A26892:3264
A Christian Directory
A Christian directory, or, A sum of practical theology and cases of conscience directing Christians how to use their knowledge and faith, how to improve all helps and means, and to perform all duties, how to overcome temptations, and to escape or mortify every sin : in four parts ... / by Richard Baxter.A Christian directory, or, A summ of practical theologie and cases of conscience directing Christians how to use their knowledge and faith, how to improve all helps and means, and to perform all duties, how to overcome temptations, and to escape or mortifie every sin : in four parts ... / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed by Robert White for Nevill Simmons, 1673
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Part 1 › Chapter 9 › Tit. 3. Special Directions against Lying and Dissembling.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. It is not a sin in all cases, to contribute towards another mans error or mistake. For,1 1. There are many cases in which it is no sin in him to mistake, nor any hurt to him: Therefore to contribute to that which is neither sin or hurt, is of it self no sin: yea, there are some cases in which an error (though not as such) may be a duty: As to think charitably and well of an hypocrite as long as he seemeth to be sincere. Here if by charitable reports I contribute to his mistake, it seemeth to be but my duty. For as he is bound to believe, so I am bound to report the best while it is probable. 2. There are many cases in which a mans ignorance or mistake may be his very great benefit: His life or estate may lye upon it: and I may know that if he understood such or such a thing, he would make use of it to his ruin. 3. There are many cases in which a mans (innocent) error is necessary to the safety of others, or of the Commonwealth. 4. It is lawful in such cases to deceive such men by Actions (as an Enemy by Military Stratagems, or a Traitor by signs which he will mistake.) And words of truth which we fore-know he will mistake (not by our fault, but by his own) do seem to be less questionable, than actions which have a proper tendency to deceive. 5. God himself hath written and spoken those words which he fore-knew that wicked men would mistake and deceive themselves by: and he hath done those works, and giveth those mercies which he knoweth they will turn to a snare against themselves. And his Dominion or Prerogative cannot here be pleaded to excuse it, if it were unholy. And in this sense (as to Permitting and Occasioning) it is said, Ezek. 14. 9. And if the Prophet be deceived, I the Lord have deceived that Prophet. Yet must we not think with Plato, that it is lawful to lye to an enemy to deceive him: For, 1. All deceit that is against Charity or Justice is sinful. 2. And all deceit that is performed by a lye. As Augustine saith, There are some lies which are spoken for another's safety or commodity, not in malice, but in benignity, as the Midwives to Pharaoh—These lies are not commended in themselves, but in the deceit (or charity) of them: They that thus lye will deserve (that is, be in the way) to be at last delivered from all lying: There is also a lying in jest, which deceiveth not; because he that it is spoken to, knoweth it to be spoken in jest:
Answ. It is not a sin in all cases, to contribute towards another mans error or mistake. For,