A26886:1529
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And next as to Mr. Blake, I find more cause in his last writings to deter me from all Disputations where pious men may think themselves concerned, than to encourage me to proceed in the justest defence. And I confess it repenteth me for his own sake that ever I defended my self against his accusations, and that I did not silently suffer him to say what he would: though yet I am willing that the equity of the Reasons which I gave for my Replying to him in that Apology, be censured by any impartial man: even those that I have expressed in my preface to that Book. But I could not then see the consequents as to himself.
And next as to Mr. Blake, I find more cause in his last writings to deter me from all Disputations where pious men may think themselves concerned, than to encourage me to proceed in the justest defence. And I confess it repenteth me for his own sake that ever I defended my self against his accusations, and that I did not silently suffer him to say what he would: though yet I am willing that the equity of the Reasons which I gave for my Replying to him in that Apologie, be censured by any impartial man: even those that I have expressed in my preface to that Book. But I could not then see the consequents as to himself.
I am heartily sorry that I have become by my defence, an occasion or temptation of so much offence, and of so much distemper and injustice to a man whom I so much love and honour; should I speak any further for that which I am confident is the truth of God, how much more might I offend and tempt him? I well hoped that he that made the assault on his Brother would have patiently heard an answer; and have been glad of such a collation of our several thoughts as might tend in any measure to beat out the truth. As he thought it was for God that he assaulted me, so I as verily think it was for God and his certain truth that I wrote my defence. And if I be mistaken, why should he be so angry at it? when I know he takes not himself to be infallible. When I wrote […] the Index the contents ⟨p. 489⟩of one section, thus [whether it be virtually written in Scripture that Mr. Blake is justified? and whether it is de fide,] he saith (pag. 336.) that [he did not without trembling of spirit read, nor without tears think upon this thus put to the question.] And whats the reason? why saith he [Who would not believe that I had directly asserted it, or made some unsavoury vaunts about it?] Truly, no man would believe it from these words, that knows what an Index is; but would understand that it tells him the matter that is contained in the page that it referreth him to, and not the matter directly asserted by another. And must we not dispute against that also which is indirectly asserted? I profess it never came into my thoughts that the most render passionate man, that was not melancholy, could have so much matter of offence in those words as to tremble or weep at them. It is a case wherein I must speak of some individual, or I could not speak to the purpose. For its granted that it is not every mans justification that is de fide, nor every justified mans, and yet some mens was. Had I instanced in Peter or Paul, it had been nothing to out business: For I confess that Scripture declareth them to be justified. Titius and Sompronius I knew not, and therefore could not instance in them. Should I have instanced in my self, he might have taken it for sophistical: For the disproof of my own certainty of justification, is no disproof of another mans; whom then could I more reasonably and fitly instance in than the Opponent himself? especially being a man of whose sincerity I am so confident.