A26886:1541
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Again I must crave pardon of this confidence: but if it seem to them to come from self-conceitedness and pride of my own judgement, or a loathness to let go what I have once received; as I willingly confess that I find such sins within me, and am no Christian, if I blame them not and hate them not in my self; so I will be bold to tell Mr. Blake and the world the very truth in this business,: which is, that the partiality that I have felt in the study of this point hath been for Mr. Blake's opinion against my own; and I had rather a great while (till the light convinced me) have found his opinion true, than my own. As I knew I should be taken for a defender of the Independents (which is a censure that I little regard) so I thought that I should the better comply with some Texts of the old Testament which Mr. Blake much urgeth, and some other reasons did cause Mr. Blake's opinion sometime so far to smile upon me, that I strove against the contrary truth, and studied all that I could to have confuted the Arguments for it, and was very willing to have found the truth on Mr. Blake's side: but it was too hard for me, and overcame me after some such reluctancy. For besides many other Reasons which I have mentioned, I find that there is no footing for a man in his way. He that will not take up with the bare name of a Dogmatical Faith, knows not (for ought I can find) what to take up with. I despair of ever prevailing with Mr. Blake, let him write never so much more on the subject, to give us a true Definition or Description of that Faith short of Justifying, which entitleth to Baptism, and to prove it from Gods word, or to agree with himself. Commonly he calls it a Dogmatical Faith: one would think now you might know the truth by this plain Name: but when I tell him that if it be merely Dogmatical, then it is only in the understandings Assent, and importeth no consent of the Will, and that this is in the Devils, and may be in those that say, [We will not have this man reign over us, nor be our Saviour, because he will not let us have our lusts] (And would he Baptize those that should say so?) Hereupon Mr. Blake will take some consent of the Will, or else it cannot become a covenanting: but ⟨p. 496⟩sometime he only describes it negatively (that it is not such as comes up to Justifying Faith): but who knows by this what it is? though he tell us what it is not:
Again I must crave pardon of this confidence: but if it seem to them to come from self-conceitedness and pride of my own judgement, or a loathness to let go what I have once received; as I willingly confess that I find such sins within me, and am no Christian, if I blame them not and hate them not in my self; so I will be bold to tell Mr. Blake and the world the very truth in this business,: which is, that the partiality that I have felt in the study of this point hath been for Mr. Blakes opinion against my own; and I had rather a great while (till the light convinced me) have found his opinion true, than my own. As I knew I should be taken for a defender of the Independants (which is a censure that I little regard) so I thought that I should the better comply with some Texts of the old Testament which Mr. Blake much urgeth, and some other reasons did cause Mr. Blakes opinion sometime so far to smile upon me, that I strove against the contrary truth, and studied all that I could to have confuted the Arguments for it, and was very willing to have found the truth on Mr. Blakes side: but it was too hard for me, and overcame me after some such reluctancy. For besides many other Reasons which I have mentioned, I find that there is no footing for a man in his way. He that will not take up with the bare name of a Dogmatical Faith, knows not (for ought I can find) what to take up with. I despair of ever prevailing with Mr. Blake, let him write never so much more on the subject, to give us a true Definition or Description of that Faith short of Justifying, which entitleth to Baptism, and to prove it from Gods word, or to agree with himself. Commonly he calls it a Dogmatical Faith: one would think now you might know the truth by this plain Name: but when I tell him that if it be meerly Dogmatical, then it is only in the understandings Assent, and importeth no consent of the Will, and that this is in the Devils, and may be in those that say, [We will not have this man reign over us, nor be our Saviour, because he will not let us have our lusts] (And would he Baptize those that should say so?) Hereupon Mr. Blake will take some consent of the Will, or else it cannot become a covenanting: but