§. 13. Quest. But will every change disoblige us? If not, what change must it be? seeing Casuists 1use to put it as a condition in general, Rebus sic stantibus. Answ. No: it is not every change of2 things that disobligeth us from the bonds of a Vow. For then Vows were of no considerable signification. But, 1. If the very Matter that was Vowed, or about which the Vow was, do cease, Cessante materiâ cessat obligatio: As if I promise to teach a pupil, I am disobliged when he is dead. If I promise to pay so much money in Gold, and the King should •orbid Gold and change his coin, I am not obliged to it. 2. Cessante termino vel correlato cessat obligatio: If the party dye to whom I am bound, my personal obligation ceaseth. And so the conjugal bond ceaseth at death, and civil bonds by civil death. 3. Cessante fine, cessat obligatio. If the use and end wholly cease my obligation which was only to that use and end ceaseth. As if a Physician promise to give Physic for nothing for the cure of the Plague, to all the poor of the City; when the Plague ceaseth, his end, and so his obligation ceaseth. 4. Cessante personâ naturali rela•â cessat obligatio personalis. When the natural person dyeth, the obligation ceaseth. I cannot be obliged to do that when I am dead which is proper to the living. The subject of the obligation ceasing, the Accidents must cease. 5. Cessante relatione vel personâ civili, cessat obligatio talis, quâ t•lis: The obligation which lay on a person in any Relation merely as such, doth cease when that Relation ceaseth. A King is not bound to Govern or protect his subjects if they traitorously depose him, or if he cast them off and take another Kingdom (as when H. 3. of France left the Kingdom of Poland); nor are subjects bound to Allegiance and obedience to him that is not indeed their King: A Judge, or Justice, or Constable, or Tutor, is no longer bound by his oath to do the offices of these Relations, than he continueth in the Relation: A divorced Wife is not bound by her conjugal vow to her Husband as before: nor masters and servants when their relations cease: nor a Soldier to his General by his military Sacrament when the Army is disbanded, or he is cashiered or dismissed.3
§. 13. Quest. But will every change disoblige us? If not, what change must it be? seeing Casuists 1use to put it as a condition in general, Rebus sic stantibus. Answ. No: it is not every change of2 things that disobligeth us from the bonds of a Vow. For then Vows were of no considerable signification. But, 1. If the very Matter that was Vowed, or about which the Vow was, do cease, Cessante materiâ cessat obligatio: As if I promise to teach a pupil, I am disobliged when he is dead. If I promise to pay so much money in Gold, and the King should •orbid Gold and change his coyne, I am not obliged to it. 2. Cessante termino vel correlato cessat obligatio: If the party dye to whom I am bound, my personal obligation ceaseth. And so the conjugal bond ceaseth at death, and civil bonds by civil death. 3. Cessante fine, cessat obligatio. If the use and end wholly cease my obligation which was only to that use and end ceaseth. As if a Physicion promise to give Physick for nothing for the cure of the Plague, to all the poor of the City; when the Plague ceaseth, his end, and so his obligation ceaseth. 4. Cessante personâ naturali rela•â cessat obligatio personalis. When the natural person dyeth, the obligation ceaseth. I cannot be •bliged to do that when I am dead which is proper to the living. The subject of the obligation ceasing, the Accidents must cease. 5. Cessante relatione vel personâ civili, cessat obligatio talis, quâ t•lis: The obligation which lay on a person in any Relation meerly as such, doth cease when that Relation ceaseth. A King is not bound to Govern or protect his subjects if they trayterously depose him, or if he cast them off and take anothor Kingdom (as when H. 3. of France left the Kingdom of P•land); nor are subjects bound to Allegiance and obedience to him that is not indeed their King: A Judge, or Justice, or Constable, or Tutor, is no longer bound by his oath to do the offices of these Relations, than he continueth in the Relation: A divorced Wife is not bound by her conjugal vow to her Husband as before: nor masters and servants when their relations cease: nor a Souldier to his General by his military Sacrament when the Army is disbanded, or he is cashiered or dismist.3
- 1Answ.
- 2Cicero d• I•g. lib. 1. Proveth that Right is founded in the La• of Nature, m•re than in mans Laws: else, saith •e, men may make evil good and good evil, and make Ad•l••ry. Perjur•, &•. just b[…]g a Law for them.Cicero d• I•g. lib. 1. Proveth that Right is founded in the La• of Nature, m•re than in mans Laws: else, saith •e, men may make evil good and good evil, and make Ad•l••ry. Perjur•, &•. just b〈…〉g a Law for them.
- 3Rule 3.