A26886:1617
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The Papists and Lutherans indeed are most on the other side: but yet they are divided, especially the Papist: Many Learned Protestants of the Reformed party have written large discourses to prove that Judas received not the Sacrament: we have divers common in English: and the beyond sea Divines are many of this mind. Beza, Grotius, Piscator, Musculus, Deodat, (five of the most judicious commentators, I think, that ever wrote on the sacred Scriptures,) are against Judas participation, (and Calvin thinks it uncertain:) besides Zanchius, Danaeus, Gomarus, Tossanus, and many more that are against it: Though I know that on the other side divers are for it.
The Papists and Lutherans indeed are most on the other side: but yet they are divided, especially the Papist: Many Learned Protestants of the Reformed party have written large discourses to prove that Iudas received not the Sacrament: we have divers common in English: and the beyond sea Divines are many of this mind. Beza, Grotius, Piscator, Musculus, Deodat, (five of the most judicious commentators, I think, that ever wrote on the sacred Scriptures,) are against Iudas participation, (and Calvin thinks it uncertain:) besides Zanchius, Danaeus, Gomarus, Tossanus, and many more that are against it: Though I know that on the other side divers are for it.
And what is there now on the other side to move us to think it probable that Judas did Receive the Sacrament? The slight conjecture of a late learned Annotator I think not fit to trouble you with. I know but one Argument worth the mentioning or much regarding that is brought: and that is from the order of Lukes words, who after the mention of the Sacrament saith, [But behold the hand of him that betrayeth me is with me on the Table.] But to this I must say that I confess it moveth me ⟨p. 530⟩not to doubt of the matter, considering, 1. that as Grotius & other expositors truly note, it is so usual with Luke to disregard the Order of things spoken, and to repeat sayings together as one continued speech which were spoken at great distance; and to put that before which was spoken after, and that after which was spoken before: Not by mistake, but because it was the Matter and not the Order that he there purposed to deliver. 2. And because it is certain that he doth thus even in the matter in hand, for saith Grotius in ver. 21. Diversos Christi srmones nullâ ordinis habita ratione connectit Lucas. Nam illud de proditore, in Coenâ justâ contigit: admonitio de vitanda ambitione planè ut credibile est, in lotione inter coenam paschalem & coenam justam. Ita [Greek or Hebrew] saepe Luce est [Greek or Hebrew]. And as Calvin concludes, we cannot from this order in Luke gather that Judas Received. And saith Beza, Apparet omnino ex aliis evangelistis ac praesertim,