A26886:1537
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I must confess that there is one part of the contest between Mr. Blake and me at least, that I think well worthy a review, and that is the question about the nature of that faith which gives Right to Sacraments: For as it is a matter that comes so frequently into practice, and of such moment to particular persons, to Ministers and to the welfare of the Church, so I do not know of any that hath said so much for that cause which I yet account so bad, as Mr. Blake hath done; and indeed he hath put a fairer gloss on this than on any of the rest. And yet in my judgement he hath left it so naked, that a little diligence and impartially may do much to discover his opinions to be inconsistent (if reduced into practice) with the Purity of the Church, and such as is unworthy the patronage of Godly learned men. Yet in this I perceive his writings have success: For I hear that some Reverend Godly men of his acquaintance are so confident that he is in the right, that they marvel that ever I should hold the contrary, and blame me as defending a principal point in the Independent cause. The Lord enlighten us, and pardon it to us, which soever of us it be that is mistaken, and doth wrong the Church of God.
There are four several Titles that are or may be produced to Baptism: The first is sincere Saving Faith: The second is the profession of such sincere Faith: The third is a Dogmatical Faith, short of Justifying Faith: The fourth is a profession of that Dogmatical Faith. I say, that only they that have the Justifying ⟨p. 493⟩Faith, have a Promise-Right to Baptism, properly so called; which I called a Right Coram Deo: but that the professors of such a Faith and their seed have an Analogical Consequential Right which followeth on Gods Precept to a Minister to Baptize them. This I called Right Coram Ecclesiâ, and is less properly a Right. And that the bare word Right might be no occasion of quarrel, I distinguished of Right; and showed how far I affirmed or denied it: But such distinctions and conclusions are nothing to the business with Mr. Blake; but fittest to be passed by. I conclude in a word that every professor of a Justifying Faith (that doth not invalidate his own profession) hath such a claim to Baptism for himself (if unbaptized) and his seed, as the Church must admit: But only the sincere Believer hath a Right from the Promise, and shall be taken by God for one to whom he is actually, as it were, obliged by his Covenant. But for the two later pretended Titles, viz. A Dogmatical Faith not Justifying, and the Profession of such a Faith, I say, they are no just Titles at all. Not but that a man who hath merely a Dogmatical Faith within, may have a Title in Foro Ecclesiae; but this Faith is not his Title, but the profession of a Saving Faith: so that if he profess only his Dogmatical Faith, and not a Saving Faith, the Minister ought not to Baptize him. This is the brief of the state of the Controversy between Master Blake and me: And did I think that any such Reverend Brethren would ever have approved his Judgement in such a cause? Yea and some of them plead from the same effectual mediums, which are alone sufficient to prove the contrary; Its the course of Hilary and others against the Arians; Hierome, Augustine, and many more against the Pelagians, and other heretics, to call them to the constant practice of the Church in Baptizing, for the proving of the nature of that Belief that we are Baptized into, and the quality of the subject.