A26886:1608
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. Christ knew what was in man, and need not that any man should tell him, John 2.25. And yet he questioned with men in humane Language; he asketh some whether they believed, and Peter, whether he loved him? Did he expect an answer from men, for the bare words sake? or as a sign of their mind? Did he oblige them to a true answer, or to a false? The case is not doubtful. And if by his omniscience he knew that many of these answers were lies, (and yet he silently permitted the answerer to seem a Disciple) it will not hence follow, that we must accept a profession simply for it self, and when it is not credible, that is, that we must believe a known lye, or that we must use those that we have no cause to believe as if we did believe them.
3. Christ knew what was in man, and need not that any man should tell him, John 2.25. And yet he questioned with men in humane Language; he asketh some whether they believed, and Peter, whether he loved him? Did he expect an answer from men, for the bare words sake? or as a sign of their mind? Did he oblige them to a true answer, or to a false? The case is not doubtfull. And if by his omniscience he knew that many of these answers were lyes, (and yet he silently permitted the answerer to seem a Disciple) it will not hence follow, that we must accept a profession simply for it self, and when it is not credible, that is, that we must believe a known lye, or that we must use those that we have no cause to believe as if we did believe them.
4. And if their Argument were of any strength, it would not only prove that we must keep in the Church, and admit to the Sacrament those that we know to have the Devil in them, and to be Traitors to Christ, contriving the destruction of his Church (as Judas did of his person) and to be Thieves and Deceivers (as Christ knew Judas to be,) and so overthrow all Church Discipline, contrary to the Scripture Laws; but also that it is not Lawful for a Master to put a known Thief and Traitor out of his Family, or to prohibit him familiarity with him at his Table, and dipping his morsels with him in the same dish. For Christ did this by Judas as well as the other. But it is contrary to