and I further profess that I never to this day (to my best remembrance) did read one Author (nor hear of one till M. Blake here speaks it) that did distinguish between the [Catholic and Universal Church;] and though I may not say that no man ever did so, as having not read all, yet I will say, I do not believe that ever one reputed, wise and Orthodox did so, and I think Mr. Blake would have proved it from some one if he could. I take this therefore to be a most injurious reproach to our Divines. Name us one man if you can that ever was guilty of this ridiculous distinction: yea or one Papist that had the front to charge them with such a thing. It is well known that our elder Reformers use to plead against the Papist that particular Churches are visible, but that Ecclesia Catholica seu Universalis is invisible (though you stick not to say that scarce any man will deny the Universal Church to be visible;) and that our latter