A26886:465
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The 6. Argument is from experience: To which I answer; All the experiences which Mr. Blake mentioneth, are not only nothing for his cause, but abundantly destructive to it. Many have been unwakened by fears of receiving unworthily to their condemnation, as wicked men do: will it follow, that therefore they may receive it who are wicked and unworthy? or that there is no such danger to them if they do: Or rather that they should not receive while they are such, and that there is danger if they do; sure it is some danger that is the matter of their fear, & some threatening which is the ground: if it be their du•y to receive it even while they know themselves to be wicked, because it is an appointed means to their conversion, what need they so to fear it, unless they fear the means of their own good? If they say, it is the unworthy receiving which they fear; Its true, but that is to receive it in state of wickedness, Impenitence and unbelief, as all the unregenerate do: surely it is the wrath of ⟨p. 144⟩God and eternal damnation which they fear, therefore they fear least it should fix them in that state. But your worthy communicant is in state of damnation, when only our unworthy communicant is such. Moreover will it follow, that because other mens doctrine which are against you doth put men into these fears which occasion their conversion, that therefore your doctrine which abateth such fears is sound? 2. Or will it follow that Receiving converteth, because the fears of unworthy Receiving do convert or conduce thereto? surely preparations and fears of unworthy Receiving are one thing, and the wicked mans unworthy Receiving it self is another thing: The former may do much good, when the later is like to do much hurt. The thing that such fear, is, least they should have no saving part in Christ, or pardon, or eternal life, which you confess your pretended worthy Receiver hath not at all.
The 6. Argument is from experience: To which I answer; All the experiences which Mr. Blake mentioneth, are not only nothing for his cause, but abundantly destructive to it. Many have been unwakened by fears of receiving unworthily to their condemnation, as wicked men do: will it follow, that therefore they may receive it who are wicked and unworthy? or that there is no such danger to them if they do: Or rather that they should not receive while they are such, and that there is danger if they do; sure it is some danger that is the matter of their fear, & some threatning which is the ground: if it be their duy to receive it even while they know themselves to be wicked, because it is an appointed means to their conversion, what need they so to fear it, unless they fear the means of their own good? If they say, it is the unworthy receiving which they fear; Its true, but that is to receive it in state of wickedness, Impenitence and unbelief, as all the unregenerate do: surely it is the wrath of