The commonest doubt is, Whether an error about the very person that I swear to, and this caused by 1his own deceit do disoblige me? All grant that I am obliged notwithstanding any circumstantial 2error, (as if I think a Woman rich whom I marry, and she prove poor, or wise and godly and she prove foolish or ungodly: yea if the error be about any integral part: as if I think she had two eyes or legs, and she have but one:) And all grant that an error about an essential part, that is, which is essential to the Relation or thing Vowed, (if inculpable at least) disobligeth: As if I took a man in marriage thinking he had been a woman! Or if I took a person for a Pastor, a Physician, a Counsellor, a Pilot, that hath no tolerable ability or skill in the essentials of any of those professions. But whether I am bound if I swear to Thomas thinking it was John, or if I marry Leah thinking she is Rachel, is the great doubt. And most Casuists say I am not: And therefore I dare not3 be bold to contradict them. But I much suspect that they fetched their decision from the Lawyers▪ who truly say, that in foro civili it inferreth no obligation: But whether it do not oblige me Ethically 4and in foro conscientiae & coeli I much doubt, 1. Because it seemeth the very case of Joshua and the Israelites, who by the guile of the Gibeonites were deceived into an error personarum, taking them to5 be other persons than they were: And yet that this oath was Obligatory saith Dr. Sanderson is apparent, 1. In the text it self, Josh. 9. 19. 2. In the miracle wrought for that victory which Joshua obtained in defending the Gibeonites, when the Sun stood still, Josh. 10. 8, 13. 3. In the severe revenge that was taken on the lives of Sauls posterity for offering to violate it, 2 Sam. 21. 2. And this seemeth to be the very case of Jacob who took not himself disobliged from Leah notwithstanding the mistake of the person through deceit. And though the Concubitus was added to the contract, that obliged most as it was the perfecting of the Contract, which an Oath doth as strongly. 3. And the nature of the thing doth confirm my doubt; because when I see the person before me there is the individuum determinatum, in the haec hom•, and so all that is essential to my Vow is included in it:
The commonest doubt is, Whether an errour about the very person that I swear to, and this caused by 1his own deceit do disoblige me? All grant that I am obliged notwithstanding any circumstantial 2errour, (as if I think a Woman rich whom I marry, and she prove poor, or wise and godly and she prove foolish or ungodly: yea if the errour be about any integral part: as if I think she had two eyes or legs, and she have but one:) And all grant that an errour about an essential part, that is, which is essential to the Relation or thing Vowed, (if inculpable at least) disobligeth: As if I took a man in marriage thinking he had been a woman! Or if I took a person for a Pastor, a Physicion, a Councellour, a Pilote, that hath no tolerable ability or skill in the essentials of any of those professions. But whether I am bound if I swear to Thomas thinking it was Iohn, or if I marry Leah thinking she is Rachel, is the great doubt. And most Casuists say I am not: And therefore I dare not3 be bold to contradict them. But I much suspect that they fetcht their decision from the Lawyers▪ who truly say, that in foro civili it inferreth no obligation: But whether it do not oblige me Ethically 4and in foro conscientiae & coeli I much doubt, 1. Because it seemeth the very case of Ioshua and the Israelites, who by the guile of the Gibeonites were deceived into an error personarum, taking them to5 be other persons than they were: And yet that this oath was Obligatory saith Dr. Sanderson is apparent, 1. In the text it self, Iosh. 9. 19. 2. In the miracle wrought for that victory which Ioshua obtained in defending the Gibeonites, when the Sun stood still, Iosh. 10. 8, 13. 3. In the severe revenge that was taken on the lives of Sauls posterity for offering to violate it, 2 Sam. 21. 2. And this seemeth to be the very case of Iacob who took not himself disobliged from Leah notwithstanding the mistake of the person through deceit. And though the Concubitus was added to the contract, that obliged most as it was the perfecting of the Contract, which an Oath doth as strongly. 3. And the nature of the thing doth confirm my doubt; because when I see the person before me there is the individuum determinatum, in the haec hom, and so all that is essential to my Vow is included in it:
- 1Quest.
- 2Answ.
- 3Sanders. p. 122.
- 4Sanders. p. 120, 121.
- 5This seemeth the case of Isaac in blessing Jacob: The error personae caused by Jacobs own deceit did not nullify the blessing, because it was fixed on the determinate person that it was spoken to.This seemeth the case of Isaac in blessing Iacob: The error personae caused by Iacobs own deceit did not nullifie the blessing, because it was fixed on the determinate person that it was spoken to.