A26886:1555
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Disputation 5: The fifth Disputation.Disputation 5: The fift Disputation.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
As for Mr. Black's impotent accusations of my owning the cause of the Papists, against the Protestant cause in the matter of Justification, because I misliked the by extreme opinions of some men; as if all had agreed in these opinions, or the Protestant difference with the Papists in the matter of Justification did lye either only or principally in these, I look upon it as such dealing as must be expected from angry men, and as Children of the same Father do sometime use against one another when they fall out. It was doubtless my sin that I was no ⟨p. 504⟩more cancelor• of provoking him, as it is his to be carried to such injustice by his passions, as that and many other passages do contain. But I am confident he forgiveth me, and I am certain I forgive him, and I am persuaded the Lord whom we most offend, in the abundance of his Grace doth forgive us both. I must confess that when I think I have a call to dispute, I do withal think that I am called to lay open the nakedness of the cause which I oppose to the utmost; and being persuaded that I speak against that which is against God, me thinks if I do not effectually manifest its falsehood, I do nothing, whereupon I find, that what is spoken against the cause is taken as a dishonour to the person, and he takes himself to be wounded or wronged by it, when I never touch the person at all: so that if I do but once name the Imposture of a common distinction, Mr. Blake comes on, as if I had called all those learned men cheaters or impostors that use that distinction (between fides, qua, & quâ) yea even those that condescended privately to write to me; and so parallels me with Mr. Craudon herein. Mr. Craudon spoke of persons, and I speak of distinctions and reasons: Is not this a mere violence, as if it were to raise an odium, and set men together by the ears? When I mention the weakness of his own arguing, he tells me, I must not answer a fool according to his folly, and marvels I will set my wit against such a ones. Is not such dealing a sufficient prohibition to dispute? If I show not the weakness of an Argument I do nothing: If I do, I make the Author a fool. If I show that an Argument is unsound, or a conclusion false: I make him false; If I show that some common distinction hath unobservedly deceived many, I make all the Learned that use it impostors, even my friends that privately vouchsafe me their writings.
As for Mr. Blak's impotent accusations of my owning the cause of the Papists, against the Protestant cause in the matter of Justification, because I misliked the by extream opinions of some men; as if all had agreed in these opinions, or the Protestant difference with the Papists in the matter of Justification did lye either only or principally in these, I look upon it as such dealing as must be expected from angry men, and as Children of the same Father do sometime use against one another when they fall out. It was doubtless my sin that I was no