A26886:1512
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And first for Mr. Robertson, he that thinks such a book doth need a Reply, is like to profit little by any of mine, and so I leave him to be of what opinion the wind and tide shall drive him to. I have read over a M. S. Book of Mr. Hotchkis which is his vindication against Mr. Robertson; wherein he hath sufficiently and easily done a needless work. To reciprocate gain-sayings with that kind of men, is an unprofitable and unpleasing thing: The sons of contention in their greatest darkness, are more zealous and unwearied in their generation and work, than the Children of light and peace in theirs. Its not desirable to match them in violence, in self-conceitedness, in rashness, or false accusations, in scorns, or loudness, or length of speech. And as peaceable Readers are grieved with such disputes, so usually the Antagonist is more hardened in his mistakes. If you have a friend that erreth, whose recovery you desire, be sure that you write not a confutation of his errors: for ordinarily that's the way to fasten him in them, and make him worse. Some will think this a hard censure, to pass on learned godly men, whose hearts should be devoted to truth, and who pretend to love the light that doth disclose it: But there's no reasoning against common unquestionable experience. Who will doubt whether it can be so, when he sees it is so? Of all the Cart-loads of controversial writings that swarm in the world, how many can you name that convinced the Antagonist, and brought him to a recantation? Bethink your selves how many you can name. Nay how many that did not provoke and harden them? By secret explications, and loving debate, the minds of many have been changed; and many by positive Asserting and proving the truth; and I confess some by controversial writings that were written against others (else I would never meddle that way) but how few by those that are written in confutation of themselves? As soon as you speak to men in the hearing of the world, they presently apprehend their reputation to be so engaged, that they ⟨p. 482⟩are excited to defend it with all their might; and instead of an impartial consideration of your arguments, and a ready entertainment of the truth, they bend their wits to study how to make good what once they have delivered, and to prove that true that once hath past their pens, that the world may not think them so weak as to have mistaken.
And first for Mr. Robertson, he that thinks such a book doth need a Reply, is like to profit little by any of mine, and so I leave him to be of what opinion the winde and tide shall drive him to. I have read over a M. S. Book of Mr. Hotchkis which is his vindication against Mr. Robertson; wherein he hath sufficiently and easily done a needless work. To reciprocate gain-sayings with that kinde of men, is an unprofitable and unpleasing thing: The sons of contention in their greatest darkness, are more zealous and unwearied in their generation and work, than the Children of light and peace in theirs. Its not desirable to match them in violence, in selfconceitedness, in rashness, or false accusations, in scorns, or lowdness, or length of speech. And as peaceable Readers are grieved with such disputes, so usually the Antagonist is more hardened in his mistakes. If you have a friend that erreth, whose recovery you desire, be sure that you write not a confutation of his errors: for ordinarily thats the way to fasten him in them, and make him worse. Some will think this a hard censure, to pass on learned godly men, whose hearts should be devoted to truth, and who pretend to love the light that doth disclose it: But there's no reasoning against common unquestionable experience. Who will doubt whether it can be so, when he sees it is so? Of all the Cart-loads of controversal writings that swarm in the world, how many can you name that convinced the Antagonist, and brought him to a recantation? Bethink your selves how many you can name. Nay how many that did not provoke and harden them? By secret explications, and loving debate, the mindes of many have been changed; and many by positive Asserting and proving the truth; and I confess some by controversal writings that were written against others (els I would never meddle that way) but how few by those that are written in confutation of themselves? As soon as you speak to men in the hearing of the world, they presently apprehend their reputation to be so engaged, that they