A26886:803
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending…
Certain disputations of right to sacraments, and the true nature of visible Christianity defending them against several sorts of opponents, especially against the second assault of that pious, reverend and dear brother Mr. Thomas Blake / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Another Confutation that I am supposed to give my self, is cited by him. p. 148. thus [No Minister can groundedly administer ⟨p. 236⟩the Sacraments to any man but himself, because he can be certain of no mans justification, being not certain of the sincerity of their faith. And if he should adventure upon probabilities or charitable conjectures, then should he be guilty of profaning the Ordinance, and every time he mistaketh, he should set the Seal of God to a lye.] I confess there is nothing of mine that can be so plausibly objected to me as a Contradiction to the present assertion, as these last words: but yet there is no just ground for that objection, if I be rightly understood. These words are plainly bent against their opinion that make Election or saving Grace to be the Title to Sacraments which the Church must judge of, and that not by the Profession of the Claimer, but as distrusting his word upon other evidences of Grace, as discoveries of the time and manner of Conversion, or the practise of those Duties wherein a stricter profession is manifested, or the like. The men that I oppose hold these Assertions. 1. We must give the Sacrament to none but the godly in sincerity. 2. We must not believe a mans Verbal Profession, though not contradicted. 3. But we must require the visible proofs of his godliness. 4. At least such as make it probable to us that he is godly. To these men I answer, 1. That it is false that we must give the Sacraments to none but the truly godly: though its true that none else should require them. 2. That we must give them to those that profess saving faith, though they have it not: For it is the Foundation of all humane Converse that we give credit to mens words, when we have no just cause to dis-credit them, especially in matters out of our reach and within theirs, such as are the secrets of their own hearts: We must therefore take their Profession, unless it be contradicted by such palpable Evidences as Nullifieth it or maketh it invalid. 3. That we have no other grounds to proceed on but this: and that on their grounds, they must profane Gods Ordinance every time they mistake in the judgement of Charity, and apply it to ungodly men: But not so on ours, who must apply it to Professors.