A26886:1546
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
It hath pleased some of the great Calumniators agents, to censure me as an Arminian, or half one, because I run not so far on the other hand as they. But its a hard case that I am in, who must needs be an Arminian, and yet must be forced to dissent from so dear a friend as Mr. Blake for fear of becoming one. I am confident that Mr. Blake in those points is Orthodox; but so could not I be, if I should entertain his opinion. For if I did believe that upon the acts of common Grace men have covenant or promise-right given them by God to be Baptized, I must needs believe that they had Right to Remission of sin in Christs blood; seeing God appointed no Baptism but what is for the Remission of sin; upon which account I have mightily displeased some Reverend friends that before over-valued me, who are favourers of the Arminian way, merely because I oppose Mr. Blake in this point.
It hath pleased some of the great Calumniators agents, to censure me as an Arminian, or half one, because I run not so far on the other hand as they. But its a hard case that I am in, who must needs be an Arminian, and yet must be forced to dissent from so dear a friend as Mr. Blake for fear of becoming one. I am confident that Mr. Blake in those points is Orthodox; but so could not I be, if I should entertain his opinion. For if I did believe that upon the acts of common Grace men have covenant or promise-right given them by God to be Baptized, I must needs believe that they had Right to Remission of sin in Christs blood; seeing God appointed no Baptism but what is for the Remission of sin; upon which account I have mightily displeased some Reverend friends that before over-valued me, who are favourers of the Arminian way, meerly because I oppose Mr. Blake in this point.
For my part, I still take faith to be the very internal covenanting with God in Christ, and not a condition of our own covenant: ⟨p. 499⟩though it be the condition of Gods covenant or promise: and so that condition of Gods covenant, and our own actual covenanting are one and the same thing: our very first covenanting with him, or consent to his terms, is that faith on which he promiseth us Justification: though there be a further performance required to our Salvation. It is all one, in my account, to believe in Christ, and to become a Christian: and Baptism (commonly called our Christening) is not to engage us to begin to be Christians hereafter: but it is the solemnization of the Christian contract or marriage between Christ and the Soul, which is supposed to be made in heart before: so that they are then actually Christians inaugurated or publicly manifested. And (for all that Mr. Blake hath said to the contrary) he that professeth any faith only, that is short of justifying faith, is not a Christian in the covenant-sense, but is only Equivocally or Analogically so called. And whereas Mr. Blake makes it more tolerable if I had used the word [Analogically] then to use the word [Equivocally,] if he had pleased to observe it, I frequently put them together as here, [Equivocally or Analogically:] so that if that will satisfy him, he might have been satisfied sooner. Yet I take the Scotists controversy to be yet undecided, whether some terms be not both Analogical and Univocal, and some both Analogical and Equivocal; (which they handle on the Question, Utrum Ens dicatur Univocè de Deo & Creaturâ) or rather that the later clause is past doubt; and therefore in our ease it is both. Nor am I yet persuaded that his old Testament covenanters, (which are the great moving instance) did profess only such a faith as was short of Justifying: and they that lived in such scandal as was inconsistent Notoriously with their profession, were by the law to be put to death: and then they were past begetting Children to plead a right in Circumcision.